How can an advanced civilization forget how to manufacture its technology?Planetary colonization by a female crewCan hive-based aliens develop advanced technology without telepathy?How could an advanced civilization have no more than a basic knowledge of biology?Advanced Technology in a Fireless World?How can advanced aliens overclock our Sun?How advanced could a civilization controlled by small children become?Would advanced civilization without religion do well?How advanced technology is needed to create a duct tape?How can society advance as a civilization if it kills off its best people?How can I ensure that advanced technology remains in the hands of the superhero community?

Does throwing a penny at a train stop the train?

ESTA: "Is your travel to the US occurring in transit to another country?" when going on a cruise

Get ids only where one id is null and other isn't

Machine learning and operations research projects

Why isn't there research to build a standard lunar, or Martian mobility platform?

Keep milk (or milk alternative) for a day without a fridge

I received a dinner invitation through my employer's email. Is it OK to attend?

What would be the ideal melee weapon made of "Phase Metal"?

Setting MAC field to all-zero to indicate unencrypted data

Why are they 'nude photos'?

Is there any word for "disobedience to God"?

How did the hit man miss?

Cops: The Hidden OEIS Substring

What does "it kind of works out" mean?

Who has taken "my" Managed package namespace? Can we find out?

Is there a word for a message that is intended to be intercepted by an adversary?

What species of wasp is this? And how to get rid of them?

How to find the shape parameters of of a beta distribution given the position of two quantiles?

Novel where a group of scientists in a spaceship encounter various aliens

What are the bumps on the Vega rocket

Was lunar module "pilot" Harrison Schmitt legally a "pilot" at the time?

What's the maximum time an interrupt service routine can take to execute on atmega328p?

Are unclear "take-it or leave-it" contracts interpreted in my favor?

Professor falsely accusing me of cheating in a class he does not teach, two months after end of the class. What precautions should I take?



How can an advanced civilization forget how to manufacture its technology?


Planetary colonization by a female crewCan hive-based aliens develop advanced technology without telepathy?How could an advanced civilization have no more than a basic knowledge of biology?Advanced Technology in a Fireless World?How can advanced aliens overclock our Sun?How advanced could a civilization controlled by small children become?Would advanced civilization without religion do well?How advanced technology is needed to create a duct tape?How can society advance as a civilization if it kills off its best people?How can I ensure that advanced technology remains in the hands of the superhero community?






.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty margin-bottom:0;








4












$begingroup$


My alien civilization is highly advanced. Their ancestors created wondrous things from medical devices that can cure nearly anything to warships that can defeat nearly any enemy.



The problem is they have forgotten how these things were created. They have all lasted for centuries, their inventors long dead, and the current inhabitants can only barely maintain them, and usually with patchwork and improvised solutions that are making the tech less and less effective.



How could a civilization get to the point where they have forgotten the secrets to their own technology?



Edit: (Thanks Morris) This would be as if modern society lost the knowledge on how to create the microchip, or the internal combustion engine, but the items were so durable, it was centuries before they started to break down



Edit 2: I'm not thinking of the obvious, like disaster, war, or a crisis that would have caused sudden loss.










share|improve this question











$endgroup$











  • $begingroup$
    Just to be clear, we're not talking about individual technologies here, we're talking about a system loss of understanding of the entire basis of their technological infrastructure across the entire civilization? As if modern humans lost the understanding of electronics and internal combustion?
    $endgroup$
    – Morris The Cat
    9 hours ago






  • 1




    $begingroup$
    Have you ever heard of the Middle Ages? In short, a century long economic crisis combined with civil strife and unrest, followed by barbarian invasions, followed by a devastating plague... and you have to pick up the broken pieces. For example, the Portland vase is a very beautiful artifact made in the Roman Empire at the beginning of the 1st century CE. Only recently have a modern artisans, e.g. Rosemarie Lierke, developed a possible efficient manufacturing methology -- until recently it was thought that making such a vase would take years...
    $endgroup$
    – AlexP
    9 hours ago







  • 3




    $begingroup$
    @AlexP we forgot how to make concrete for almost two thousand years, and we STILL can't make it as well as the Romans did.
    $endgroup$
    – Morris The Cat
    9 hours ago






  • 2




    $begingroup$
    @RichardU yeah, we've had that happen multiple times. Or rather with multiple topics but mostly around the same time - the Dark Ages. Although if we look at today, we have people who forgot that vaccinations work or that the world is round. The latter of which was figured out way back by the ancient Greeks and yet today people dispute it.
    $endgroup$
    – VLAZ
    8 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    Ah, I started typing up my answer before your Edit #2. I'll leave my answer in case you can get some use out of it.
    $endgroup$
    – Nex Terren
    8 hours ago

















4












$begingroup$


My alien civilization is highly advanced. Their ancestors created wondrous things from medical devices that can cure nearly anything to warships that can defeat nearly any enemy.



The problem is they have forgotten how these things were created. They have all lasted for centuries, their inventors long dead, and the current inhabitants can only barely maintain them, and usually with patchwork and improvised solutions that are making the tech less and less effective.



How could a civilization get to the point where they have forgotten the secrets to their own technology?



Edit: (Thanks Morris) This would be as if modern society lost the knowledge on how to create the microchip, or the internal combustion engine, but the items were so durable, it was centuries before they started to break down



Edit 2: I'm not thinking of the obvious, like disaster, war, or a crisis that would have caused sudden loss.










share|improve this question











$endgroup$











  • $begingroup$
    Just to be clear, we're not talking about individual technologies here, we're talking about a system loss of understanding of the entire basis of their technological infrastructure across the entire civilization? As if modern humans lost the understanding of electronics and internal combustion?
    $endgroup$
    – Morris The Cat
    9 hours ago






  • 1




    $begingroup$
    Have you ever heard of the Middle Ages? In short, a century long economic crisis combined with civil strife and unrest, followed by barbarian invasions, followed by a devastating plague... and you have to pick up the broken pieces. For example, the Portland vase is a very beautiful artifact made in the Roman Empire at the beginning of the 1st century CE. Only recently have a modern artisans, e.g. Rosemarie Lierke, developed a possible efficient manufacturing methology -- until recently it was thought that making such a vase would take years...
    $endgroup$
    – AlexP
    9 hours ago







  • 3




    $begingroup$
    @AlexP we forgot how to make concrete for almost two thousand years, and we STILL can't make it as well as the Romans did.
    $endgroup$
    – Morris The Cat
    9 hours ago






  • 2




    $begingroup$
    @RichardU yeah, we've had that happen multiple times. Or rather with multiple topics but mostly around the same time - the Dark Ages. Although if we look at today, we have people who forgot that vaccinations work or that the world is round. The latter of which was figured out way back by the ancient Greeks and yet today people dispute it.
    $endgroup$
    – VLAZ
    8 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    Ah, I started typing up my answer before your Edit #2. I'll leave my answer in case you can get some use out of it.
    $endgroup$
    – Nex Terren
    8 hours ago













4












4








4


1



$begingroup$


My alien civilization is highly advanced. Their ancestors created wondrous things from medical devices that can cure nearly anything to warships that can defeat nearly any enemy.



The problem is they have forgotten how these things were created. They have all lasted for centuries, their inventors long dead, and the current inhabitants can only barely maintain them, and usually with patchwork and improvised solutions that are making the tech less and less effective.



How could a civilization get to the point where they have forgotten the secrets to their own technology?



Edit: (Thanks Morris) This would be as if modern society lost the knowledge on how to create the microchip, or the internal combustion engine, but the items were so durable, it was centuries before they started to break down



Edit 2: I'm not thinking of the obvious, like disaster, war, or a crisis that would have caused sudden loss.










share|improve this question











$endgroup$




My alien civilization is highly advanced. Their ancestors created wondrous things from medical devices that can cure nearly anything to warships that can defeat nearly any enemy.



The problem is they have forgotten how these things were created. They have all lasted for centuries, their inventors long dead, and the current inhabitants can only barely maintain them, and usually with patchwork and improvised solutions that are making the tech less and less effective.



How could a civilization get to the point where they have forgotten the secrets to their own technology?



Edit: (Thanks Morris) This would be as if modern society lost the knowledge on how to create the microchip, or the internal combustion engine, but the items were so durable, it was centuries before they started to break down



Edit 2: I'm not thinking of the obvious, like disaster, war, or a crisis that would have caused sudden loss.







society technology






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited 8 hours ago









Brythan

22.7k9 gold badges45 silver badges89 bronze badges




22.7k9 gold badges45 silver badges89 bronze badges










asked 9 hours ago









Richard URichard U

6,11012 silver badges33 bronze badges




6,11012 silver badges33 bronze badges











  • $begingroup$
    Just to be clear, we're not talking about individual technologies here, we're talking about a system loss of understanding of the entire basis of their technological infrastructure across the entire civilization? As if modern humans lost the understanding of electronics and internal combustion?
    $endgroup$
    – Morris The Cat
    9 hours ago






  • 1




    $begingroup$
    Have you ever heard of the Middle Ages? In short, a century long economic crisis combined with civil strife and unrest, followed by barbarian invasions, followed by a devastating plague... and you have to pick up the broken pieces. For example, the Portland vase is a very beautiful artifact made in the Roman Empire at the beginning of the 1st century CE. Only recently have a modern artisans, e.g. Rosemarie Lierke, developed a possible efficient manufacturing methology -- until recently it was thought that making such a vase would take years...
    $endgroup$
    – AlexP
    9 hours ago







  • 3




    $begingroup$
    @AlexP we forgot how to make concrete for almost two thousand years, and we STILL can't make it as well as the Romans did.
    $endgroup$
    – Morris The Cat
    9 hours ago






  • 2




    $begingroup$
    @RichardU yeah, we've had that happen multiple times. Or rather with multiple topics but mostly around the same time - the Dark Ages. Although if we look at today, we have people who forgot that vaccinations work or that the world is round. The latter of which was figured out way back by the ancient Greeks and yet today people dispute it.
    $endgroup$
    – VLAZ
    8 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    Ah, I started typing up my answer before your Edit #2. I'll leave my answer in case you can get some use out of it.
    $endgroup$
    – Nex Terren
    8 hours ago
















  • $begingroup$
    Just to be clear, we're not talking about individual technologies here, we're talking about a system loss of understanding of the entire basis of their technological infrastructure across the entire civilization? As if modern humans lost the understanding of electronics and internal combustion?
    $endgroup$
    – Morris The Cat
    9 hours ago






  • 1




    $begingroup$
    Have you ever heard of the Middle Ages? In short, a century long economic crisis combined with civil strife and unrest, followed by barbarian invasions, followed by a devastating plague... and you have to pick up the broken pieces. For example, the Portland vase is a very beautiful artifact made in the Roman Empire at the beginning of the 1st century CE. Only recently have a modern artisans, e.g. Rosemarie Lierke, developed a possible efficient manufacturing methology -- until recently it was thought that making such a vase would take years...
    $endgroup$
    – AlexP
    9 hours ago







  • 3




    $begingroup$
    @AlexP we forgot how to make concrete for almost two thousand years, and we STILL can't make it as well as the Romans did.
    $endgroup$
    – Morris The Cat
    9 hours ago






  • 2




    $begingroup$
    @RichardU yeah, we've had that happen multiple times. Or rather with multiple topics but mostly around the same time - the Dark Ages. Although if we look at today, we have people who forgot that vaccinations work or that the world is round. The latter of which was figured out way back by the ancient Greeks and yet today people dispute it.
    $endgroup$
    – VLAZ
    8 hours ago










  • $begingroup$
    Ah, I started typing up my answer before your Edit #2. I'll leave my answer in case you can get some use out of it.
    $endgroup$
    – Nex Terren
    8 hours ago















$begingroup$
Just to be clear, we're not talking about individual technologies here, we're talking about a system loss of understanding of the entire basis of their technological infrastructure across the entire civilization? As if modern humans lost the understanding of electronics and internal combustion?
$endgroup$
– Morris The Cat
9 hours ago




$begingroup$
Just to be clear, we're not talking about individual technologies here, we're talking about a system loss of understanding of the entire basis of their technological infrastructure across the entire civilization? As if modern humans lost the understanding of electronics and internal combustion?
$endgroup$
– Morris The Cat
9 hours ago




1




1




$begingroup$
Have you ever heard of the Middle Ages? In short, a century long economic crisis combined with civil strife and unrest, followed by barbarian invasions, followed by a devastating plague... and you have to pick up the broken pieces. For example, the Portland vase is a very beautiful artifact made in the Roman Empire at the beginning of the 1st century CE. Only recently have a modern artisans, e.g. Rosemarie Lierke, developed a possible efficient manufacturing methology -- until recently it was thought that making such a vase would take years...
$endgroup$
– AlexP
9 hours ago





$begingroup$
Have you ever heard of the Middle Ages? In short, a century long economic crisis combined with civil strife and unrest, followed by barbarian invasions, followed by a devastating plague... and you have to pick up the broken pieces. For example, the Portland vase is a very beautiful artifact made in the Roman Empire at the beginning of the 1st century CE. Only recently have a modern artisans, e.g. Rosemarie Lierke, developed a possible efficient manufacturing methology -- until recently it was thought that making such a vase would take years...
$endgroup$
– AlexP
9 hours ago





3




3




$begingroup$
@AlexP we forgot how to make concrete for almost two thousand years, and we STILL can't make it as well as the Romans did.
$endgroup$
– Morris The Cat
9 hours ago




$begingroup$
@AlexP we forgot how to make concrete for almost two thousand years, and we STILL can't make it as well as the Romans did.
$endgroup$
– Morris The Cat
9 hours ago




2




2




$begingroup$
@RichardU yeah, we've had that happen multiple times. Or rather with multiple topics but mostly around the same time - the Dark Ages. Although if we look at today, we have people who forgot that vaccinations work or that the world is round. The latter of which was figured out way back by the ancient Greeks and yet today people dispute it.
$endgroup$
– VLAZ
8 hours ago




$begingroup$
@RichardU yeah, we've had that happen multiple times. Or rather with multiple topics but mostly around the same time - the Dark Ages. Although if we look at today, we have people who forgot that vaccinations work or that the world is round. The latter of which was figured out way back by the ancient Greeks and yet today people dispute it.
$endgroup$
– VLAZ
8 hours ago












$begingroup$
Ah, I started typing up my answer before your Edit #2. I'll leave my answer in case you can get some use out of it.
$endgroup$
– Nex Terren
8 hours ago




$begingroup$
Ah, I started typing up my answer before your Edit #2. I'll leave my answer in case you can get some use out of it.
$endgroup$
– Nex Terren
8 hours ago










7 Answers
7






active

oldest

votes


















5












$begingroup$

The Holy Order of Engineers



You can take this more or less literal (keep the religious aspect or divorce this answer from it), but either way it works.



Due to an internal power struggle long ago (that possibly developed into a civil war that was stamped out), the Powers That Be determined that equipping the masses with the understanding of how to build or develop weapons of war or other technology that could be leveraged militarily, economically, or politically were dangerous to have in the hands of the masses.



And so the Holy Order of Engineers was created. This very closed-mouth and tightly-knit organization was given authority and charge over all higher learning, research, and development that possibly could relate to engineering or R&D, or in many cases, the actual manufacturing (for the technological crown jewels). The Followers of Engineering Ongoing was founded as a sister organization to the Order that was taught how to maintain infrastructure. The Followers were overseen and governed at arm's length by the Order as while the Followers were less dangerous than the Order, they still had the potential of arming the masses with easily exploitable technology. The Order dispatches Inquisitors routinely not only to weed out engineering from the masses, but to check in on the Followers to ensure that anyone too intelligent, creative, ambitious, or otherwise on the path of engineering was either recruited or put to the sword (or mag rail gun, as the case may be) and made an example of.



And in this manner your civilization continued for quite some time. Centuries perhaps.



But like all great things this came to an end. The governing authorities grew to not trust the Order and their ever increasing influence, or perhaps the Order grew too proud and attempted to rebel. Either way, while the Order understood amazing technologies, they lacked the infrastructure and manpower to defend them. It wasn't long before the Order was all but stamped out, and the last few members of the Order followed their holy code to protect their archives from the masses, and deleted or burned them all. (If in the modern era, the Order probably had designed a magnificent virus that was able to crawl through all their servers and scramble the data irreversibly)



The last few members of the Order defected and were folded into the Followers, however these measly few weren't enough to provide understanding of these incredibly advanced technologies besides the insight to deal with perhaps more advanced troubleshooting, and even then not in all cases.



And so your civilization limps along, possessing the marvelous technology of the Order, but none of its understanding.






share|improve this answer











$endgroup$








  • 1




    $begingroup$
    This is brilliant, THANK YOU!
    $endgroup$
    – Richard U
    8 hours ago


















4












$begingroup$

Consider how far removed, for example, Shakespearean English is from the English we speak today. That's a mere 400 years of linguistic evolution. Now imagine that Shakespeare wrote a technical manual.



The language of the forebearers has fallen out of use. No one alive today speaks the ancient tongue. The forebearers left detailed instructions on how to replicate their great machines, but linguistic scholars have tried and failed to make sense of the text.



Since the machines never needed to be replaced (until now), the study and advancement of engineering ceased long ago. Apprentices abandoned the field for newer, more exciting opportunities and the knowledge was never passed down.






share|improve this answer









$endgroup$












  • $begingroup$
    Another great idea! You guys are brilliant!
    $endgroup$
    – Richard U
    8 hours ago


















3












$begingroup$

Their toolset became more and more sophisticated. Their universities and trade schools paid lip service to starting from first principles, but that got more and more perfunctory.



For a comparison, take modern software development. Many programmers can do java, or javascript, but people who can really write machine code are a tiny minority.



I've met young programmers who couldn't explain what a bubblesort is, and why it is usually inferior to quicksort, but superior in a few cases.



So expand this into the future. There are plenty of people who can build starships if they have a functioning nanofactory. There are some who can build a nanofactory with nanofac assembly tools. But the people who can build the tools to build the tools to build the tools get fewer and fewer, until their number gets too low.






share|improve this answer









$endgroup$




















    2












    $begingroup$

    Secrecy



    If your technology is a trade secret, then only a few select people are allowed to know exactly how it's done. In fact, it may be complex enough that some people know how to make some parts of the whole, but no one person knows all the secrets necessary to get from raw ingredients to finished product.



    The formula for Coca-Cola is an example.




    According to the company, only two employees are privy to the complete
    formula at any given time and they are not permitted to travel
    together. When one dies, the other must choose a successor within the
    company and impart the secret to that person. The identity of the two
    employees in possession of the secret is itself a secret.




    It is theoretically possible that some massive disaster could wipe out both people at once, dooming the full formula. Assuming it's not written down in some bank vault or something.



    Greek Fire is another example of a trade secret that was lost to time.



    Any time there is a thing known to only a few people, that lack of redundancy makes it more likely that the knowledge is lost to time.



    State Collapse



    When Rome fell, Europe lost a great deal of technology. Roman roads, Roman sewer, aqueduct, and other architectural systems were all lost for centuries. During an empire collapse, people stop worrying about major projects or passing down critical but complex skills. Their focus shifts to survival: food, safety, shelter. Everything else becomes "we'll worry about that later," but if the collapse spans a generation, then later becomes centuries. We didn't surpass Roman roads until the 19th century. Rome had better roads between cities at 10 CE than Washington DC had, inside the city, in 1865 CE.



    Political/Religious Censorship



    If a political, religious, or combined power takes control, they may ban entire segments of technology outright. Galileo Galilei faced censorship for his works on heliocentrism, for example. Those parts of modern technology that involve mass communication or the internet are largely banned in despotic regimes like North Korea.



    If a society is never allowed to study, learn, expand, or pass down knowledge of a technology, then it will quickly be lost to those people.



    Poor or No Documentation



    Perhaps the technology is poorly documented or only verbally documented. If all the details are written on paper or papyrus and there aren't enough copies that survive, then the knowledge is lost. Or if all of your critical texts on the subject are digital and there's a massive EMP or other catastrophe that destroys your computers, then that knowledge is gone. Perhaps your survivors can restore some of the knowledge from memory, if they survive and if they can remember enough to matter. But probably not all of it and not in all cases.



    What separates this from Secrecy, above, is the intent. Secrecy implies a desire to prevent outsiders from learning a skill. Poor Documentation is less about preventing the spread of knowledge and more about the inability to spread that knowledge.



    Examples of this include many of the ancient monument sites like Stonehenge, where we know it existed, but we simply don't understand all of the reasons why and/or the methods how they were built. Was the construction considered a secret or perhaps a state collapse? Maybe, maybe not. But the lack of permanent record clouds the knowledge, certainly.



    Natural Disaster



    If all of your knowledge of a specific technology is housed in one geographic location, then a major disaster could destroy all of it. An earthquake or fire could destroy a building, losing everything (and even everyone) it contains. This is less likely to be a sole reason than the above. More likely is that this is the flashpoint that destroys a technology because of the limits placed on it by the above reasons. Secrecy forces a lack of redundancy that then leaves it vulnerable to an earthquake, for example.



    Combination



    Probably, many technologies that become lost over time will be lost through a combination of things, not just any one thing. We do not know exactly how the Egyptian Pyramids were built. Is that because the engineers were lost during the fall of the Egyptian empire? Or because there were so few engineers? It is difficult to be sure, but probably a combination of secrecy, documentation, and state collapse combined to cause the loss.



    Or maybe a natural disaster triggers a state collapse. Or Secrecy and/or religious/state censorship combined with a natural disaster destroy all the holders of your knowledge...






    share|improve this answer









    $endgroup$




















      1












      $begingroup$

      So, the simplest answer is a confluence of two factors.



      First: A technological 'plateau'.



      Your society reached a point where further refinement of the basic fundamentals of their technology came to a halt due to diminishing returns on development. A good example of this is the widespread stagnation of military technology during the interwar periods prior to WW1 and WW2. Nobody cared enough about improving things to bother trying to figure out HOW. A more modern hypothetical example would be the point at which the technology required for a smartphone gets so small and efficient that there's no practical benefit in improving it anymore.



      Basically, in the absence of new frontiers (either physical or technological), your society loses the incentive to innovate, which means most of the citizens of your civilization have no reason to learn how any of their stuff works, because that information just isn't useful.



      Second: Massive automation of manufacturing.



      Continuing on the theme above, the only two reasons the living members of your civilization would have to learn how their technology works is either to improve it, repair it, or build more of it. We addressed item one in the first section, this section addresses the other two. In the absence of any need to continually retool their manufacturing to accommodate new advancements, your civilization would naturally tend more and more towards automation of their factories. You put raw materials in, finished goods come out the other side. You have robots to build the goods, you have other robots to repair THOSE robots when they break down. You have MORE robots to repair anything ELSE that breaks.



      Over time the living members of your civilization who actually know how any of this works become fewer and fewer because their contribution has little or no benefit. Eventually the last living member who understood how to build or repair any of the robots dies, and nobody notices because the robots are doing just fine keeping themselves in working order.



      This state of affairs could persist for a LONG time without any problems, until civil unrest or disruption of the supply chain of raw materials caused things to start breaking down, and by that point there would be nobody left who knew how to repair or rebuild them.






      share|improve this answer









      $endgroup$




















        1












        $begingroup$

        One possible solution is having a wide spread very basic technology that suddenly isn't viable anymore.



        Say, for instance, this alien society had discovered a room temperature superconductor. It would be used for all wiring in everything, because the ability to not lose power to heat from resistance. But if some fungus/organism developed that could eat or corrode the superconductor, and was spread far and wide before anyone noticed what was happening, or how bad the problem was, then it could cripple all technology that the civilization uses, from power delivery to microprocessors. *



        You'd have some people who could figure out how to jerry rig solutions, assuming they could find other conductors, but these people would likely be rare, and located in places with high population density, meaning less food to go around, and all the chaos that implies.



        Just about any technology that most other technology relies on would work.



        * This is a sub plot in the book Ringworld by Larry Niven.






        share|improve this answer









        $endgroup$




















          0












          $begingroup$

          The "death" of AI rulers.



          enter image description here



          Their civilization built powerful artificial minds, for thousands of years those mostly benevolent Minds controlled their civilization, ran their factories, invented their medicines, built their spaceships and designed their devices.



          They built things to last and built everything with a lot of failsafes and fallbacks.



          But eventually there was a brief and almost silent civil war between the Minds. During that war a host of computer viruses designed to target Artificial Minds were released by both sides through the civilizations networks and infrastructure.



          One day the citizens of the civilization woke up to find their rulers dead



          Their queries addressed to the ruling minds unanswered and everything was left in failsafe mode.



          They tried to build replacement Minds... but everything in their civilization is suffused with computer viruses designed to find and kill such AI's.



          So they found themselves surrounded by devices that mostly still worked, even many factories to produce things.



          But the Minds had never explained how the Magitech really worked, perhaps it was simply beyond the comprehension of normal organic minds.



          So now they hobble along, flying ships they don't really understand, using devices they may not be able to reproduce.






          share|improve this answer









          $endgroup$















            Your Answer








            StackExchange.ready(function()
            var channelOptions =
            tags: "".split(" "),
            id: "579"
            ;
            initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

            StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
            // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
            if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
            StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
            createEditor();
            );

            else
            createEditor();

            );

            function createEditor()
            StackExchange.prepareEditor(
            heartbeatType: 'answer',
            autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
            convertImagesToLinks: false,
            noModals: true,
            showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
            reputationToPostImages: null,
            bindNavPrevention: true,
            postfix: "",
            imageUploader:
            brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
            contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
            allowUrls: true
            ,
            noCode: true, onDemand: true,
            discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
            ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
            );



            );













            draft saved

            draft discarded


















            StackExchange.ready(
            function ()
            StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fworldbuilding.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f150663%2fhow-can-an-advanced-civilization-forget-how-to-manufacture-its-technology%23new-answer', 'question_page');

            );

            Post as a guest















            Required, but never shown

























            7 Answers
            7






            active

            oldest

            votes








            7 Answers
            7






            active

            oldest

            votes









            active

            oldest

            votes






            active

            oldest

            votes









            5












            $begingroup$

            The Holy Order of Engineers



            You can take this more or less literal (keep the religious aspect or divorce this answer from it), but either way it works.



            Due to an internal power struggle long ago (that possibly developed into a civil war that was stamped out), the Powers That Be determined that equipping the masses with the understanding of how to build or develop weapons of war or other technology that could be leveraged militarily, economically, or politically were dangerous to have in the hands of the masses.



            And so the Holy Order of Engineers was created. This very closed-mouth and tightly-knit organization was given authority and charge over all higher learning, research, and development that possibly could relate to engineering or R&D, or in many cases, the actual manufacturing (for the technological crown jewels). The Followers of Engineering Ongoing was founded as a sister organization to the Order that was taught how to maintain infrastructure. The Followers were overseen and governed at arm's length by the Order as while the Followers were less dangerous than the Order, they still had the potential of arming the masses with easily exploitable technology. The Order dispatches Inquisitors routinely not only to weed out engineering from the masses, but to check in on the Followers to ensure that anyone too intelligent, creative, ambitious, or otherwise on the path of engineering was either recruited or put to the sword (or mag rail gun, as the case may be) and made an example of.



            And in this manner your civilization continued for quite some time. Centuries perhaps.



            But like all great things this came to an end. The governing authorities grew to not trust the Order and their ever increasing influence, or perhaps the Order grew too proud and attempted to rebel. Either way, while the Order understood amazing technologies, they lacked the infrastructure and manpower to defend them. It wasn't long before the Order was all but stamped out, and the last few members of the Order followed their holy code to protect their archives from the masses, and deleted or burned them all. (If in the modern era, the Order probably had designed a magnificent virus that was able to crawl through all their servers and scramble the data irreversibly)



            The last few members of the Order defected and were folded into the Followers, however these measly few weren't enough to provide understanding of these incredibly advanced technologies besides the insight to deal with perhaps more advanced troubleshooting, and even then not in all cases.



            And so your civilization limps along, possessing the marvelous technology of the Order, but none of its understanding.






            share|improve this answer











            $endgroup$








            • 1




              $begingroup$
              This is brilliant, THANK YOU!
              $endgroup$
              – Richard U
              8 hours ago















            5












            $begingroup$

            The Holy Order of Engineers



            You can take this more or less literal (keep the religious aspect or divorce this answer from it), but either way it works.



            Due to an internal power struggle long ago (that possibly developed into a civil war that was stamped out), the Powers That Be determined that equipping the masses with the understanding of how to build or develop weapons of war or other technology that could be leveraged militarily, economically, or politically were dangerous to have in the hands of the masses.



            And so the Holy Order of Engineers was created. This very closed-mouth and tightly-knit organization was given authority and charge over all higher learning, research, and development that possibly could relate to engineering or R&D, or in many cases, the actual manufacturing (for the technological crown jewels). The Followers of Engineering Ongoing was founded as a sister organization to the Order that was taught how to maintain infrastructure. The Followers were overseen and governed at arm's length by the Order as while the Followers were less dangerous than the Order, they still had the potential of arming the masses with easily exploitable technology. The Order dispatches Inquisitors routinely not only to weed out engineering from the masses, but to check in on the Followers to ensure that anyone too intelligent, creative, ambitious, or otherwise on the path of engineering was either recruited or put to the sword (or mag rail gun, as the case may be) and made an example of.



            And in this manner your civilization continued for quite some time. Centuries perhaps.



            But like all great things this came to an end. The governing authorities grew to not trust the Order and their ever increasing influence, or perhaps the Order grew too proud and attempted to rebel. Either way, while the Order understood amazing technologies, they lacked the infrastructure and manpower to defend them. It wasn't long before the Order was all but stamped out, and the last few members of the Order followed their holy code to protect their archives from the masses, and deleted or burned them all. (If in the modern era, the Order probably had designed a magnificent virus that was able to crawl through all their servers and scramble the data irreversibly)



            The last few members of the Order defected and were folded into the Followers, however these measly few weren't enough to provide understanding of these incredibly advanced technologies besides the insight to deal with perhaps more advanced troubleshooting, and even then not in all cases.



            And so your civilization limps along, possessing the marvelous technology of the Order, but none of its understanding.






            share|improve this answer











            $endgroup$








            • 1




              $begingroup$
              This is brilliant, THANK YOU!
              $endgroup$
              – Richard U
              8 hours ago













            5












            5








            5





            $begingroup$

            The Holy Order of Engineers



            You can take this more or less literal (keep the religious aspect or divorce this answer from it), but either way it works.



            Due to an internal power struggle long ago (that possibly developed into a civil war that was stamped out), the Powers That Be determined that equipping the masses with the understanding of how to build or develop weapons of war or other technology that could be leveraged militarily, economically, or politically were dangerous to have in the hands of the masses.



            And so the Holy Order of Engineers was created. This very closed-mouth and tightly-knit organization was given authority and charge over all higher learning, research, and development that possibly could relate to engineering or R&D, or in many cases, the actual manufacturing (for the technological crown jewels). The Followers of Engineering Ongoing was founded as a sister organization to the Order that was taught how to maintain infrastructure. The Followers were overseen and governed at arm's length by the Order as while the Followers were less dangerous than the Order, they still had the potential of arming the masses with easily exploitable technology. The Order dispatches Inquisitors routinely not only to weed out engineering from the masses, but to check in on the Followers to ensure that anyone too intelligent, creative, ambitious, or otherwise on the path of engineering was either recruited or put to the sword (or mag rail gun, as the case may be) and made an example of.



            And in this manner your civilization continued for quite some time. Centuries perhaps.



            But like all great things this came to an end. The governing authorities grew to not trust the Order and their ever increasing influence, or perhaps the Order grew too proud and attempted to rebel. Either way, while the Order understood amazing technologies, they lacked the infrastructure and manpower to defend them. It wasn't long before the Order was all but stamped out, and the last few members of the Order followed their holy code to protect their archives from the masses, and deleted or burned them all. (If in the modern era, the Order probably had designed a magnificent virus that was able to crawl through all their servers and scramble the data irreversibly)



            The last few members of the Order defected and were folded into the Followers, however these measly few weren't enough to provide understanding of these incredibly advanced technologies besides the insight to deal with perhaps more advanced troubleshooting, and even then not in all cases.



            And so your civilization limps along, possessing the marvelous technology of the Order, but none of its understanding.






            share|improve this answer











            $endgroup$



            The Holy Order of Engineers



            You can take this more or less literal (keep the religious aspect or divorce this answer from it), but either way it works.



            Due to an internal power struggle long ago (that possibly developed into a civil war that was stamped out), the Powers That Be determined that equipping the masses with the understanding of how to build or develop weapons of war or other technology that could be leveraged militarily, economically, or politically were dangerous to have in the hands of the masses.



            And so the Holy Order of Engineers was created. This very closed-mouth and tightly-knit organization was given authority and charge over all higher learning, research, and development that possibly could relate to engineering or R&D, or in many cases, the actual manufacturing (for the technological crown jewels). The Followers of Engineering Ongoing was founded as a sister organization to the Order that was taught how to maintain infrastructure. The Followers were overseen and governed at arm's length by the Order as while the Followers were less dangerous than the Order, they still had the potential of arming the masses with easily exploitable technology. The Order dispatches Inquisitors routinely not only to weed out engineering from the masses, but to check in on the Followers to ensure that anyone too intelligent, creative, ambitious, or otherwise on the path of engineering was either recruited or put to the sword (or mag rail gun, as the case may be) and made an example of.



            And in this manner your civilization continued for quite some time. Centuries perhaps.



            But like all great things this came to an end. The governing authorities grew to not trust the Order and their ever increasing influence, or perhaps the Order grew too proud and attempted to rebel. Either way, while the Order understood amazing technologies, they lacked the infrastructure and manpower to defend them. It wasn't long before the Order was all but stamped out, and the last few members of the Order followed their holy code to protect their archives from the masses, and deleted or burned them all. (If in the modern era, the Order probably had designed a magnificent virus that was able to crawl through all their servers and scramble the data irreversibly)



            The last few members of the Order defected and were folded into the Followers, however these measly few weren't enough to provide understanding of these incredibly advanced technologies besides the insight to deal with perhaps more advanced troubleshooting, and even then not in all cases.



            And so your civilization limps along, possessing the marvelous technology of the Order, but none of its understanding.







            share|improve this answer














            share|improve this answer



            share|improve this answer








            edited 8 hours ago

























            answered 8 hours ago









            Nex TerrenNex Terren

            12.9k4 gold badges56 silver badges103 bronze badges




            12.9k4 gold badges56 silver badges103 bronze badges







            • 1




              $begingroup$
              This is brilliant, THANK YOU!
              $endgroup$
              – Richard U
              8 hours ago












            • 1




              $begingroup$
              This is brilliant, THANK YOU!
              $endgroup$
              – Richard U
              8 hours ago







            1




            1




            $begingroup$
            This is brilliant, THANK YOU!
            $endgroup$
            – Richard U
            8 hours ago




            $begingroup$
            This is brilliant, THANK YOU!
            $endgroup$
            – Richard U
            8 hours ago













            4












            $begingroup$

            Consider how far removed, for example, Shakespearean English is from the English we speak today. That's a mere 400 years of linguistic evolution. Now imagine that Shakespeare wrote a technical manual.



            The language of the forebearers has fallen out of use. No one alive today speaks the ancient tongue. The forebearers left detailed instructions on how to replicate their great machines, but linguistic scholars have tried and failed to make sense of the text.



            Since the machines never needed to be replaced (until now), the study and advancement of engineering ceased long ago. Apprentices abandoned the field for newer, more exciting opportunities and the knowledge was never passed down.






            share|improve this answer









            $endgroup$












            • $begingroup$
              Another great idea! You guys are brilliant!
              $endgroup$
              – Richard U
              8 hours ago















            4












            $begingroup$

            Consider how far removed, for example, Shakespearean English is from the English we speak today. That's a mere 400 years of linguistic evolution. Now imagine that Shakespeare wrote a technical manual.



            The language of the forebearers has fallen out of use. No one alive today speaks the ancient tongue. The forebearers left detailed instructions on how to replicate their great machines, but linguistic scholars have tried and failed to make sense of the text.



            Since the machines never needed to be replaced (until now), the study and advancement of engineering ceased long ago. Apprentices abandoned the field for newer, more exciting opportunities and the knowledge was never passed down.






            share|improve this answer









            $endgroup$












            • $begingroup$
              Another great idea! You guys are brilliant!
              $endgroup$
              – Richard U
              8 hours ago













            4












            4








            4





            $begingroup$

            Consider how far removed, for example, Shakespearean English is from the English we speak today. That's a mere 400 years of linguistic evolution. Now imagine that Shakespeare wrote a technical manual.



            The language of the forebearers has fallen out of use. No one alive today speaks the ancient tongue. The forebearers left detailed instructions on how to replicate their great machines, but linguistic scholars have tried and failed to make sense of the text.



            Since the machines never needed to be replaced (until now), the study and advancement of engineering ceased long ago. Apprentices abandoned the field for newer, more exciting opportunities and the knowledge was never passed down.






            share|improve this answer









            $endgroup$



            Consider how far removed, for example, Shakespearean English is from the English we speak today. That's a mere 400 years of linguistic evolution. Now imagine that Shakespeare wrote a technical manual.



            The language of the forebearers has fallen out of use. No one alive today speaks the ancient tongue. The forebearers left detailed instructions on how to replicate their great machines, but linguistic scholars have tried and failed to make sense of the text.



            Since the machines never needed to be replaced (until now), the study and advancement of engineering ceased long ago. Apprentices abandoned the field for newer, more exciting opportunities and the knowledge was never passed down.







            share|improve this answer












            share|improve this answer



            share|improve this answer










            answered 8 hours ago









            IAntoniazziIAntoniazzi

            3725 bronze badges




            3725 bronze badges











            • $begingroup$
              Another great idea! You guys are brilliant!
              $endgroup$
              – Richard U
              8 hours ago
















            • $begingroup$
              Another great idea! You guys are brilliant!
              $endgroup$
              – Richard U
              8 hours ago















            $begingroup$
            Another great idea! You guys are brilliant!
            $endgroup$
            – Richard U
            8 hours ago




            $begingroup$
            Another great idea! You guys are brilliant!
            $endgroup$
            – Richard U
            8 hours ago











            3












            $begingroup$

            Their toolset became more and more sophisticated. Their universities and trade schools paid lip service to starting from first principles, but that got more and more perfunctory.



            For a comparison, take modern software development. Many programmers can do java, or javascript, but people who can really write machine code are a tiny minority.



            I've met young programmers who couldn't explain what a bubblesort is, and why it is usually inferior to quicksort, but superior in a few cases.



            So expand this into the future. There are plenty of people who can build starships if they have a functioning nanofactory. There are some who can build a nanofactory with nanofac assembly tools. But the people who can build the tools to build the tools to build the tools get fewer and fewer, until their number gets too low.






            share|improve this answer









            $endgroup$

















              3












              $begingroup$

              Their toolset became more and more sophisticated. Their universities and trade schools paid lip service to starting from first principles, but that got more and more perfunctory.



              For a comparison, take modern software development. Many programmers can do java, or javascript, but people who can really write machine code are a tiny minority.



              I've met young programmers who couldn't explain what a bubblesort is, and why it is usually inferior to quicksort, but superior in a few cases.



              So expand this into the future. There are plenty of people who can build starships if they have a functioning nanofactory. There are some who can build a nanofactory with nanofac assembly tools. But the people who can build the tools to build the tools to build the tools get fewer and fewer, until their number gets too low.






              share|improve this answer









              $endgroup$















                3












                3








                3





                $begingroup$

                Their toolset became more and more sophisticated. Their universities and trade schools paid lip service to starting from first principles, but that got more and more perfunctory.



                For a comparison, take modern software development. Many programmers can do java, or javascript, but people who can really write machine code are a tiny minority.



                I've met young programmers who couldn't explain what a bubblesort is, and why it is usually inferior to quicksort, but superior in a few cases.



                So expand this into the future. There are plenty of people who can build starships if they have a functioning nanofactory. There are some who can build a nanofactory with nanofac assembly tools. But the people who can build the tools to build the tools to build the tools get fewer and fewer, until their number gets too low.






                share|improve this answer









                $endgroup$



                Their toolset became more and more sophisticated. Their universities and trade schools paid lip service to starting from first principles, but that got more and more perfunctory.



                For a comparison, take modern software development. Many programmers can do java, or javascript, but people who can really write machine code are a tiny minority.



                I've met young programmers who couldn't explain what a bubblesort is, and why it is usually inferior to quicksort, but superior in a few cases.



                So expand this into the future. There are plenty of people who can build starships if they have a functioning nanofactory. There are some who can build a nanofactory with nanofac assembly tools. But the people who can build the tools to build the tools to build the tools get fewer and fewer, until their number gets too low.







                share|improve this answer












                share|improve this answer



                share|improve this answer










                answered 8 hours ago









                o.m.o.m.

                66.4k7 gold badges98 silver badges219 bronze badges




                66.4k7 gold badges98 silver badges219 bronze badges





















                    2












                    $begingroup$

                    Secrecy



                    If your technology is a trade secret, then only a few select people are allowed to know exactly how it's done. In fact, it may be complex enough that some people know how to make some parts of the whole, but no one person knows all the secrets necessary to get from raw ingredients to finished product.



                    The formula for Coca-Cola is an example.




                    According to the company, only two employees are privy to the complete
                    formula at any given time and they are not permitted to travel
                    together. When one dies, the other must choose a successor within the
                    company and impart the secret to that person. The identity of the two
                    employees in possession of the secret is itself a secret.




                    It is theoretically possible that some massive disaster could wipe out both people at once, dooming the full formula. Assuming it's not written down in some bank vault or something.



                    Greek Fire is another example of a trade secret that was lost to time.



                    Any time there is a thing known to only a few people, that lack of redundancy makes it more likely that the knowledge is lost to time.



                    State Collapse



                    When Rome fell, Europe lost a great deal of technology. Roman roads, Roman sewer, aqueduct, and other architectural systems were all lost for centuries. During an empire collapse, people stop worrying about major projects or passing down critical but complex skills. Their focus shifts to survival: food, safety, shelter. Everything else becomes "we'll worry about that later," but if the collapse spans a generation, then later becomes centuries. We didn't surpass Roman roads until the 19th century. Rome had better roads between cities at 10 CE than Washington DC had, inside the city, in 1865 CE.



                    Political/Religious Censorship



                    If a political, religious, or combined power takes control, they may ban entire segments of technology outright. Galileo Galilei faced censorship for his works on heliocentrism, for example. Those parts of modern technology that involve mass communication or the internet are largely banned in despotic regimes like North Korea.



                    If a society is never allowed to study, learn, expand, or pass down knowledge of a technology, then it will quickly be lost to those people.



                    Poor or No Documentation



                    Perhaps the technology is poorly documented or only verbally documented. If all the details are written on paper or papyrus and there aren't enough copies that survive, then the knowledge is lost. Or if all of your critical texts on the subject are digital and there's a massive EMP or other catastrophe that destroys your computers, then that knowledge is gone. Perhaps your survivors can restore some of the knowledge from memory, if they survive and if they can remember enough to matter. But probably not all of it and not in all cases.



                    What separates this from Secrecy, above, is the intent. Secrecy implies a desire to prevent outsiders from learning a skill. Poor Documentation is less about preventing the spread of knowledge and more about the inability to spread that knowledge.



                    Examples of this include many of the ancient monument sites like Stonehenge, where we know it existed, but we simply don't understand all of the reasons why and/or the methods how they were built. Was the construction considered a secret or perhaps a state collapse? Maybe, maybe not. But the lack of permanent record clouds the knowledge, certainly.



                    Natural Disaster



                    If all of your knowledge of a specific technology is housed in one geographic location, then a major disaster could destroy all of it. An earthquake or fire could destroy a building, losing everything (and even everyone) it contains. This is less likely to be a sole reason than the above. More likely is that this is the flashpoint that destroys a technology because of the limits placed on it by the above reasons. Secrecy forces a lack of redundancy that then leaves it vulnerable to an earthquake, for example.



                    Combination



                    Probably, many technologies that become lost over time will be lost through a combination of things, not just any one thing. We do not know exactly how the Egyptian Pyramids were built. Is that because the engineers were lost during the fall of the Egyptian empire? Or because there were so few engineers? It is difficult to be sure, but probably a combination of secrecy, documentation, and state collapse combined to cause the loss.



                    Or maybe a natural disaster triggers a state collapse. Or Secrecy and/or religious/state censorship combined with a natural disaster destroy all the holders of your knowledge...






                    share|improve this answer









                    $endgroup$

















                      2












                      $begingroup$

                      Secrecy



                      If your technology is a trade secret, then only a few select people are allowed to know exactly how it's done. In fact, it may be complex enough that some people know how to make some parts of the whole, but no one person knows all the secrets necessary to get from raw ingredients to finished product.



                      The formula for Coca-Cola is an example.




                      According to the company, only two employees are privy to the complete
                      formula at any given time and they are not permitted to travel
                      together. When one dies, the other must choose a successor within the
                      company and impart the secret to that person. The identity of the two
                      employees in possession of the secret is itself a secret.




                      It is theoretically possible that some massive disaster could wipe out both people at once, dooming the full formula. Assuming it's not written down in some bank vault or something.



                      Greek Fire is another example of a trade secret that was lost to time.



                      Any time there is a thing known to only a few people, that lack of redundancy makes it more likely that the knowledge is lost to time.



                      State Collapse



                      When Rome fell, Europe lost a great deal of technology. Roman roads, Roman sewer, aqueduct, and other architectural systems were all lost for centuries. During an empire collapse, people stop worrying about major projects or passing down critical but complex skills. Their focus shifts to survival: food, safety, shelter. Everything else becomes "we'll worry about that later," but if the collapse spans a generation, then later becomes centuries. We didn't surpass Roman roads until the 19th century. Rome had better roads between cities at 10 CE than Washington DC had, inside the city, in 1865 CE.



                      Political/Religious Censorship



                      If a political, religious, or combined power takes control, they may ban entire segments of technology outright. Galileo Galilei faced censorship for his works on heliocentrism, for example. Those parts of modern technology that involve mass communication or the internet are largely banned in despotic regimes like North Korea.



                      If a society is never allowed to study, learn, expand, or pass down knowledge of a technology, then it will quickly be lost to those people.



                      Poor or No Documentation



                      Perhaps the technology is poorly documented or only verbally documented. If all the details are written on paper or papyrus and there aren't enough copies that survive, then the knowledge is lost. Or if all of your critical texts on the subject are digital and there's a massive EMP or other catastrophe that destroys your computers, then that knowledge is gone. Perhaps your survivors can restore some of the knowledge from memory, if they survive and if they can remember enough to matter. But probably not all of it and not in all cases.



                      What separates this from Secrecy, above, is the intent. Secrecy implies a desire to prevent outsiders from learning a skill. Poor Documentation is less about preventing the spread of knowledge and more about the inability to spread that knowledge.



                      Examples of this include many of the ancient monument sites like Stonehenge, where we know it existed, but we simply don't understand all of the reasons why and/or the methods how they were built. Was the construction considered a secret or perhaps a state collapse? Maybe, maybe not. But the lack of permanent record clouds the knowledge, certainly.



                      Natural Disaster



                      If all of your knowledge of a specific technology is housed in one geographic location, then a major disaster could destroy all of it. An earthquake or fire could destroy a building, losing everything (and even everyone) it contains. This is less likely to be a sole reason than the above. More likely is that this is the flashpoint that destroys a technology because of the limits placed on it by the above reasons. Secrecy forces a lack of redundancy that then leaves it vulnerable to an earthquake, for example.



                      Combination



                      Probably, many technologies that become lost over time will be lost through a combination of things, not just any one thing. We do not know exactly how the Egyptian Pyramids were built. Is that because the engineers were lost during the fall of the Egyptian empire? Or because there were so few engineers? It is difficult to be sure, but probably a combination of secrecy, documentation, and state collapse combined to cause the loss.



                      Or maybe a natural disaster triggers a state collapse. Or Secrecy and/or religious/state censorship combined with a natural disaster destroy all the holders of your knowledge...






                      share|improve this answer









                      $endgroup$















                        2












                        2








                        2





                        $begingroup$

                        Secrecy



                        If your technology is a trade secret, then only a few select people are allowed to know exactly how it's done. In fact, it may be complex enough that some people know how to make some parts of the whole, but no one person knows all the secrets necessary to get from raw ingredients to finished product.



                        The formula for Coca-Cola is an example.




                        According to the company, only two employees are privy to the complete
                        formula at any given time and they are not permitted to travel
                        together. When one dies, the other must choose a successor within the
                        company and impart the secret to that person. The identity of the two
                        employees in possession of the secret is itself a secret.




                        It is theoretically possible that some massive disaster could wipe out both people at once, dooming the full formula. Assuming it's not written down in some bank vault or something.



                        Greek Fire is another example of a trade secret that was lost to time.



                        Any time there is a thing known to only a few people, that lack of redundancy makes it more likely that the knowledge is lost to time.



                        State Collapse



                        When Rome fell, Europe lost a great deal of technology. Roman roads, Roman sewer, aqueduct, and other architectural systems were all lost for centuries. During an empire collapse, people stop worrying about major projects or passing down critical but complex skills. Their focus shifts to survival: food, safety, shelter. Everything else becomes "we'll worry about that later," but if the collapse spans a generation, then later becomes centuries. We didn't surpass Roman roads until the 19th century. Rome had better roads between cities at 10 CE than Washington DC had, inside the city, in 1865 CE.



                        Political/Religious Censorship



                        If a political, religious, or combined power takes control, they may ban entire segments of technology outright. Galileo Galilei faced censorship for his works on heliocentrism, for example. Those parts of modern technology that involve mass communication or the internet are largely banned in despotic regimes like North Korea.



                        If a society is never allowed to study, learn, expand, or pass down knowledge of a technology, then it will quickly be lost to those people.



                        Poor or No Documentation



                        Perhaps the technology is poorly documented or only verbally documented. If all the details are written on paper or papyrus and there aren't enough copies that survive, then the knowledge is lost. Or if all of your critical texts on the subject are digital and there's a massive EMP or other catastrophe that destroys your computers, then that knowledge is gone. Perhaps your survivors can restore some of the knowledge from memory, if they survive and if they can remember enough to matter. But probably not all of it and not in all cases.



                        What separates this from Secrecy, above, is the intent. Secrecy implies a desire to prevent outsiders from learning a skill. Poor Documentation is less about preventing the spread of knowledge and more about the inability to spread that knowledge.



                        Examples of this include many of the ancient monument sites like Stonehenge, where we know it existed, but we simply don't understand all of the reasons why and/or the methods how they were built. Was the construction considered a secret or perhaps a state collapse? Maybe, maybe not. But the lack of permanent record clouds the knowledge, certainly.



                        Natural Disaster



                        If all of your knowledge of a specific technology is housed in one geographic location, then a major disaster could destroy all of it. An earthquake or fire could destroy a building, losing everything (and even everyone) it contains. This is less likely to be a sole reason than the above. More likely is that this is the flashpoint that destroys a technology because of the limits placed on it by the above reasons. Secrecy forces a lack of redundancy that then leaves it vulnerable to an earthquake, for example.



                        Combination



                        Probably, many technologies that become lost over time will be lost through a combination of things, not just any one thing. We do not know exactly how the Egyptian Pyramids were built. Is that because the engineers were lost during the fall of the Egyptian empire? Or because there were so few engineers? It is difficult to be sure, but probably a combination of secrecy, documentation, and state collapse combined to cause the loss.



                        Or maybe a natural disaster triggers a state collapse. Or Secrecy and/or religious/state censorship combined with a natural disaster destroy all the holders of your knowledge...






                        share|improve this answer









                        $endgroup$



                        Secrecy



                        If your technology is a trade secret, then only a few select people are allowed to know exactly how it's done. In fact, it may be complex enough that some people know how to make some parts of the whole, but no one person knows all the secrets necessary to get from raw ingredients to finished product.



                        The formula for Coca-Cola is an example.




                        According to the company, only two employees are privy to the complete
                        formula at any given time and they are not permitted to travel
                        together. When one dies, the other must choose a successor within the
                        company and impart the secret to that person. The identity of the two
                        employees in possession of the secret is itself a secret.




                        It is theoretically possible that some massive disaster could wipe out both people at once, dooming the full formula. Assuming it's not written down in some bank vault or something.



                        Greek Fire is another example of a trade secret that was lost to time.



                        Any time there is a thing known to only a few people, that lack of redundancy makes it more likely that the knowledge is lost to time.



                        State Collapse



                        When Rome fell, Europe lost a great deal of technology. Roman roads, Roman sewer, aqueduct, and other architectural systems were all lost for centuries. During an empire collapse, people stop worrying about major projects or passing down critical but complex skills. Their focus shifts to survival: food, safety, shelter. Everything else becomes "we'll worry about that later," but if the collapse spans a generation, then later becomes centuries. We didn't surpass Roman roads until the 19th century. Rome had better roads between cities at 10 CE than Washington DC had, inside the city, in 1865 CE.



                        Political/Religious Censorship



                        If a political, religious, or combined power takes control, they may ban entire segments of technology outright. Galileo Galilei faced censorship for his works on heliocentrism, for example. Those parts of modern technology that involve mass communication or the internet are largely banned in despotic regimes like North Korea.



                        If a society is never allowed to study, learn, expand, or pass down knowledge of a technology, then it will quickly be lost to those people.



                        Poor or No Documentation



                        Perhaps the technology is poorly documented or only verbally documented. If all the details are written on paper or papyrus and there aren't enough copies that survive, then the knowledge is lost. Or if all of your critical texts on the subject are digital and there's a massive EMP or other catastrophe that destroys your computers, then that knowledge is gone. Perhaps your survivors can restore some of the knowledge from memory, if they survive and if they can remember enough to matter. But probably not all of it and not in all cases.



                        What separates this from Secrecy, above, is the intent. Secrecy implies a desire to prevent outsiders from learning a skill. Poor Documentation is less about preventing the spread of knowledge and more about the inability to spread that knowledge.



                        Examples of this include many of the ancient monument sites like Stonehenge, where we know it existed, but we simply don't understand all of the reasons why and/or the methods how they were built. Was the construction considered a secret or perhaps a state collapse? Maybe, maybe not. But the lack of permanent record clouds the knowledge, certainly.



                        Natural Disaster



                        If all of your knowledge of a specific technology is housed in one geographic location, then a major disaster could destroy all of it. An earthquake or fire could destroy a building, losing everything (and even everyone) it contains. This is less likely to be a sole reason than the above. More likely is that this is the flashpoint that destroys a technology because of the limits placed on it by the above reasons. Secrecy forces a lack of redundancy that then leaves it vulnerable to an earthquake, for example.



                        Combination



                        Probably, many technologies that become lost over time will be lost through a combination of things, not just any one thing. We do not know exactly how the Egyptian Pyramids were built. Is that because the engineers were lost during the fall of the Egyptian empire? Or because there were so few engineers? It is difficult to be sure, but probably a combination of secrecy, documentation, and state collapse combined to cause the loss.



                        Or maybe a natural disaster triggers a state collapse. Or Secrecy and/or religious/state censorship combined with a natural disaster destroy all the holders of your knowledge...







                        share|improve this answer












                        share|improve this answer



                        share|improve this answer










                        answered 8 hours ago









                        CaMCaM

                        12.2k29 silver badges63 bronze badges




                        12.2k29 silver badges63 bronze badges





















                            1












                            $begingroup$

                            So, the simplest answer is a confluence of two factors.



                            First: A technological 'plateau'.



                            Your society reached a point where further refinement of the basic fundamentals of their technology came to a halt due to diminishing returns on development. A good example of this is the widespread stagnation of military technology during the interwar periods prior to WW1 and WW2. Nobody cared enough about improving things to bother trying to figure out HOW. A more modern hypothetical example would be the point at which the technology required for a smartphone gets so small and efficient that there's no practical benefit in improving it anymore.



                            Basically, in the absence of new frontiers (either physical or technological), your society loses the incentive to innovate, which means most of the citizens of your civilization have no reason to learn how any of their stuff works, because that information just isn't useful.



                            Second: Massive automation of manufacturing.



                            Continuing on the theme above, the only two reasons the living members of your civilization would have to learn how their technology works is either to improve it, repair it, or build more of it. We addressed item one in the first section, this section addresses the other two. In the absence of any need to continually retool their manufacturing to accommodate new advancements, your civilization would naturally tend more and more towards automation of their factories. You put raw materials in, finished goods come out the other side. You have robots to build the goods, you have other robots to repair THOSE robots when they break down. You have MORE robots to repair anything ELSE that breaks.



                            Over time the living members of your civilization who actually know how any of this works become fewer and fewer because their contribution has little or no benefit. Eventually the last living member who understood how to build or repair any of the robots dies, and nobody notices because the robots are doing just fine keeping themselves in working order.



                            This state of affairs could persist for a LONG time without any problems, until civil unrest or disruption of the supply chain of raw materials caused things to start breaking down, and by that point there would be nobody left who knew how to repair or rebuild them.






                            share|improve this answer









                            $endgroup$

















                              1












                              $begingroup$

                              So, the simplest answer is a confluence of two factors.



                              First: A technological 'plateau'.



                              Your society reached a point where further refinement of the basic fundamentals of their technology came to a halt due to diminishing returns on development. A good example of this is the widespread stagnation of military technology during the interwar periods prior to WW1 and WW2. Nobody cared enough about improving things to bother trying to figure out HOW. A more modern hypothetical example would be the point at which the technology required for a smartphone gets so small and efficient that there's no practical benefit in improving it anymore.



                              Basically, in the absence of new frontiers (either physical or technological), your society loses the incentive to innovate, which means most of the citizens of your civilization have no reason to learn how any of their stuff works, because that information just isn't useful.



                              Second: Massive automation of manufacturing.



                              Continuing on the theme above, the only two reasons the living members of your civilization would have to learn how their technology works is either to improve it, repair it, or build more of it. We addressed item one in the first section, this section addresses the other two. In the absence of any need to continually retool their manufacturing to accommodate new advancements, your civilization would naturally tend more and more towards automation of their factories. You put raw materials in, finished goods come out the other side. You have robots to build the goods, you have other robots to repair THOSE robots when they break down. You have MORE robots to repair anything ELSE that breaks.



                              Over time the living members of your civilization who actually know how any of this works become fewer and fewer because their contribution has little or no benefit. Eventually the last living member who understood how to build or repair any of the robots dies, and nobody notices because the robots are doing just fine keeping themselves in working order.



                              This state of affairs could persist for a LONG time without any problems, until civil unrest or disruption of the supply chain of raw materials caused things to start breaking down, and by that point there would be nobody left who knew how to repair or rebuild them.






                              share|improve this answer









                              $endgroup$















                                1












                                1








                                1





                                $begingroup$

                                So, the simplest answer is a confluence of two factors.



                                First: A technological 'plateau'.



                                Your society reached a point where further refinement of the basic fundamentals of their technology came to a halt due to diminishing returns on development. A good example of this is the widespread stagnation of military technology during the interwar periods prior to WW1 and WW2. Nobody cared enough about improving things to bother trying to figure out HOW. A more modern hypothetical example would be the point at which the technology required for a smartphone gets so small and efficient that there's no practical benefit in improving it anymore.



                                Basically, in the absence of new frontiers (either physical or technological), your society loses the incentive to innovate, which means most of the citizens of your civilization have no reason to learn how any of their stuff works, because that information just isn't useful.



                                Second: Massive automation of manufacturing.



                                Continuing on the theme above, the only two reasons the living members of your civilization would have to learn how their technology works is either to improve it, repair it, or build more of it. We addressed item one in the first section, this section addresses the other two. In the absence of any need to continually retool their manufacturing to accommodate new advancements, your civilization would naturally tend more and more towards automation of their factories. You put raw materials in, finished goods come out the other side. You have robots to build the goods, you have other robots to repair THOSE robots when they break down. You have MORE robots to repair anything ELSE that breaks.



                                Over time the living members of your civilization who actually know how any of this works become fewer and fewer because their contribution has little or no benefit. Eventually the last living member who understood how to build or repair any of the robots dies, and nobody notices because the robots are doing just fine keeping themselves in working order.



                                This state of affairs could persist for a LONG time without any problems, until civil unrest or disruption of the supply chain of raw materials caused things to start breaking down, and by that point there would be nobody left who knew how to repair or rebuild them.






                                share|improve this answer









                                $endgroup$



                                So, the simplest answer is a confluence of two factors.



                                First: A technological 'plateau'.



                                Your society reached a point where further refinement of the basic fundamentals of their technology came to a halt due to diminishing returns on development. A good example of this is the widespread stagnation of military technology during the interwar periods prior to WW1 and WW2. Nobody cared enough about improving things to bother trying to figure out HOW. A more modern hypothetical example would be the point at which the technology required for a smartphone gets so small and efficient that there's no practical benefit in improving it anymore.



                                Basically, in the absence of new frontiers (either physical or technological), your society loses the incentive to innovate, which means most of the citizens of your civilization have no reason to learn how any of their stuff works, because that information just isn't useful.



                                Second: Massive automation of manufacturing.



                                Continuing on the theme above, the only two reasons the living members of your civilization would have to learn how their technology works is either to improve it, repair it, or build more of it. We addressed item one in the first section, this section addresses the other two. In the absence of any need to continually retool their manufacturing to accommodate new advancements, your civilization would naturally tend more and more towards automation of their factories. You put raw materials in, finished goods come out the other side. You have robots to build the goods, you have other robots to repair THOSE robots when they break down. You have MORE robots to repair anything ELSE that breaks.



                                Over time the living members of your civilization who actually know how any of this works become fewer and fewer because their contribution has little or no benefit. Eventually the last living member who understood how to build or repair any of the robots dies, and nobody notices because the robots are doing just fine keeping themselves in working order.



                                This state of affairs could persist for a LONG time without any problems, until civil unrest or disruption of the supply chain of raw materials caused things to start breaking down, and by that point there would be nobody left who knew how to repair or rebuild them.







                                share|improve this answer












                                share|improve this answer



                                share|improve this answer










                                answered 8 hours ago









                                Morris The CatMorris The Cat

                                6,4321 gold badge17 silver badges34 bronze badges




                                6,4321 gold badge17 silver badges34 bronze badges





















                                    1












                                    $begingroup$

                                    One possible solution is having a wide spread very basic technology that suddenly isn't viable anymore.



                                    Say, for instance, this alien society had discovered a room temperature superconductor. It would be used for all wiring in everything, because the ability to not lose power to heat from resistance. But if some fungus/organism developed that could eat or corrode the superconductor, and was spread far and wide before anyone noticed what was happening, or how bad the problem was, then it could cripple all technology that the civilization uses, from power delivery to microprocessors. *



                                    You'd have some people who could figure out how to jerry rig solutions, assuming they could find other conductors, but these people would likely be rare, and located in places with high population density, meaning less food to go around, and all the chaos that implies.



                                    Just about any technology that most other technology relies on would work.



                                    * This is a sub plot in the book Ringworld by Larry Niven.






                                    share|improve this answer









                                    $endgroup$

















                                      1












                                      $begingroup$

                                      One possible solution is having a wide spread very basic technology that suddenly isn't viable anymore.



                                      Say, for instance, this alien society had discovered a room temperature superconductor. It would be used for all wiring in everything, because the ability to not lose power to heat from resistance. But if some fungus/organism developed that could eat or corrode the superconductor, and was spread far and wide before anyone noticed what was happening, or how bad the problem was, then it could cripple all technology that the civilization uses, from power delivery to microprocessors. *



                                      You'd have some people who could figure out how to jerry rig solutions, assuming they could find other conductors, but these people would likely be rare, and located in places with high population density, meaning less food to go around, and all the chaos that implies.



                                      Just about any technology that most other technology relies on would work.



                                      * This is a sub plot in the book Ringworld by Larry Niven.






                                      share|improve this answer









                                      $endgroup$















                                        1












                                        1








                                        1





                                        $begingroup$

                                        One possible solution is having a wide spread very basic technology that suddenly isn't viable anymore.



                                        Say, for instance, this alien society had discovered a room temperature superconductor. It would be used for all wiring in everything, because the ability to not lose power to heat from resistance. But if some fungus/organism developed that could eat or corrode the superconductor, and was spread far and wide before anyone noticed what was happening, or how bad the problem was, then it could cripple all technology that the civilization uses, from power delivery to microprocessors. *



                                        You'd have some people who could figure out how to jerry rig solutions, assuming they could find other conductors, but these people would likely be rare, and located in places with high population density, meaning less food to go around, and all the chaos that implies.



                                        Just about any technology that most other technology relies on would work.



                                        * This is a sub plot in the book Ringworld by Larry Niven.






                                        share|improve this answer









                                        $endgroup$



                                        One possible solution is having a wide spread very basic technology that suddenly isn't viable anymore.



                                        Say, for instance, this alien society had discovered a room temperature superconductor. It would be used for all wiring in everything, because the ability to not lose power to heat from resistance. But if some fungus/organism developed that could eat or corrode the superconductor, and was spread far and wide before anyone noticed what was happening, or how bad the problem was, then it could cripple all technology that the civilization uses, from power delivery to microprocessors. *



                                        You'd have some people who could figure out how to jerry rig solutions, assuming they could find other conductors, but these people would likely be rare, and located in places with high population density, meaning less food to go around, and all the chaos that implies.



                                        Just about any technology that most other technology relies on would work.



                                        * This is a sub plot in the book Ringworld by Larry Niven.







                                        share|improve this answer












                                        share|improve this answer



                                        share|improve this answer










                                        answered 7 hours ago









                                        AndyD273AndyD273

                                        31.4k2 gold badges60 silver badges137 bronze badges




                                        31.4k2 gold badges60 silver badges137 bronze badges





















                                            0












                                            $begingroup$

                                            The "death" of AI rulers.



                                            enter image description here



                                            Their civilization built powerful artificial minds, for thousands of years those mostly benevolent Minds controlled their civilization, ran their factories, invented their medicines, built their spaceships and designed their devices.



                                            They built things to last and built everything with a lot of failsafes and fallbacks.



                                            But eventually there was a brief and almost silent civil war between the Minds. During that war a host of computer viruses designed to target Artificial Minds were released by both sides through the civilizations networks and infrastructure.



                                            One day the citizens of the civilization woke up to find their rulers dead



                                            Their queries addressed to the ruling minds unanswered and everything was left in failsafe mode.



                                            They tried to build replacement Minds... but everything in their civilization is suffused with computer viruses designed to find and kill such AI's.



                                            So they found themselves surrounded by devices that mostly still worked, even many factories to produce things.



                                            But the Minds had never explained how the Magitech really worked, perhaps it was simply beyond the comprehension of normal organic minds.



                                            So now they hobble along, flying ships they don't really understand, using devices they may not be able to reproduce.






                                            share|improve this answer









                                            $endgroup$

















                                              0












                                              $begingroup$

                                              The "death" of AI rulers.



                                              enter image description here



                                              Their civilization built powerful artificial minds, for thousands of years those mostly benevolent Minds controlled their civilization, ran their factories, invented their medicines, built their spaceships and designed their devices.



                                              They built things to last and built everything with a lot of failsafes and fallbacks.



                                              But eventually there was a brief and almost silent civil war between the Minds. During that war a host of computer viruses designed to target Artificial Minds were released by both sides through the civilizations networks and infrastructure.



                                              One day the citizens of the civilization woke up to find their rulers dead



                                              Their queries addressed to the ruling minds unanswered and everything was left in failsafe mode.



                                              They tried to build replacement Minds... but everything in their civilization is suffused with computer viruses designed to find and kill such AI's.



                                              So they found themselves surrounded by devices that mostly still worked, even many factories to produce things.



                                              But the Minds had never explained how the Magitech really worked, perhaps it was simply beyond the comprehension of normal organic minds.



                                              So now they hobble along, flying ships they don't really understand, using devices they may not be able to reproduce.






                                              share|improve this answer









                                              $endgroup$















                                                0












                                                0








                                                0





                                                $begingroup$

                                                The "death" of AI rulers.



                                                enter image description here



                                                Their civilization built powerful artificial minds, for thousands of years those mostly benevolent Minds controlled their civilization, ran their factories, invented their medicines, built their spaceships and designed their devices.



                                                They built things to last and built everything with a lot of failsafes and fallbacks.



                                                But eventually there was a brief and almost silent civil war between the Minds. During that war a host of computer viruses designed to target Artificial Minds were released by both sides through the civilizations networks and infrastructure.



                                                One day the citizens of the civilization woke up to find their rulers dead



                                                Their queries addressed to the ruling minds unanswered and everything was left in failsafe mode.



                                                They tried to build replacement Minds... but everything in their civilization is suffused with computer viruses designed to find and kill such AI's.



                                                So they found themselves surrounded by devices that mostly still worked, even many factories to produce things.



                                                But the Minds had never explained how the Magitech really worked, perhaps it was simply beyond the comprehension of normal organic minds.



                                                So now they hobble along, flying ships they don't really understand, using devices they may not be able to reproduce.






                                                share|improve this answer









                                                $endgroup$



                                                The "death" of AI rulers.



                                                enter image description here



                                                Their civilization built powerful artificial minds, for thousands of years those mostly benevolent Minds controlled their civilization, ran their factories, invented their medicines, built their spaceships and designed their devices.



                                                They built things to last and built everything with a lot of failsafes and fallbacks.



                                                But eventually there was a brief and almost silent civil war between the Minds. During that war a host of computer viruses designed to target Artificial Minds were released by both sides through the civilizations networks and infrastructure.



                                                One day the citizens of the civilization woke up to find their rulers dead



                                                Their queries addressed to the ruling minds unanswered and everything was left in failsafe mode.



                                                They tried to build replacement Minds... but everything in their civilization is suffused with computer viruses designed to find and kill such AI's.



                                                So they found themselves surrounded by devices that mostly still worked, even many factories to produce things.



                                                But the Minds had never explained how the Magitech really worked, perhaps it was simply beyond the comprehension of normal organic minds.



                                                So now they hobble along, flying ships they don't really understand, using devices they may not be able to reproduce.







                                                share|improve this answer












                                                share|improve this answer



                                                share|improve this answer










                                                answered 8 hours ago









                                                MurphyMurphy

                                                24.8k2 gold badges48 silver badges88 bronze badges




                                                24.8k2 gold badges48 silver badges88 bronze badges



























                                                    draft saved

                                                    draft discarded
















































                                                    Thanks for contributing an answer to Worldbuilding Stack Exchange!


                                                    • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

                                                    But avoid


                                                    • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

                                                    • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.

                                                    Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.


                                                    To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




                                                    draft saved


                                                    draft discarded














                                                    StackExchange.ready(
                                                    function ()
                                                    StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fworldbuilding.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f150663%2fhow-can-an-advanced-civilization-forget-how-to-manufacture-its-technology%23new-answer', 'question_page');

                                                    );

                                                    Post as a guest















                                                    Required, but never shown





















































                                                    Required, but never shown














                                                    Required, but never shown












                                                    Required, but never shown







                                                    Required, but never shown

































                                                    Required, but never shown














                                                    Required, but never shown












                                                    Required, but never shown







                                                    Required, but never shown







                                                    Popular posts from this blog

                                                    Invision Community Contents History See also References External links Navigation menuProprietaryinvisioncommunity.comIPS Community ForumsIPS Community Forumsthis blog entry"License Changes, IP.Board 3.4, and the Future""Interview -- Matt Mecham of Ibforums""CEO Invision Power Board, Matt Mecham Is a Liar, Thief!"IPB License Explanation 1.3, 1.3.1, 2.0, and 2.1ArchivedSecurity Fixes, Updates And Enhancements For IPB 1.3.1Archived"New Demo Accounts - Invision Power Services"the original"New Default Skin"the original"Invision Power Board 3.0.0 and Applications Released"the original"Archived copy"the original"Perpetual licenses being done away with""Release Notes - Invision Power Services""Introducing: IPS Community Suite 4!"Invision Community Release Notes

                                                    Canceling a color specificationRandomly assigning color to Graphics3D objects?Default color for Filling in Mathematica 9Coloring specific elements of sets with a prime modified order in an array plotHow to pick a color differing significantly from the colors already in a given color list?Detection of the text colorColor numbers based on their valueCan color schemes for use with ColorData include opacity specification?My dynamic color schemes

                                                    Tom Holland Mục lục Đầu đời và giáo dục | Sự nghiệp | Cuộc sống cá nhân | Phim tham gia | Giải thưởng và đề cử | Chú thích | Liên kết ngoài | Trình đơn chuyển hướngProfile“Person Details for Thomas Stanley Holland, "England and Wales Birth Registration Index, 1837-2008" — FamilySearch.org”"Meet Tom Holland... the 16-year-old star of The Impossible""Schoolboy actor Tom Holland finds himself in Oscar contention for role in tsunami drama"“Naomi Watts on the Prince William and Harry's reaction to her film about the late Princess Diana”lưu trữ"Holland and Pflueger Are West End's Two New 'Billy Elliots'""I'm so envious of my son, the movie star! British writer Dominic Holland's spent 20 years trying to crack Hollywood - but he's been beaten to it by a very unlikely rival"“Richard and Margaret Povey of Jersey, Channel Islands, UK: Information about Thomas Stanley Holland”"Tom Holland to play Billy Elliot""New Billy Elliot leaving the garage"Billy Elliot the Musical - Tom Holland - Billy"A Tale of four Billys: Tom Holland""The Feel Good Factor""Thames Christian College schoolboys join Myleene Klass for The Feelgood Factor""Government launches £600,000 arts bursaries pilot""BILLY's Chapman, Holland, Gardner & Jackson-Keen Visit Prime Minister""Elton John 'blown away' by Billy Elliot fifth birthday" (video with John's interview and fragments of Holland's performance)"First News interviews Arrietty's Tom Holland"“33rd Critics' Circle Film Awards winners”“National Board of Review Current Awards”Bản gốc"Ron Howard Whaling Tale 'In The Heart Of The Sea' Casts Tom Holland"“'Spider-Man' Finds Tom Holland to Star as New Web-Slinger”lưu trữ“Captain America: Civil War (2016)”“Film Review: ‘Captain America: Civil War’”lưu trữ“‘Captain America: Civil War’ review: Choose your own avenger”lưu trữ“The Lost City of Z reviews”“Sony Pictures and Marvel Studios Find Their 'Spider-Man' Star and Director”“‘Mary Magdalene’, ‘Current War’ & ‘Wind River’ Get 2017 Release Dates From Weinstein”“Lionsgate Unleashing Daisy Ridley & Tom Holland Starrer ‘Chaos Walking’ In Cannes”“PTA's 'Master' Leads Chicago Film Critics Nominations, UPDATED: Houston and Indiana Critics Nominations”“Nominaciones Goya 2013 Telecinco Cinema – ENG”“Jameson Empire Film Awards: Martin Freeman wins best actor for performance in The Hobbit”“34th Annual Young Artist Awards”Bản gốc“Teen Choice Awards 2016—Captain America: Civil War Leads Second Wave of Nominations”“BAFTA Film Award Nominations: ‘La La Land’ Leads Race”“Saturn Awards Nominations 2017: 'Rogue One,' 'Walking Dead' Lead”Tom HollandTom HollandTom HollandTom Hollandmedia.gettyimages.comWorldCat Identities300279794no20130442900000 0004 0355 42791085670554170004732cb16706349t(data)XX5557367