Importance of the current postdoc advisor's letter in TT job searchPros and cons of not having PhD advisor's letter of recommendation after postdoc?Job search when coming up for tenureLeaving soft-money job for tenure track position that doesn't start until August: when to tell current advisor?How to get rid of unwanted and annoying co-author?Will these “errors” in my advisor's letter raise red flags when I apply for academic faculty positions?Bad recommendation letter from previous postdoc adviserChanging thesis supervisor to avoid bad letter of recommendation from current supervisor?Inform the search committee of another university about your current campus interviewreference letter from current line manager?
How to write characters doing illogical things in a believable way?
shell script to check if input is a string/integer/float
Can I see Harvest moon in India?
Importance of the current postdoc advisor's letter in TT job search
What is the meaning of 「ぞんぞん」?
Why don't Wizards use wrist straps to protect against disarming charms?
What is this gigantic dish at Ben Gurion airport?
Ethernet, Wifi and a little human psychology
Amortized Loans seem to benefit the bank more than the customer
Teleport everything in a large zone; or teleport all living things and make a lot of equipment disappear
What makes a smart phone "kosher"?
Seven Places at Once - Another Google Earth Challenge?
Is the Dodge action perceptible to other characters?
How would you control supersoldiers in a late iron-age society?
How does a simple logistic regression model achieve a 92% classification accuracy on MNIST?
Why does the speed of sound decrease at high altitudes although the air density decreases?
How can I use expandafter the expand the definition of this control sequence?
Prove that a convergent real sequence always has a smallest or a largest term
Is my sink P-trap too low?
Why any infinite sequence of real functions can be generated from a finite set through composition?
How clean are pets?
Are there objective criteria for classifying consonance v. dissonance?
What was the motivation for the invention of electric pianos?
Why is the year in this ISO timestamp not 2019?
Importance of the current postdoc advisor's letter in TT job search
Pros and cons of not having PhD advisor's letter of recommendation after postdoc?Job search when coming up for tenureLeaving soft-money job for tenure track position that doesn't start until August: when to tell current advisor?How to get rid of unwanted and annoying co-author?Will these “errors” in my advisor's letter raise red flags when I apply for academic faculty positions?Bad recommendation letter from previous postdoc adviserChanging thesis supervisor to avoid bad letter of recommendation from current supervisor?Inform the search committee of another university about your current campus interviewreference letter from current line manager?
.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty margin-bottom:0;
I have strong publication record in my Ph.D. and 1st Postdoc that went for two years. Got 4 TT interview calls before last year.. but not successful in any. Last year did not apply, but this year, after fixing a few shortcomings noticed in my previous interviews, started the search again. In the meantime I published a couple of top journals as the corresponding author. However, I am not in harmonious professional relation with the present postdoc advisor. I am working for a little over one year in this position but did not yield any journal publication. I am sure that this advisor's reference will have negative impact on my search, if at all he agrees to write one. The only best way for me is avoid this advisor's letter, since I can arrange the required number of good letters from my previous affiliations. If I proceed with out my present advisor's reference, will it have any bearing on my chances? Expecting some suggestions from the people having experience in search committees.
advisor recommendation-letter tenure-track
New contributor
add a comment
|
I have strong publication record in my Ph.D. and 1st Postdoc that went for two years. Got 4 TT interview calls before last year.. but not successful in any. Last year did not apply, but this year, after fixing a few shortcomings noticed in my previous interviews, started the search again. In the meantime I published a couple of top journals as the corresponding author. However, I am not in harmonious professional relation with the present postdoc advisor. I am working for a little over one year in this position but did not yield any journal publication. I am sure that this advisor's reference will have negative impact on my search, if at all he agrees to write one. The only best way for me is avoid this advisor's letter, since I can arrange the required number of good letters from my previous affiliations. If I proceed with out my present advisor's reference, will it have any bearing on my chances? Expecting some suggestions from the people having experience in search committees.
advisor recommendation-letter tenure-track
New contributor
It might have a bearing on your chances, but your strategy still seems the best one given the situation.
– Noah Snyder
7 hours ago
add a comment
|
I have strong publication record in my Ph.D. and 1st Postdoc that went for two years. Got 4 TT interview calls before last year.. but not successful in any. Last year did not apply, but this year, after fixing a few shortcomings noticed in my previous interviews, started the search again. In the meantime I published a couple of top journals as the corresponding author. However, I am not in harmonious professional relation with the present postdoc advisor. I am working for a little over one year in this position but did not yield any journal publication. I am sure that this advisor's reference will have negative impact on my search, if at all he agrees to write one. The only best way for me is avoid this advisor's letter, since I can arrange the required number of good letters from my previous affiliations. If I proceed with out my present advisor's reference, will it have any bearing on my chances? Expecting some suggestions from the people having experience in search committees.
advisor recommendation-letter tenure-track
New contributor
I have strong publication record in my Ph.D. and 1st Postdoc that went for two years. Got 4 TT interview calls before last year.. but not successful in any. Last year did not apply, but this year, after fixing a few shortcomings noticed in my previous interviews, started the search again. In the meantime I published a couple of top journals as the corresponding author. However, I am not in harmonious professional relation with the present postdoc advisor. I am working for a little over one year in this position but did not yield any journal publication. I am sure that this advisor's reference will have negative impact on my search, if at all he agrees to write one. The only best way for me is avoid this advisor's letter, since I can arrange the required number of good letters from my previous affiliations. If I proceed with out my present advisor's reference, will it have any bearing on my chances? Expecting some suggestions from the people having experience in search committees.
advisor recommendation-letter tenure-track
advisor recommendation-letter tenure-track
New contributor
New contributor
edited 2 hours ago
Dilworth
4,42914 silver badges24 bronze badges
4,42914 silver badges24 bronze badges
New contributor
asked 8 hours ago
arnarn
161 bronze badge
161 bronze badge
New contributor
New contributor
It might have a bearing on your chances, but your strategy still seems the best one given the situation.
– Noah Snyder
7 hours ago
add a comment
|
It might have a bearing on your chances, but your strategy still seems the best one given the situation.
– Noah Snyder
7 hours ago
It might have a bearing on your chances, but your strategy still seems the best one given the situation.
– Noah Snyder
7 hours ago
It might have a bearing on your chances, but your strategy still seems the best one given the situation.
– Noah Snyder
7 hours ago
add a comment
|
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
In my view, strong letters are extremely important. You certainly don't want any letters from people interested in sabotaging you in any way. Even poorly written letters can be a setback. So can letters written by non-native speakers who may not grok the nuances of certain phrases.
There is the concept of Damning with Faint Praise that can be absolutely deadly in a letter. It can be intentional or not, actually.
Get letters from people who know your potential and are willing to speak for it. They need to know about your past work, of course, but people will be looking for potential and how it relates to a particular position.
If you have any doubts about what a person might say, ask them about it, or go elsewhere. In certain situations (non-native speakers, say) you might even request that a letter writer check their letter with a neutral third party, such as a department head. This would have saved me tremendous grief long ago.
Thank you for the suggestion. I can get strong letters from my previous advisors and the other known Profs. Since I am working with the present advisor currently, is it okay to apply without this advisor's letter? How should I defend if it is questioned in the interview?
– arn
7 hours ago
2
If a letter from your current advisor will harm your search, you must apply without a letter from your current advisor. Will that omission have an effect? Of course! But the effect of a negative or weak letter is far worse.
– JeffE
6 hours ago
1
"This would have saved me tremendous grief long ago." Is that a story you can share?
– darij grinberg
2 hours ago
1
@darijgrinberg, I had a great advisor who wrote me a great letter if you knew how he meant it. Unfortunately he was Czech (not a native English speaker) and a classically educated mathematician. His description of my essential knowledge (classical real analysis) made it sound like all I knew was Calculus. Of course, both of us knew what he meant, but it was years before another faculty member reviewed that letter and saw the implication. Moreover it was a difficult time to get an academic job in math (70's).
– Buffy
2 hours ago
1
@Buffy: Ah, the classical European humility plus the non-existent separation between calculus and analysis outside of the US :)
– darij grinberg
2 hours ago
|
show 2 more comments
There is no problem in asking other people than your postdoc host to provide letters for you. It is you who decide who to ask, and recruitment committees will probably not even notice, nor will care whether your postdoc host is missing (unless there exists a special relation between a committee member and the host, in which case you can still not ask the host for a letter).
add a comment
|
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function()
var channelOptions =
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "415"
;
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
createEditor();
);
else
createEditor();
);
function createEditor()
StackExchange.prepareEditor(
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: true,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: 10,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader:
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/"u003ecc by-sa 4.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
,
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
);
);
arn is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2facademia.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f137129%2fimportance-of-the-current-postdoc-advisors-letter-in-tt-job-search%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
In my view, strong letters are extremely important. You certainly don't want any letters from people interested in sabotaging you in any way. Even poorly written letters can be a setback. So can letters written by non-native speakers who may not grok the nuances of certain phrases.
There is the concept of Damning with Faint Praise that can be absolutely deadly in a letter. It can be intentional or not, actually.
Get letters from people who know your potential and are willing to speak for it. They need to know about your past work, of course, but people will be looking for potential and how it relates to a particular position.
If you have any doubts about what a person might say, ask them about it, or go elsewhere. In certain situations (non-native speakers, say) you might even request that a letter writer check their letter with a neutral third party, such as a department head. This would have saved me tremendous grief long ago.
Thank you for the suggestion. I can get strong letters from my previous advisors and the other known Profs. Since I am working with the present advisor currently, is it okay to apply without this advisor's letter? How should I defend if it is questioned in the interview?
– arn
7 hours ago
2
If a letter from your current advisor will harm your search, you must apply without a letter from your current advisor. Will that omission have an effect? Of course! But the effect of a negative or weak letter is far worse.
– JeffE
6 hours ago
1
"This would have saved me tremendous grief long ago." Is that a story you can share?
– darij grinberg
2 hours ago
1
@darijgrinberg, I had a great advisor who wrote me a great letter if you knew how he meant it. Unfortunately he was Czech (not a native English speaker) and a classically educated mathematician. His description of my essential knowledge (classical real analysis) made it sound like all I knew was Calculus. Of course, both of us knew what he meant, but it was years before another faculty member reviewed that letter and saw the implication. Moreover it was a difficult time to get an academic job in math (70's).
– Buffy
2 hours ago
1
@Buffy: Ah, the classical European humility plus the non-existent separation between calculus and analysis outside of the US :)
– darij grinberg
2 hours ago
|
show 2 more comments
In my view, strong letters are extremely important. You certainly don't want any letters from people interested in sabotaging you in any way. Even poorly written letters can be a setback. So can letters written by non-native speakers who may not grok the nuances of certain phrases.
There is the concept of Damning with Faint Praise that can be absolutely deadly in a letter. It can be intentional or not, actually.
Get letters from people who know your potential and are willing to speak for it. They need to know about your past work, of course, but people will be looking for potential and how it relates to a particular position.
If you have any doubts about what a person might say, ask them about it, or go elsewhere. In certain situations (non-native speakers, say) you might even request that a letter writer check their letter with a neutral third party, such as a department head. This would have saved me tremendous grief long ago.
Thank you for the suggestion. I can get strong letters from my previous advisors and the other known Profs. Since I am working with the present advisor currently, is it okay to apply without this advisor's letter? How should I defend if it is questioned in the interview?
– arn
7 hours ago
2
If a letter from your current advisor will harm your search, you must apply without a letter from your current advisor. Will that omission have an effect? Of course! But the effect of a negative or weak letter is far worse.
– JeffE
6 hours ago
1
"This would have saved me tremendous grief long ago." Is that a story you can share?
– darij grinberg
2 hours ago
1
@darijgrinberg, I had a great advisor who wrote me a great letter if you knew how he meant it. Unfortunately he was Czech (not a native English speaker) and a classically educated mathematician. His description of my essential knowledge (classical real analysis) made it sound like all I knew was Calculus. Of course, both of us knew what he meant, but it was years before another faculty member reviewed that letter and saw the implication. Moreover it was a difficult time to get an academic job in math (70's).
– Buffy
2 hours ago
1
@Buffy: Ah, the classical European humility plus the non-existent separation between calculus and analysis outside of the US :)
– darij grinberg
2 hours ago
|
show 2 more comments
In my view, strong letters are extremely important. You certainly don't want any letters from people interested in sabotaging you in any way. Even poorly written letters can be a setback. So can letters written by non-native speakers who may not grok the nuances of certain phrases.
There is the concept of Damning with Faint Praise that can be absolutely deadly in a letter. It can be intentional or not, actually.
Get letters from people who know your potential and are willing to speak for it. They need to know about your past work, of course, but people will be looking for potential and how it relates to a particular position.
If you have any doubts about what a person might say, ask them about it, or go elsewhere. In certain situations (non-native speakers, say) you might even request that a letter writer check their letter with a neutral third party, such as a department head. This would have saved me tremendous grief long ago.
In my view, strong letters are extremely important. You certainly don't want any letters from people interested in sabotaging you in any way. Even poorly written letters can be a setback. So can letters written by non-native speakers who may not grok the nuances of certain phrases.
There is the concept of Damning with Faint Praise that can be absolutely deadly in a letter. It can be intentional or not, actually.
Get letters from people who know your potential and are willing to speak for it. They need to know about your past work, of course, but people will be looking for potential and how it relates to a particular position.
If you have any doubts about what a person might say, ask them about it, or go elsewhere. In certain situations (non-native speakers, say) you might even request that a letter writer check their letter with a neutral third party, such as a department head. This would have saved me tremendous grief long ago.
answered 8 hours ago
BuffyBuffy
82.9k21 gold badges253 silver badges363 bronze badges
82.9k21 gold badges253 silver badges363 bronze badges
Thank you for the suggestion. I can get strong letters from my previous advisors and the other known Profs. Since I am working with the present advisor currently, is it okay to apply without this advisor's letter? How should I defend if it is questioned in the interview?
– arn
7 hours ago
2
If a letter from your current advisor will harm your search, you must apply without a letter from your current advisor. Will that omission have an effect? Of course! But the effect of a negative or weak letter is far worse.
– JeffE
6 hours ago
1
"This would have saved me tremendous grief long ago." Is that a story you can share?
– darij grinberg
2 hours ago
1
@darijgrinberg, I had a great advisor who wrote me a great letter if you knew how he meant it. Unfortunately he was Czech (not a native English speaker) and a classically educated mathematician. His description of my essential knowledge (classical real analysis) made it sound like all I knew was Calculus. Of course, both of us knew what he meant, but it was years before another faculty member reviewed that letter and saw the implication. Moreover it was a difficult time to get an academic job in math (70's).
– Buffy
2 hours ago
1
@Buffy: Ah, the classical European humility plus the non-existent separation between calculus and analysis outside of the US :)
– darij grinberg
2 hours ago
|
show 2 more comments
Thank you for the suggestion. I can get strong letters from my previous advisors and the other known Profs. Since I am working with the present advisor currently, is it okay to apply without this advisor's letter? How should I defend if it is questioned in the interview?
– arn
7 hours ago
2
If a letter from your current advisor will harm your search, you must apply without a letter from your current advisor. Will that omission have an effect? Of course! But the effect of a negative or weak letter is far worse.
– JeffE
6 hours ago
1
"This would have saved me tremendous grief long ago." Is that a story you can share?
– darij grinberg
2 hours ago
1
@darijgrinberg, I had a great advisor who wrote me a great letter if you knew how he meant it. Unfortunately he was Czech (not a native English speaker) and a classically educated mathematician. His description of my essential knowledge (classical real analysis) made it sound like all I knew was Calculus. Of course, both of us knew what he meant, but it was years before another faculty member reviewed that letter and saw the implication. Moreover it was a difficult time to get an academic job in math (70's).
– Buffy
2 hours ago
1
@Buffy: Ah, the classical European humility plus the non-existent separation between calculus and analysis outside of the US :)
– darij grinberg
2 hours ago
Thank you for the suggestion. I can get strong letters from my previous advisors and the other known Profs. Since I am working with the present advisor currently, is it okay to apply without this advisor's letter? How should I defend if it is questioned in the interview?
– arn
7 hours ago
Thank you for the suggestion. I can get strong letters from my previous advisors and the other known Profs. Since I am working with the present advisor currently, is it okay to apply without this advisor's letter? How should I defend if it is questioned in the interview?
– arn
7 hours ago
2
2
If a letter from your current advisor will harm your search, you must apply without a letter from your current advisor. Will that omission have an effect? Of course! But the effect of a negative or weak letter is far worse.
– JeffE
6 hours ago
If a letter from your current advisor will harm your search, you must apply without a letter from your current advisor. Will that omission have an effect? Of course! But the effect of a negative or weak letter is far worse.
– JeffE
6 hours ago
1
1
"This would have saved me tremendous grief long ago." Is that a story you can share?
– darij grinberg
2 hours ago
"This would have saved me tremendous grief long ago." Is that a story you can share?
– darij grinberg
2 hours ago
1
1
@darijgrinberg, I had a great advisor who wrote me a great letter if you knew how he meant it. Unfortunately he was Czech (not a native English speaker) and a classically educated mathematician. His description of my essential knowledge (classical real analysis) made it sound like all I knew was Calculus. Of course, both of us knew what he meant, but it was years before another faculty member reviewed that letter and saw the implication. Moreover it was a difficult time to get an academic job in math (70's).
– Buffy
2 hours ago
@darijgrinberg, I had a great advisor who wrote me a great letter if you knew how he meant it. Unfortunately he was Czech (not a native English speaker) and a classically educated mathematician. His description of my essential knowledge (classical real analysis) made it sound like all I knew was Calculus. Of course, both of us knew what he meant, but it was years before another faculty member reviewed that letter and saw the implication. Moreover it was a difficult time to get an academic job in math (70's).
– Buffy
2 hours ago
1
1
@Buffy: Ah, the classical European humility plus the non-existent separation between calculus and analysis outside of the US :)
– darij grinberg
2 hours ago
@Buffy: Ah, the classical European humility plus the non-existent separation between calculus and analysis outside of the US :)
– darij grinberg
2 hours ago
|
show 2 more comments
There is no problem in asking other people than your postdoc host to provide letters for you. It is you who decide who to ask, and recruitment committees will probably not even notice, nor will care whether your postdoc host is missing (unless there exists a special relation between a committee member and the host, in which case you can still not ask the host for a letter).
add a comment
|
There is no problem in asking other people than your postdoc host to provide letters for you. It is you who decide who to ask, and recruitment committees will probably not even notice, nor will care whether your postdoc host is missing (unless there exists a special relation between a committee member and the host, in which case you can still not ask the host for a letter).
add a comment
|
There is no problem in asking other people than your postdoc host to provide letters for you. It is you who decide who to ask, and recruitment committees will probably not even notice, nor will care whether your postdoc host is missing (unless there exists a special relation between a committee member and the host, in which case you can still not ask the host for a letter).
There is no problem in asking other people than your postdoc host to provide letters for you. It is you who decide who to ask, and recruitment committees will probably not even notice, nor will care whether your postdoc host is missing (unless there exists a special relation between a committee member and the host, in which case you can still not ask the host for a letter).
answered 2 hours ago
DilworthDilworth
4,42914 silver badges24 bronze badges
4,42914 silver badges24 bronze badges
add a comment
|
add a comment
|
arn is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
arn is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
arn is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
arn is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Thanks for contributing an answer to Academia Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2facademia.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f137129%2fimportance-of-the-current-postdoc-advisors-letter-in-tt-job-search%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
It might have a bearing on your chances, but your strategy still seems the best one given the situation.
– Noah Snyder
7 hours ago