What halachos of mourning apply to a grandchild for his grandparent's death?What is the purpose of the laws of mourning?What types of hair - and whose hair - are included in mourning-related hair-cutting prohibitions?Is the mourning for a late relative dependent on the state of their relationship before death?Practical Halachas after death of a close relativeDoes a mourner tear one garment, or every garment he wears for a period of time?Throwing dust on head = common mourning ritual?Was it customary for there to be an annual lamentation for someone's death, e.g. the daughter of Jephthah? Details as to her mourning process?What is the origin and reason for mourners to sit on the floor or low seat?Are there special Halachos for homeowners?Do the stringencies for someone who is cremated apply if they didn’t specify/want to be cremated?

Reference for electronegativities of different metal oxidation states

How do we explain the use of a software on a math paper?

Vehemently against code formatting

What does it mean for a program to be 32 or 64 bit?

Bash - Execute two commands and get exit status 1 if first fails

How can sister protect herself from impulse purchases with a credit card?

Is it wise to pay off mortgage with 401k?

Can I have a delimited macro with a literal # in the parameter text?

How could the B-29 bomber back up under its own power?

Gambler's Fallacy Dice

Why aren't satellites disintegrated even though they orbit earth within earth's Roche Limits?

Addressing an email

Would it be possible to set up a franchise in the ancient world?

Is there any official Lore on Keraptis the Wizard, apart from what is in White Plume Mountain?

Cycling to work - 30 mile return

Should I twist DC power and ground wires from a power supply?

How to fix "webpack Dev Server Invalid Options" in Vuejs

Can the bitcoin lightning network support more than 8 decimal places?

Precedent for disabled Kings

Does the Aboleth have expertise in history and perception?

Chain rule instead of product rule

Failing students when it might cause them economic ruin

pwaS eht tirsf dna tasl setterl fo hace dorw

Why could the Lunar Ascent Engine be used only once?



What halachos of mourning apply to a grandchild for his grandparent's death?


What is the purpose of the laws of mourning?What types of hair - and whose hair - are included in mourning-related hair-cutting prohibitions?Is the mourning for a late relative dependent on the state of their relationship before death?Practical Halachas after death of a close relativeDoes a mourner tear one garment, or every garment he wears for a period of time?Throwing dust on head = common mourning ritual?Was it customary for there to be an annual lamentation for someone's death, e.g. the daughter of Jephthah? Details as to her mourning process?What is the origin and reason for mourners to sit on the floor or low seat?Are there special Halachos for homeowners?Do the stringencies for someone who is cremated apply if they didn’t specify/want to be cremated?













2















What halachos of mourning, if any, apply to a grandchild upon his or her grandparent's death? Do they tear keri'ah upon hearing of the grandparent's death? Do they sit shivah?










share|improve this question



















  • 1





    Unfortunate is the grandchild who never needed to mourn their grandparent.

    – Double AA
    4 hours ago












  • @DoubleAA Not exactly what I intended when saying that, but I see how my language lends itself to that. Will edit.

    – DonielF
    4 hours ago















2















What halachos of mourning, if any, apply to a grandchild upon his or her grandparent's death? Do they tear keri'ah upon hearing of the grandparent's death? Do they sit shivah?










share|improve this question



















  • 1





    Unfortunate is the grandchild who never needed to mourn their grandparent.

    – Double AA
    4 hours ago












  • @DoubleAA Not exactly what I intended when saying that, but I see how my language lends itself to that. Will edit.

    – DonielF
    4 hours ago













2












2








2








What halachos of mourning, if any, apply to a grandchild upon his or her grandparent's death? Do they tear keri'ah upon hearing of the grandparent's death? Do they sit shivah?










share|improve this question
















What halachos of mourning, if any, apply to a grandchild upon his or her grandparent's death? Do they tear keri'ah upon hearing of the grandparent's death? Do they sit shivah?







halacha mourning-aveilus






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited 4 hours ago







DonielF

















asked 5 hours ago









DonielFDonielF

18.1k12693




18.1k12693







  • 1





    Unfortunate is the grandchild who never needed to mourn their grandparent.

    – Double AA
    4 hours ago












  • @DoubleAA Not exactly what I intended when saying that, but I see how my language lends itself to that. Will edit.

    – DonielF
    4 hours ago












  • 1





    Unfortunate is the grandchild who never needed to mourn their grandparent.

    – Double AA
    4 hours ago












  • @DoubleAA Not exactly what I intended when saying that, but I see how my language lends itself to that. Will edit.

    – DonielF
    4 hours ago







1




1





Unfortunate is the grandchild who never needed to mourn their grandparent.

– Double AA
4 hours ago






Unfortunate is the grandchild who never needed to mourn their grandparent.

– Double AA
4 hours ago














@DoubleAA Not exactly what I intended when saying that, but I see how my language lends itself to that. Will edit.

– DonielF
4 hours ago





@DoubleAA Not exactly what I intended when saying that, but I see how my language lends itself to that. Will edit.

– DonielF
4 hours ago










1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes


















2














Upon hearing bad news, one says the blessing ברוך אתה יקוק אלוקינו מלך העולם דיין האמת"‏" (OC 222:2).



Regarding mourning, the Shulchan Arukh rules (YD 374.6):




כל מי שמתאבל עליו מתאבל עמו אם מת לו מת ודוקא בעודו בפניו אבל שלא בפניו אין צריך לנהוג אבלות...: הגה וי"א דהאידנא נוהגין להקל באבילות זה של המתאבלים עמו דאין זה אלא משום כבוד המתאבלים ועכשיו נהגו כולם למחול וכן נוהגין האידנא שלא להתאבל כלל עם המתאבלים וכל המחמיר בזה אינו אלא מן המתמיהים (הגהות מיימוני פ"ב) ומ"מ נהגו שכל קרובי המת הפסולים לו לעדות מראים קצת אבילות בעצמן כל שבוע הראשונה דהיינו עד אחר שבת הראשון שאינם רוחצים ואין משנים קצת בגדיהם כמו בשאר שבת ויש מקומות שנהגו עוד להחמיר בענינים אחרים והעיקר כמו שכתבתי ... מי שרוצה להחמיר על עצמו להתאבל על מי שאינו צריך או ללבוש שחורים על קרובו אין מוחין בידו



Whomever he mourns for he [also] mourns with if he suffers a breavement. [This applies] only whilst he is in his presence, but when not in his presence, he is not bound to observe mourning rites... Gloss: Some say that nowadays we adopt a lenient view regarding this [type] of mourning with respect to those who mourn with him, for this is only out of respect to those who observe mourning rites, but now it is the common practice to forego [this honour], and thus is the accepted practice nowadays, [viz.,] not to mourn at all with those who observe mourning rites. He who adopts a stringent view in this [matter] is one of those who make people wonder [at their strange conduct]. Nevertheless, it is the accepted practice that all the near-of-kin of the dead person who are disqualified to offer testimony in his behalf, exhibit some [signs] of mourning [by placing] themselves [under this stringency] the first entire week, i.e., until after the first Sabbath [in] that they do not wash [themselves] nor change some of their clothes as on other Sabbaths. There are, however, localities where the accepted usage is to adopt additional stringencies in other matters [pertaining to this type of mourning], but the fundamental principle is as I have written [above]... One who desires to place himself under a stringency, [viz.,] to observe mourning rites for one for whom he is not dutibound [to mourn], or to put on dark clothes [in mourning] for his near-of-kin, is not reproved [for doing so].




Regarding tearing clothing, the Shulchan Arukh rules (YD 340:4):




כשם שקורע על קרובו שמתאבל עליו כך קורע בפני קרובו על מת שמת לקרובו כיצד הרי שמת בן בנו או אחי בנו או אם בנו חייב לקרוע בפני בנו וכן קורע על חמיו וחמותו והאשה קורעת על חמיה וחמותה. (ואין נוהגין עכשיו כן וכמו שיתבאר לקמן סי' שע"ד לענין אבלות):‏



Just as he rends for his near-of-kin, for whom he observes mourning rites, so does he rend in the presence of his near-of-kin, when the latter sustains a bereavement. In what respect? If his son's son dies, or his son's brother, or the mother of his son, he is required to rend in the presence of his son. So too, does he rend for his father-in-law and his mother-in-law, and a woman rends for her father-in-law and her mother-in-law. (Nowadays we do not follow this practice as will be explained infra §374 in the subject of mourning.)




In short, if the mourners insist the grandchild would have to act like a mourner in pretty much all respects while in front of them. Commonly though the mourners do not insist. Use of common sense to fit in and not offend the mourners is key.



(I'll say that even stronger: the grandchild is not in the thick of it like his parent is and is in a unique position to offer much needed support, so helping his parent in whatever way works best in their situation is a enormous act of kindness and is to be actively encouraged. Forget about the technical laws and do whatever is best for the real mourners which might indeed mean looking distraught and not shaving or bathing, but might not. Focus on the goal here not on the means.)



You can find some discussion in Rishonim trying to obligate grandchildren in particular in more mourning due to the obligation to honor a grandparent in Or Zarua 2:428.






share|improve this answer

























  • 1. To where in §374 is he referring? 2. If the mourners don’t insist/he’s not in the presence of the mourners, is the grandchild allowed to follow Hilchos Aveilus, but he’s not obligated to do so, or is it prohibited? 3. Likewise for keri’ah - is he saying the custom is not to tear, but one could if he wants to, or that one shouldn’t tear?

    – DonielF
    3 hours ago











  • @DonielF 1 presumably 374:6 which I cited first so you'd get it, even though it's out of order. 2 the rama there says clearly in that source that one who does mourning for someone he doesn't need to "isn't reproved", but also that mourning too much for a second degree relative would make you מן המתמיהים bizarre. 3 wasteful tearing is prohibited as bal tashchis (though if the grandparent was the grandchild's teacher or was a respected person it may not be considered wasteful, but that's a general question not specifically for grandparent)

    – Double AA
    3 hours ago



















1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes








1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes









active

oldest

votes






active

oldest

votes









2














Upon hearing bad news, one says the blessing ברוך אתה יקוק אלוקינו מלך העולם דיין האמת"‏" (OC 222:2).



Regarding mourning, the Shulchan Arukh rules (YD 374.6):




כל מי שמתאבל עליו מתאבל עמו אם מת לו מת ודוקא בעודו בפניו אבל שלא בפניו אין צריך לנהוג אבלות...: הגה וי"א דהאידנא נוהגין להקל באבילות זה של המתאבלים עמו דאין זה אלא משום כבוד המתאבלים ועכשיו נהגו כולם למחול וכן נוהגין האידנא שלא להתאבל כלל עם המתאבלים וכל המחמיר בזה אינו אלא מן המתמיהים (הגהות מיימוני פ"ב) ומ"מ נהגו שכל קרובי המת הפסולים לו לעדות מראים קצת אבילות בעצמן כל שבוע הראשונה דהיינו עד אחר שבת הראשון שאינם רוחצים ואין משנים קצת בגדיהם כמו בשאר שבת ויש מקומות שנהגו עוד להחמיר בענינים אחרים והעיקר כמו שכתבתי ... מי שרוצה להחמיר על עצמו להתאבל על מי שאינו צריך או ללבוש שחורים על קרובו אין מוחין בידו



Whomever he mourns for he [also] mourns with if he suffers a breavement. [This applies] only whilst he is in his presence, but when not in his presence, he is not bound to observe mourning rites... Gloss: Some say that nowadays we adopt a lenient view regarding this [type] of mourning with respect to those who mourn with him, for this is only out of respect to those who observe mourning rites, but now it is the common practice to forego [this honour], and thus is the accepted practice nowadays, [viz.,] not to mourn at all with those who observe mourning rites. He who adopts a stringent view in this [matter] is one of those who make people wonder [at their strange conduct]. Nevertheless, it is the accepted practice that all the near-of-kin of the dead person who are disqualified to offer testimony in his behalf, exhibit some [signs] of mourning [by placing] themselves [under this stringency] the first entire week, i.e., until after the first Sabbath [in] that they do not wash [themselves] nor change some of their clothes as on other Sabbaths. There are, however, localities where the accepted usage is to adopt additional stringencies in other matters [pertaining to this type of mourning], but the fundamental principle is as I have written [above]... One who desires to place himself under a stringency, [viz.,] to observe mourning rites for one for whom he is not dutibound [to mourn], or to put on dark clothes [in mourning] for his near-of-kin, is not reproved [for doing so].




Regarding tearing clothing, the Shulchan Arukh rules (YD 340:4):




כשם שקורע על קרובו שמתאבל עליו כך קורע בפני קרובו על מת שמת לקרובו כיצד הרי שמת בן בנו או אחי בנו או אם בנו חייב לקרוע בפני בנו וכן קורע על חמיו וחמותו והאשה קורעת על חמיה וחמותה. (ואין נוהגין עכשיו כן וכמו שיתבאר לקמן סי' שע"ד לענין אבלות):‏



Just as he rends for his near-of-kin, for whom he observes mourning rites, so does he rend in the presence of his near-of-kin, when the latter sustains a bereavement. In what respect? If his son's son dies, or his son's brother, or the mother of his son, he is required to rend in the presence of his son. So too, does he rend for his father-in-law and his mother-in-law, and a woman rends for her father-in-law and her mother-in-law. (Nowadays we do not follow this practice as will be explained infra §374 in the subject of mourning.)




In short, if the mourners insist the grandchild would have to act like a mourner in pretty much all respects while in front of them. Commonly though the mourners do not insist. Use of common sense to fit in and not offend the mourners is key.



(I'll say that even stronger: the grandchild is not in the thick of it like his parent is and is in a unique position to offer much needed support, so helping his parent in whatever way works best in their situation is a enormous act of kindness and is to be actively encouraged. Forget about the technical laws and do whatever is best for the real mourners which might indeed mean looking distraught and not shaving or bathing, but might not. Focus on the goal here not on the means.)



You can find some discussion in Rishonim trying to obligate grandchildren in particular in more mourning due to the obligation to honor a grandparent in Or Zarua 2:428.






share|improve this answer

























  • 1. To where in §374 is he referring? 2. If the mourners don’t insist/he’s not in the presence of the mourners, is the grandchild allowed to follow Hilchos Aveilus, but he’s not obligated to do so, or is it prohibited? 3. Likewise for keri’ah - is he saying the custom is not to tear, but one could if he wants to, or that one shouldn’t tear?

    – DonielF
    3 hours ago











  • @DonielF 1 presumably 374:6 which I cited first so you'd get it, even though it's out of order. 2 the rama there says clearly in that source that one who does mourning for someone he doesn't need to "isn't reproved", but also that mourning too much for a second degree relative would make you מן המתמיהים bizarre. 3 wasteful tearing is prohibited as bal tashchis (though if the grandparent was the grandchild's teacher or was a respected person it may not be considered wasteful, but that's a general question not specifically for grandparent)

    – Double AA
    3 hours ago
















2














Upon hearing bad news, one says the blessing ברוך אתה יקוק אלוקינו מלך העולם דיין האמת"‏" (OC 222:2).



Regarding mourning, the Shulchan Arukh rules (YD 374.6):




כל מי שמתאבל עליו מתאבל עמו אם מת לו מת ודוקא בעודו בפניו אבל שלא בפניו אין צריך לנהוג אבלות...: הגה וי"א דהאידנא נוהגין להקל באבילות זה של המתאבלים עמו דאין זה אלא משום כבוד המתאבלים ועכשיו נהגו כולם למחול וכן נוהגין האידנא שלא להתאבל כלל עם המתאבלים וכל המחמיר בזה אינו אלא מן המתמיהים (הגהות מיימוני פ"ב) ומ"מ נהגו שכל קרובי המת הפסולים לו לעדות מראים קצת אבילות בעצמן כל שבוע הראשונה דהיינו עד אחר שבת הראשון שאינם רוחצים ואין משנים קצת בגדיהם כמו בשאר שבת ויש מקומות שנהגו עוד להחמיר בענינים אחרים והעיקר כמו שכתבתי ... מי שרוצה להחמיר על עצמו להתאבל על מי שאינו צריך או ללבוש שחורים על קרובו אין מוחין בידו



Whomever he mourns for he [also] mourns with if he suffers a breavement. [This applies] only whilst he is in his presence, but when not in his presence, he is not bound to observe mourning rites... Gloss: Some say that nowadays we adopt a lenient view regarding this [type] of mourning with respect to those who mourn with him, for this is only out of respect to those who observe mourning rites, but now it is the common practice to forego [this honour], and thus is the accepted practice nowadays, [viz.,] not to mourn at all with those who observe mourning rites. He who adopts a stringent view in this [matter] is one of those who make people wonder [at their strange conduct]. Nevertheless, it is the accepted practice that all the near-of-kin of the dead person who are disqualified to offer testimony in his behalf, exhibit some [signs] of mourning [by placing] themselves [under this stringency] the first entire week, i.e., until after the first Sabbath [in] that they do not wash [themselves] nor change some of their clothes as on other Sabbaths. There are, however, localities where the accepted usage is to adopt additional stringencies in other matters [pertaining to this type of mourning], but the fundamental principle is as I have written [above]... One who desires to place himself under a stringency, [viz.,] to observe mourning rites for one for whom he is not dutibound [to mourn], or to put on dark clothes [in mourning] for his near-of-kin, is not reproved [for doing so].




Regarding tearing clothing, the Shulchan Arukh rules (YD 340:4):




כשם שקורע על קרובו שמתאבל עליו כך קורע בפני קרובו על מת שמת לקרובו כיצד הרי שמת בן בנו או אחי בנו או אם בנו חייב לקרוע בפני בנו וכן קורע על חמיו וחמותו והאשה קורעת על חמיה וחמותה. (ואין נוהגין עכשיו כן וכמו שיתבאר לקמן סי' שע"ד לענין אבלות):‏



Just as he rends for his near-of-kin, for whom he observes mourning rites, so does he rend in the presence of his near-of-kin, when the latter sustains a bereavement. In what respect? If his son's son dies, or his son's brother, or the mother of his son, he is required to rend in the presence of his son. So too, does he rend for his father-in-law and his mother-in-law, and a woman rends for her father-in-law and her mother-in-law. (Nowadays we do not follow this practice as will be explained infra §374 in the subject of mourning.)




In short, if the mourners insist the grandchild would have to act like a mourner in pretty much all respects while in front of them. Commonly though the mourners do not insist. Use of common sense to fit in and not offend the mourners is key.



(I'll say that even stronger: the grandchild is not in the thick of it like his parent is and is in a unique position to offer much needed support, so helping his parent in whatever way works best in their situation is a enormous act of kindness and is to be actively encouraged. Forget about the technical laws and do whatever is best for the real mourners which might indeed mean looking distraught and not shaving or bathing, but might not. Focus on the goal here not on the means.)



You can find some discussion in Rishonim trying to obligate grandchildren in particular in more mourning due to the obligation to honor a grandparent in Or Zarua 2:428.






share|improve this answer

























  • 1. To where in §374 is he referring? 2. If the mourners don’t insist/he’s not in the presence of the mourners, is the grandchild allowed to follow Hilchos Aveilus, but he’s not obligated to do so, or is it prohibited? 3. Likewise for keri’ah - is he saying the custom is not to tear, but one could if he wants to, or that one shouldn’t tear?

    – DonielF
    3 hours ago











  • @DonielF 1 presumably 374:6 which I cited first so you'd get it, even though it's out of order. 2 the rama there says clearly in that source that one who does mourning for someone he doesn't need to "isn't reproved", but also that mourning too much for a second degree relative would make you מן המתמיהים bizarre. 3 wasteful tearing is prohibited as bal tashchis (though if the grandparent was the grandchild's teacher or was a respected person it may not be considered wasteful, but that's a general question not specifically for grandparent)

    – Double AA
    3 hours ago














2












2








2







Upon hearing bad news, one says the blessing ברוך אתה יקוק אלוקינו מלך העולם דיין האמת"‏" (OC 222:2).



Regarding mourning, the Shulchan Arukh rules (YD 374.6):




כל מי שמתאבל עליו מתאבל עמו אם מת לו מת ודוקא בעודו בפניו אבל שלא בפניו אין צריך לנהוג אבלות...: הגה וי"א דהאידנא נוהגין להקל באבילות זה של המתאבלים עמו דאין זה אלא משום כבוד המתאבלים ועכשיו נהגו כולם למחול וכן נוהגין האידנא שלא להתאבל כלל עם המתאבלים וכל המחמיר בזה אינו אלא מן המתמיהים (הגהות מיימוני פ"ב) ומ"מ נהגו שכל קרובי המת הפסולים לו לעדות מראים קצת אבילות בעצמן כל שבוע הראשונה דהיינו עד אחר שבת הראשון שאינם רוחצים ואין משנים קצת בגדיהם כמו בשאר שבת ויש מקומות שנהגו עוד להחמיר בענינים אחרים והעיקר כמו שכתבתי ... מי שרוצה להחמיר על עצמו להתאבל על מי שאינו צריך או ללבוש שחורים על קרובו אין מוחין בידו



Whomever he mourns for he [also] mourns with if he suffers a breavement. [This applies] only whilst he is in his presence, but when not in his presence, he is not bound to observe mourning rites... Gloss: Some say that nowadays we adopt a lenient view regarding this [type] of mourning with respect to those who mourn with him, for this is only out of respect to those who observe mourning rites, but now it is the common practice to forego [this honour], and thus is the accepted practice nowadays, [viz.,] not to mourn at all with those who observe mourning rites. He who adopts a stringent view in this [matter] is one of those who make people wonder [at their strange conduct]. Nevertheless, it is the accepted practice that all the near-of-kin of the dead person who are disqualified to offer testimony in his behalf, exhibit some [signs] of mourning [by placing] themselves [under this stringency] the first entire week, i.e., until after the first Sabbath [in] that they do not wash [themselves] nor change some of their clothes as on other Sabbaths. There are, however, localities where the accepted usage is to adopt additional stringencies in other matters [pertaining to this type of mourning], but the fundamental principle is as I have written [above]... One who desires to place himself under a stringency, [viz.,] to observe mourning rites for one for whom he is not dutibound [to mourn], or to put on dark clothes [in mourning] for his near-of-kin, is not reproved [for doing so].




Regarding tearing clothing, the Shulchan Arukh rules (YD 340:4):




כשם שקורע על קרובו שמתאבל עליו כך קורע בפני קרובו על מת שמת לקרובו כיצד הרי שמת בן בנו או אחי בנו או אם בנו חייב לקרוע בפני בנו וכן קורע על חמיו וחמותו והאשה קורעת על חמיה וחמותה. (ואין נוהגין עכשיו כן וכמו שיתבאר לקמן סי' שע"ד לענין אבלות):‏



Just as he rends for his near-of-kin, for whom he observes mourning rites, so does he rend in the presence of his near-of-kin, when the latter sustains a bereavement. In what respect? If his son's son dies, or his son's brother, or the mother of his son, he is required to rend in the presence of his son. So too, does he rend for his father-in-law and his mother-in-law, and a woman rends for her father-in-law and her mother-in-law. (Nowadays we do not follow this practice as will be explained infra §374 in the subject of mourning.)




In short, if the mourners insist the grandchild would have to act like a mourner in pretty much all respects while in front of them. Commonly though the mourners do not insist. Use of common sense to fit in and not offend the mourners is key.



(I'll say that even stronger: the grandchild is not in the thick of it like his parent is and is in a unique position to offer much needed support, so helping his parent in whatever way works best in their situation is a enormous act of kindness and is to be actively encouraged. Forget about the technical laws and do whatever is best for the real mourners which might indeed mean looking distraught and not shaving or bathing, but might not. Focus on the goal here not on the means.)



You can find some discussion in Rishonim trying to obligate grandchildren in particular in more mourning due to the obligation to honor a grandparent in Or Zarua 2:428.






share|improve this answer















Upon hearing bad news, one says the blessing ברוך אתה יקוק אלוקינו מלך העולם דיין האמת"‏" (OC 222:2).



Regarding mourning, the Shulchan Arukh rules (YD 374.6):




כל מי שמתאבל עליו מתאבל עמו אם מת לו מת ודוקא בעודו בפניו אבל שלא בפניו אין צריך לנהוג אבלות...: הגה וי"א דהאידנא נוהגין להקל באבילות זה של המתאבלים עמו דאין זה אלא משום כבוד המתאבלים ועכשיו נהגו כולם למחול וכן נוהגין האידנא שלא להתאבל כלל עם המתאבלים וכל המחמיר בזה אינו אלא מן המתמיהים (הגהות מיימוני פ"ב) ומ"מ נהגו שכל קרובי המת הפסולים לו לעדות מראים קצת אבילות בעצמן כל שבוע הראשונה דהיינו עד אחר שבת הראשון שאינם רוחצים ואין משנים קצת בגדיהם כמו בשאר שבת ויש מקומות שנהגו עוד להחמיר בענינים אחרים והעיקר כמו שכתבתי ... מי שרוצה להחמיר על עצמו להתאבל על מי שאינו צריך או ללבוש שחורים על קרובו אין מוחין בידו



Whomever he mourns for he [also] mourns with if he suffers a breavement. [This applies] only whilst he is in his presence, but when not in his presence, he is not bound to observe mourning rites... Gloss: Some say that nowadays we adopt a lenient view regarding this [type] of mourning with respect to those who mourn with him, for this is only out of respect to those who observe mourning rites, but now it is the common practice to forego [this honour], and thus is the accepted practice nowadays, [viz.,] not to mourn at all with those who observe mourning rites. He who adopts a stringent view in this [matter] is one of those who make people wonder [at their strange conduct]. Nevertheless, it is the accepted practice that all the near-of-kin of the dead person who are disqualified to offer testimony in his behalf, exhibit some [signs] of mourning [by placing] themselves [under this stringency] the first entire week, i.e., until after the first Sabbath [in] that they do not wash [themselves] nor change some of their clothes as on other Sabbaths. There are, however, localities where the accepted usage is to adopt additional stringencies in other matters [pertaining to this type of mourning], but the fundamental principle is as I have written [above]... One who desires to place himself under a stringency, [viz.,] to observe mourning rites for one for whom he is not dutibound [to mourn], or to put on dark clothes [in mourning] for his near-of-kin, is not reproved [for doing so].




Regarding tearing clothing, the Shulchan Arukh rules (YD 340:4):




כשם שקורע על קרובו שמתאבל עליו כך קורע בפני קרובו על מת שמת לקרובו כיצד הרי שמת בן בנו או אחי בנו או אם בנו חייב לקרוע בפני בנו וכן קורע על חמיו וחמותו והאשה קורעת על חמיה וחמותה. (ואין נוהגין עכשיו כן וכמו שיתבאר לקמן סי' שע"ד לענין אבלות):‏



Just as he rends for his near-of-kin, for whom he observes mourning rites, so does he rend in the presence of his near-of-kin, when the latter sustains a bereavement. In what respect? If his son's son dies, or his son's brother, or the mother of his son, he is required to rend in the presence of his son. So too, does he rend for his father-in-law and his mother-in-law, and a woman rends for her father-in-law and her mother-in-law. (Nowadays we do not follow this practice as will be explained infra §374 in the subject of mourning.)




In short, if the mourners insist the grandchild would have to act like a mourner in pretty much all respects while in front of them. Commonly though the mourners do not insist. Use of common sense to fit in and not offend the mourners is key.



(I'll say that even stronger: the grandchild is not in the thick of it like his parent is and is in a unique position to offer much needed support, so helping his parent in whatever way works best in their situation is a enormous act of kindness and is to be actively encouraged. Forget about the technical laws and do whatever is best for the real mourners which might indeed mean looking distraught and not shaving or bathing, but might not. Focus on the goal here not on the means.)



You can find some discussion in Rishonim trying to obligate grandchildren in particular in more mourning due to the obligation to honor a grandparent in Or Zarua 2:428.







share|improve this answer














share|improve this answer



share|improve this answer








edited 3 hours ago

























answered 4 hours ago









Double AADouble AA

79.7k6198433




79.7k6198433












  • 1. To where in §374 is he referring? 2. If the mourners don’t insist/he’s not in the presence of the mourners, is the grandchild allowed to follow Hilchos Aveilus, but he’s not obligated to do so, or is it prohibited? 3. Likewise for keri’ah - is he saying the custom is not to tear, but one could if he wants to, or that one shouldn’t tear?

    – DonielF
    3 hours ago











  • @DonielF 1 presumably 374:6 which I cited first so you'd get it, even though it's out of order. 2 the rama there says clearly in that source that one who does mourning for someone he doesn't need to "isn't reproved", but also that mourning too much for a second degree relative would make you מן המתמיהים bizarre. 3 wasteful tearing is prohibited as bal tashchis (though if the grandparent was the grandchild's teacher or was a respected person it may not be considered wasteful, but that's a general question not specifically for grandparent)

    – Double AA
    3 hours ago


















  • 1. To where in §374 is he referring? 2. If the mourners don’t insist/he’s not in the presence of the mourners, is the grandchild allowed to follow Hilchos Aveilus, but he’s not obligated to do so, or is it prohibited? 3. Likewise for keri’ah - is he saying the custom is not to tear, but one could if he wants to, or that one shouldn’t tear?

    – DonielF
    3 hours ago











  • @DonielF 1 presumably 374:6 which I cited first so you'd get it, even though it's out of order. 2 the rama there says clearly in that source that one who does mourning for someone he doesn't need to "isn't reproved", but also that mourning too much for a second degree relative would make you מן המתמיהים bizarre. 3 wasteful tearing is prohibited as bal tashchis (though if the grandparent was the grandchild's teacher or was a respected person it may not be considered wasteful, but that's a general question not specifically for grandparent)

    – Double AA
    3 hours ago

















1. To where in §374 is he referring? 2. If the mourners don’t insist/he’s not in the presence of the mourners, is the grandchild allowed to follow Hilchos Aveilus, but he’s not obligated to do so, or is it prohibited? 3. Likewise for keri’ah - is he saying the custom is not to tear, but one could if he wants to, or that one shouldn’t tear?

– DonielF
3 hours ago





1. To where in §374 is he referring? 2. If the mourners don’t insist/he’s not in the presence of the mourners, is the grandchild allowed to follow Hilchos Aveilus, but he’s not obligated to do so, or is it prohibited? 3. Likewise for keri’ah - is he saying the custom is not to tear, but one could if he wants to, or that one shouldn’t tear?

– DonielF
3 hours ago













@DonielF 1 presumably 374:6 which I cited first so you'd get it, even though it's out of order. 2 the rama there says clearly in that source that one who does mourning for someone he doesn't need to "isn't reproved", but also that mourning too much for a second degree relative would make you מן המתמיהים bizarre. 3 wasteful tearing is prohibited as bal tashchis (though if the grandparent was the grandchild's teacher or was a respected person it may not be considered wasteful, but that's a general question not specifically for grandparent)

– Double AA
3 hours ago






@DonielF 1 presumably 374:6 which I cited first so you'd get it, even though it's out of order. 2 the rama there says clearly in that source that one who does mourning for someone he doesn't need to "isn't reproved", but also that mourning too much for a second degree relative would make you מן המתמיהים bizarre. 3 wasteful tearing is prohibited as bal tashchis (though if the grandparent was the grandchild's teacher or was a respected person it may not be considered wasteful, but that's a general question not specifically for grandparent)

– Double AA
3 hours ago




Popular posts from this blog

Invision Community Contents History See also References External links Navigation menuProprietaryinvisioncommunity.comIPS Community ForumsIPS Community Forumsthis blog entry"License Changes, IP.Board 3.4, and the Future""Interview -- Matt Mecham of Ibforums""CEO Invision Power Board, Matt Mecham Is a Liar, Thief!"IPB License Explanation 1.3, 1.3.1, 2.0, and 2.1ArchivedSecurity Fixes, Updates And Enhancements For IPB 1.3.1Archived"New Demo Accounts - Invision Power Services"the original"New Default Skin"the original"Invision Power Board 3.0.0 and Applications Released"the original"Archived copy"the original"Perpetual licenses being done away with""Release Notes - Invision Power Services""Introducing: IPS Community Suite 4!"Invision Community Release Notes

Canceling a color specificationRandomly assigning color to Graphics3D objects?Default color for Filling in Mathematica 9Coloring specific elements of sets with a prime modified order in an array plotHow to pick a color differing significantly from the colors already in a given color list?Detection of the text colorColor numbers based on their valueCan color schemes for use with ColorData include opacity specification?My dynamic color schemes

Tom Holland Mục lục Đầu đời và giáo dục | Sự nghiệp | Cuộc sống cá nhân | Phim tham gia | Giải thưởng và đề cử | Chú thích | Liên kết ngoài | Trình đơn chuyển hướngProfile“Person Details for Thomas Stanley Holland, "England and Wales Birth Registration Index, 1837-2008" — FamilySearch.org”"Meet Tom Holland... the 16-year-old star of The Impossible""Schoolboy actor Tom Holland finds himself in Oscar contention for role in tsunami drama"“Naomi Watts on the Prince William and Harry's reaction to her film about the late Princess Diana”lưu trữ"Holland and Pflueger Are West End's Two New 'Billy Elliots'""I'm so envious of my son, the movie star! British writer Dominic Holland's spent 20 years trying to crack Hollywood - but he's been beaten to it by a very unlikely rival"“Richard and Margaret Povey of Jersey, Channel Islands, UK: Information about Thomas Stanley Holland”"Tom Holland to play Billy Elliot""New Billy Elliot leaving the garage"Billy Elliot the Musical - Tom Holland - Billy"A Tale of four Billys: Tom Holland""The Feel Good Factor""Thames Christian College schoolboys join Myleene Klass for The Feelgood Factor""Government launches £600,000 arts bursaries pilot""BILLY's Chapman, Holland, Gardner & Jackson-Keen Visit Prime Minister""Elton John 'blown away' by Billy Elliot fifth birthday" (video with John's interview and fragments of Holland's performance)"First News interviews Arrietty's Tom Holland"“33rd Critics' Circle Film Awards winners”“National Board of Review Current Awards”Bản gốc"Ron Howard Whaling Tale 'In The Heart Of The Sea' Casts Tom Holland"“'Spider-Man' Finds Tom Holland to Star as New Web-Slinger”lưu trữ“Captain America: Civil War (2016)”“Film Review: ‘Captain America: Civil War’”lưu trữ“‘Captain America: Civil War’ review: Choose your own avenger”lưu trữ“The Lost City of Z reviews”“Sony Pictures and Marvel Studios Find Their 'Spider-Man' Star and Director”“‘Mary Magdalene’, ‘Current War’ & ‘Wind River’ Get 2017 Release Dates From Weinstein”“Lionsgate Unleashing Daisy Ridley & Tom Holland Starrer ‘Chaos Walking’ In Cannes”“PTA's 'Master' Leads Chicago Film Critics Nominations, UPDATED: Houston and Indiana Critics Nominations”“Nominaciones Goya 2013 Telecinco Cinema – ENG”“Jameson Empire Film Awards: Martin Freeman wins best actor for performance in The Hobbit”“34th Annual Young Artist Awards”Bản gốc“Teen Choice Awards 2016—Captain America: Civil War Leads Second Wave of Nominations”“BAFTA Film Award Nominations: ‘La La Land’ Leads Race”“Saturn Awards Nominations 2017: 'Rogue One,' 'Walking Dead' Lead”Tom HollandTom HollandTom HollandTom Hollandmedia.gettyimages.comWorldCat Identities300279794no20130442900000 0004 0355 42791085670554170004732cb16706349t(data)XX5557367