Why didn't Kes send Voyager home?Why didn't Seven of Nine assimilate the Voyager crew when she was separated from the collective?1x09 Emanations - How to recover the shroud?Was Voyager really significantly slower than the Enterprise-D?How was Voyager still in the Delta Quadrant at the end of the series?How did Voyager encounter the Krenim so soon when Kes hadn't ascended?Did Kes become a Traveler?Why didn't Voyager get home in the first season?Why would passage through Borg space take too much time?When was the earliest opportunity the Voyager crew had to return to the Alpha quadrant after being stranded?
An employee has low self-confidence, and is performing poorly. How can I help?
Comparison of values in dictionary
Why does transition from one electron shell to another shell always produce massless photon?
How much money should I save in order to generate $1000/month for the rest of my life?
Solving a Certainty Equivalent (Decision Analysis) problem
Relation between signal processing and control systems engineering?
Does journal access significantly influence choice in which journal to publish in?
How to find out which object is taking space?
How to write Hanief (my name) in Japanese?
I pay for a service, but I miss the broadcast
Sanitise a high score table
Is there such thing as plasma (from reentry) creating lift?
Can I perform Umrah while on a Saudi Arabian visit e-visa
Translation Golf XLVIII — We're sorry to see you go
Can I use I2C over 2m cables?
How to make "acts of patience" exciting?
Should a grammatical article be a part of a web link anchor
I am confused with the word order when putting a sentence into passé composé with reflexive verbs
Why do English transliterations of Arabic names have so many Qs in them?
Can something have more sugar per 100g than the percentage of sugar that's in it?
Transiting through Switzerland by coach with lots of cash
How can I curtail abuse of the Illusion wizard's Illusory Reality feature?
How to make a gift without seeming creepy?
Should I withdraw my paper because the Editor is behaving so badly with me?
Why didn't Kes send Voyager home?
Why didn't Seven of Nine assimilate the Voyager crew when she was separated from the collective?1x09 Emanations - How to recover the shroud?Was Voyager really significantly slower than the Enterprise-D?How was Voyager still in the Delta Quadrant at the end of the series?How did Voyager encounter the Krenim so soon when Kes hadn't ascended?Did Kes become a Traveler?Why didn't Voyager get home in the first season?Why would passage through Borg space take too much time?When was the earliest opportunity the Voyager crew had to return to the Alpha quadrant after being stranded?
.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty
margin-bottom:0;
When Kes left Voyager in the episode "The Gift", she used her psychic abilities to propel Voyager through Borg space almost instantly, cutting ten years off their journey. But why (in-universe) didn't she send them all the way back to Earth? (Out of universe, it would have meant the series was over.)
star-trek star-trek-voyager
add a comment
|
When Kes left Voyager in the episode "The Gift", she used her psychic abilities to propel Voyager through Borg space almost instantly, cutting ten years off their journey. But why (in-universe) didn't she send them all the way back to Earth? (Out of universe, it would have meant the series was over.)
star-trek star-trek-voyager
4
Wasn't Voyager almost coming apart just going that distance?
– Jon Clements
10 hours ago
@JonClements While Harry yells "We're coming apart", there is little other evidence to suggest the ship was in much danger when Kes flung them. More damage was being done by Kes during her transformation. youtu.be/GWFaH3UvbYM
– Xantec
9 hours ago
maybe too many unknowns about her new found powers put caution before omnipotence. Which now that you mention it she did have Q like powers yet Q was worried about what us mere humans might become oneday!
– onepound
7 hours ago
3
She was powerful, not omnipotent. I don't know that this question can be authoritatively answered because we've only seen one other Ocampa with enhanced capabilities,Tanis-"Cold Fire", and no real idea as to the limits of their powers. It does seem safe to assume though that if she could have, she would have.
– Emsley Wyatt
7 hours ago
add a comment
|
When Kes left Voyager in the episode "The Gift", she used her psychic abilities to propel Voyager through Borg space almost instantly, cutting ten years off their journey. But why (in-universe) didn't she send them all the way back to Earth? (Out of universe, it would have meant the series was over.)
star-trek star-trek-voyager
When Kes left Voyager in the episode "The Gift", she used her psychic abilities to propel Voyager through Borg space almost instantly, cutting ten years off their journey. But why (in-universe) didn't she send them all the way back to Earth? (Out of universe, it would have meant the series was over.)
star-trek star-trek-voyager
star-trek star-trek-voyager
edited 10 hours ago
TheLethalCarrot
78.9k33 gold badges512 silver badges548 bronze badges
78.9k33 gold badges512 silver badges548 bronze badges
asked 10 hours ago
WallnutWallnut
3,0833 gold badges25 silver badges40 bronze badges
3,0833 gold badges25 silver badges40 bronze badges
4
Wasn't Voyager almost coming apart just going that distance?
– Jon Clements
10 hours ago
@JonClements While Harry yells "We're coming apart", there is little other evidence to suggest the ship was in much danger when Kes flung them. More damage was being done by Kes during her transformation. youtu.be/GWFaH3UvbYM
– Xantec
9 hours ago
maybe too many unknowns about her new found powers put caution before omnipotence. Which now that you mention it she did have Q like powers yet Q was worried about what us mere humans might become oneday!
– onepound
7 hours ago
3
She was powerful, not omnipotent. I don't know that this question can be authoritatively answered because we've only seen one other Ocampa with enhanced capabilities,Tanis-"Cold Fire", and no real idea as to the limits of their powers. It does seem safe to assume though that if she could have, she would have.
– Emsley Wyatt
7 hours ago
add a comment
|
4
Wasn't Voyager almost coming apart just going that distance?
– Jon Clements
10 hours ago
@JonClements While Harry yells "We're coming apart", there is little other evidence to suggest the ship was in much danger when Kes flung them. More damage was being done by Kes during her transformation. youtu.be/GWFaH3UvbYM
– Xantec
9 hours ago
maybe too many unknowns about her new found powers put caution before omnipotence. Which now that you mention it she did have Q like powers yet Q was worried about what us mere humans might become oneday!
– onepound
7 hours ago
3
She was powerful, not omnipotent. I don't know that this question can be authoritatively answered because we've only seen one other Ocampa with enhanced capabilities,Tanis-"Cold Fire", and no real idea as to the limits of their powers. It does seem safe to assume though that if she could have, she would have.
– Emsley Wyatt
7 hours ago
4
4
Wasn't Voyager almost coming apart just going that distance?
– Jon Clements
10 hours ago
Wasn't Voyager almost coming apart just going that distance?
– Jon Clements
10 hours ago
@JonClements While Harry yells "We're coming apart", there is little other evidence to suggest the ship was in much danger when Kes flung them. More damage was being done by Kes during her transformation. youtu.be/GWFaH3UvbYM
– Xantec
9 hours ago
@JonClements While Harry yells "We're coming apart", there is little other evidence to suggest the ship was in much danger when Kes flung them. More damage was being done by Kes during her transformation. youtu.be/GWFaH3UvbYM
– Xantec
9 hours ago
maybe too many unknowns about her new found powers put caution before omnipotence. Which now that you mention it she did have Q like powers yet Q was worried about what us mere humans might become oneday!
– onepound
7 hours ago
maybe too many unknowns about her new found powers put caution before omnipotence. Which now that you mention it she did have Q like powers yet Q was worried about what us mere humans might become oneday!
– onepound
7 hours ago
3
3
She was powerful, not omnipotent. I don't know that this question can be authoritatively answered because we've only seen one other Ocampa with enhanced capabilities,Tanis-"Cold Fire", and no real idea as to the limits of their powers. It does seem safe to assume though that if she could have, she would have.
– Emsley Wyatt
7 hours ago
She was powerful, not omnipotent. I don't know that this question can be authoritatively answered because we've only seen one other Ocampa with enhanced capabilities,Tanis-"Cold Fire", and no real idea as to the limits of their powers. It does seem safe to assume though that if she could have, she would have.
– Emsley Wyatt
7 hours ago
add a comment
|
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
I think the episode deals with this relatively well. She gives them a gift while she's still corporeal enough to do so, throwing them as far as she can, while respecting the physical integrity of the ship.
PARIS: This can't be right. Our speed is - it's impossible!
KIM: We're coming apart!
PARIS: We've just dropped out of whatever it was we were in.
Had she tried to chuck them another 10,000 light years, the ship would presumably have exploded or fallen apart, killing everyone on board. And I think we can all agree that that wouldn't be much of a present.
add a comment
|
We could postulate some explanations, but we don't know the answers. It's largely a mystery.
She missed.
She is very new to her abilities. This reminds me of myself playing pool. The ball hardly goes the direction I want, let alone at the perfect speed.She was not powerful enough.
She is young for an evolved being. Maybe toddlers are too limited.
The word omnipotent is used to express that we cannot fathom a being's power or abilities; it is nonetheless a misnomer. Even Q admits that his powers have limitations. We can't begin to understand his abilities, let alone understand how he is limited.
- She was too powerful and she lacked the tools for an accurate push.
Let's pretend we're human beings trying to build an ant tunnel. This job would be "beneath us" and quite "too small" for our fat fingers. We would need to create tools so we could work small and also not push too hard. Similarly, Kes may not have had the tools to be properly accurate. Anyone who has played paper football can relate to how hard it is to be accurate with a flick of a finger.
- She knew there would be unintended consequences.
Maybe if she flung them all the way home, the Borg would mistake the trip as powered by Starfleet technology. The borg would see this as both a threat and an awesome new technology to acquire, so they would invade and destroy their home. She couldn't let that happen.
- She can see through time and complied with fate.
She knows that her role was to help so much and no farther.
- Caution
I like @onepound's thought: she was being cautious. She didn't want to blow up the ship by "smacking" them too hard.
- She was in a hurry
Hey, powerful beings have things to do, you know? Maybe she needed to go meet the other ascended Ocampa who were calling to her. She didn't have time to do it right.
- The prime directive.
While Kes certainly is not beholden to the prime directive, she does understand the idea that you can do harm by helping too much. See also #4.
As for my thinking, it clear she could have picked up the ship and walked it all the way home safely. So #4, #5, #7, and #8 seem most likely to me.
Although, I do find the question hollow. As the OP mentioned, ultimately the answer is the "writers didn't want to."
add a comment
|
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function()
var channelOptions =
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "186"
;
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
createEditor();
);
else
createEditor();
);
function createEditor()
StackExchange.prepareEditor(
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader:
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/"u003ecc by-sa 4.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
,
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
);
);
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f220898%2fwhy-didnt-kes-send-voyager-home%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
I think the episode deals with this relatively well. She gives them a gift while she's still corporeal enough to do so, throwing them as far as she can, while respecting the physical integrity of the ship.
PARIS: This can't be right. Our speed is - it's impossible!
KIM: We're coming apart!
PARIS: We've just dropped out of whatever it was we were in.
Had she tried to chuck them another 10,000 light years, the ship would presumably have exploded or fallen apart, killing everyone on board. And I think we can all agree that that wouldn't be much of a present.
add a comment
|
I think the episode deals with this relatively well. She gives them a gift while she's still corporeal enough to do so, throwing them as far as she can, while respecting the physical integrity of the ship.
PARIS: This can't be right. Our speed is - it's impossible!
KIM: We're coming apart!
PARIS: We've just dropped out of whatever it was we were in.
Had she tried to chuck them another 10,000 light years, the ship would presumably have exploded or fallen apart, killing everyone on board. And I think we can all agree that that wouldn't be much of a present.
add a comment
|
I think the episode deals with this relatively well. She gives them a gift while she's still corporeal enough to do so, throwing them as far as she can, while respecting the physical integrity of the ship.
PARIS: This can't be right. Our speed is - it's impossible!
KIM: We're coming apart!
PARIS: We've just dropped out of whatever it was we were in.
Had she tried to chuck them another 10,000 light years, the ship would presumably have exploded or fallen apart, killing everyone on board. And I think we can all agree that that wouldn't be much of a present.
I think the episode deals with this relatively well. She gives them a gift while she's still corporeal enough to do so, throwing them as far as she can, while respecting the physical integrity of the ship.
PARIS: This can't be right. Our speed is - it's impossible!
KIM: We're coming apart!
PARIS: We've just dropped out of whatever it was we were in.
Had she tried to chuck them another 10,000 light years, the ship would presumably have exploded or fallen apart, killing everyone on board. And I think we can all agree that that wouldn't be much of a present.
answered 5 hours ago
ValorumValorum
447k123 gold badges3280 silver badges3455 bronze badges
447k123 gold badges3280 silver badges3455 bronze badges
add a comment
|
add a comment
|
We could postulate some explanations, but we don't know the answers. It's largely a mystery.
She missed.
She is very new to her abilities. This reminds me of myself playing pool. The ball hardly goes the direction I want, let alone at the perfect speed.She was not powerful enough.
She is young for an evolved being. Maybe toddlers are too limited.
The word omnipotent is used to express that we cannot fathom a being's power or abilities; it is nonetheless a misnomer. Even Q admits that his powers have limitations. We can't begin to understand his abilities, let alone understand how he is limited.
- She was too powerful and she lacked the tools for an accurate push.
Let's pretend we're human beings trying to build an ant tunnel. This job would be "beneath us" and quite "too small" for our fat fingers. We would need to create tools so we could work small and also not push too hard. Similarly, Kes may not have had the tools to be properly accurate. Anyone who has played paper football can relate to how hard it is to be accurate with a flick of a finger.
- She knew there would be unintended consequences.
Maybe if she flung them all the way home, the Borg would mistake the trip as powered by Starfleet technology. The borg would see this as both a threat and an awesome new technology to acquire, so they would invade and destroy their home. She couldn't let that happen.
- She can see through time and complied with fate.
She knows that her role was to help so much and no farther.
- Caution
I like @onepound's thought: she was being cautious. She didn't want to blow up the ship by "smacking" them too hard.
- She was in a hurry
Hey, powerful beings have things to do, you know? Maybe she needed to go meet the other ascended Ocampa who were calling to her. She didn't have time to do it right.
- The prime directive.
While Kes certainly is not beholden to the prime directive, she does understand the idea that you can do harm by helping too much. See also #4.
As for my thinking, it clear she could have picked up the ship and walked it all the way home safely. So #4, #5, #7, and #8 seem most likely to me.
Although, I do find the question hollow. As the OP mentioned, ultimately the answer is the "writers didn't want to."
add a comment
|
We could postulate some explanations, but we don't know the answers. It's largely a mystery.
She missed.
She is very new to her abilities. This reminds me of myself playing pool. The ball hardly goes the direction I want, let alone at the perfect speed.She was not powerful enough.
She is young for an evolved being. Maybe toddlers are too limited.
The word omnipotent is used to express that we cannot fathom a being's power or abilities; it is nonetheless a misnomer. Even Q admits that his powers have limitations. We can't begin to understand his abilities, let alone understand how he is limited.
- She was too powerful and she lacked the tools for an accurate push.
Let's pretend we're human beings trying to build an ant tunnel. This job would be "beneath us" and quite "too small" for our fat fingers. We would need to create tools so we could work small and also not push too hard. Similarly, Kes may not have had the tools to be properly accurate. Anyone who has played paper football can relate to how hard it is to be accurate with a flick of a finger.
- She knew there would be unintended consequences.
Maybe if she flung them all the way home, the Borg would mistake the trip as powered by Starfleet technology. The borg would see this as both a threat and an awesome new technology to acquire, so they would invade and destroy their home. She couldn't let that happen.
- She can see through time and complied with fate.
She knows that her role was to help so much and no farther.
- Caution
I like @onepound's thought: she was being cautious. She didn't want to blow up the ship by "smacking" them too hard.
- She was in a hurry
Hey, powerful beings have things to do, you know? Maybe she needed to go meet the other ascended Ocampa who were calling to her. She didn't have time to do it right.
- The prime directive.
While Kes certainly is not beholden to the prime directive, she does understand the idea that you can do harm by helping too much. See also #4.
As for my thinking, it clear she could have picked up the ship and walked it all the way home safely. So #4, #5, #7, and #8 seem most likely to me.
Although, I do find the question hollow. As the OP mentioned, ultimately the answer is the "writers didn't want to."
add a comment
|
We could postulate some explanations, but we don't know the answers. It's largely a mystery.
She missed.
She is very new to her abilities. This reminds me of myself playing pool. The ball hardly goes the direction I want, let alone at the perfect speed.She was not powerful enough.
She is young for an evolved being. Maybe toddlers are too limited.
The word omnipotent is used to express that we cannot fathom a being's power or abilities; it is nonetheless a misnomer. Even Q admits that his powers have limitations. We can't begin to understand his abilities, let alone understand how he is limited.
- She was too powerful and she lacked the tools for an accurate push.
Let's pretend we're human beings trying to build an ant tunnel. This job would be "beneath us" and quite "too small" for our fat fingers. We would need to create tools so we could work small and also not push too hard. Similarly, Kes may not have had the tools to be properly accurate. Anyone who has played paper football can relate to how hard it is to be accurate with a flick of a finger.
- She knew there would be unintended consequences.
Maybe if she flung them all the way home, the Borg would mistake the trip as powered by Starfleet technology. The borg would see this as both a threat and an awesome new technology to acquire, so they would invade and destroy their home. She couldn't let that happen.
- She can see through time and complied with fate.
She knows that her role was to help so much and no farther.
- Caution
I like @onepound's thought: she was being cautious. She didn't want to blow up the ship by "smacking" them too hard.
- She was in a hurry
Hey, powerful beings have things to do, you know? Maybe she needed to go meet the other ascended Ocampa who were calling to her. She didn't have time to do it right.
- The prime directive.
While Kes certainly is not beholden to the prime directive, she does understand the idea that you can do harm by helping too much. See also #4.
As for my thinking, it clear she could have picked up the ship and walked it all the way home safely. So #4, #5, #7, and #8 seem most likely to me.
Although, I do find the question hollow. As the OP mentioned, ultimately the answer is the "writers didn't want to."
We could postulate some explanations, but we don't know the answers. It's largely a mystery.
She missed.
She is very new to her abilities. This reminds me of myself playing pool. The ball hardly goes the direction I want, let alone at the perfect speed.She was not powerful enough.
She is young for an evolved being. Maybe toddlers are too limited.
The word omnipotent is used to express that we cannot fathom a being's power or abilities; it is nonetheless a misnomer. Even Q admits that his powers have limitations. We can't begin to understand his abilities, let alone understand how he is limited.
- She was too powerful and she lacked the tools for an accurate push.
Let's pretend we're human beings trying to build an ant tunnel. This job would be "beneath us" and quite "too small" for our fat fingers. We would need to create tools so we could work small and also not push too hard. Similarly, Kes may not have had the tools to be properly accurate. Anyone who has played paper football can relate to how hard it is to be accurate with a flick of a finger.
- She knew there would be unintended consequences.
Maybe if she flung them all the way home, the Borg would mistake the trip as powered by Starfleet technology. The borg would see this as both a threat and an awesome new technology to acquire, so they would invade and destroy their home. She couldn't let that happen.
- She can see through time and complied with fate.
She knows that her role was to help so much and no farther.
- Caution
I like @onepound's thought: she was being cautious. She didn't want to blow up the ship by "smacking" them too hard.
- She was in a hurry
Hey, powerful beings have things to do, you know? Maybe she needed to go meet the other ascended Ocampa who were calling to her. She didn't have time to do it right.
- The prime directive.
While Kes certainly is not beholden to the prime directive, she does understand the idea that you can do harm by helping too much. See also #4.
As for my thinking, it clear she could have picked up the ship and walked it all the way home safely. So #4, #5, #7, and #8 seem most likely to me.
Although, I do find the question hollow. As the OP mentioned, ultimately the answer is the "writers didn't want to."
answered 6 hours ago
BAMF4baconBAMF4bacon
1763 bronze badges
1763 bronze badges
add a comment
|
add a comment
|
Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f220898%2fwhy-didnt-kes-send-voyager-home%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
4
Wasn't Voyager almost coming apart just going that distance?
– Jon Clements
10 hours ago
@JonClements While Harry yells "We're coming apart", there is little other evidence to suggest the ship was in much danger when Kes flung them. More damage was being done by Kes during her transformation. youtu.be/GWFaH3UvbYM
– Xantec
9 hours ago
maybe too many unknowns about her new found powers put caution before omnipotence. Which now that you mention it she did have Q like powers yet Q was worried about what us mere humans might become oneday!
– onepound
7 hours ago
3
She was powerful, not omnipotent. I don't know that this question can be authoritatively answered because we've only seen one other Ocampa with enhanced capabilities,Tanis-"Cold Fire", and no real idea as to the limits of their powers. It does seem safe to assume though that if she could have, she would have.
– Emsley Wyatt
7 hours ago