What's the origin of the trope that dragons used to be common but aren't any more?Where did the idea of “rocket tubes” come from?What is the earliest worldbuilding fiction?What was the first story to feature stopped time?Books about dragons and war from a cat-loving authorRomance book about a shapeshifting unicorn and a shapeshifting dragonWhere does the notion of being injured or killed by an illusion originate?Why did J. K. Rowling choose to downplay dragons?Children's Book of short stories about dragonsShort story about military airships and a dragon corpsWhat's the origin of the trope where *healthy* immortality is a cause for sadness?
White marks on garage ceiling
Reference request for Evacuation Planning
Water Jug Problem in AI
Where do I put nobles/royalty in a scifi military
Solving Subset-Product in Python
How to test oom-killer from command line
What's the difference between "can't move" and "speed becomes 0"?
Time Complexity of Parallel.ForEach
What color is a wolf's coat?
find longest common substring in space O(n)
Is there a way to easily validate that a SQL Script is compatible with a specific SQL Server version?
Three button calculator
What is the purpose of R1 in this circuit?
Personal item size
Why is the Exchange French considered drawish?
What's the most rewarding path?
PyQGIS using selected layer from a combobox
Does every truth have to be provable based on evidence?
Why is super hero technology never used by civilians?
When "this" is captured by a lambda, does it have to be used explicitly?
Why don't all humans have absolute pitch?
Continuous functions taking uncountably many values countably often
Thinking about the notes when playing a piece
What would cause vast differences in lifespans between the sexes?
What's the origin of the trope that dragons used to be common but aren't any more?
Where did the idea of “rocket tubes” come from?What is the earliest worldbuilding fiction?What was the first story to feature stopped time?Books about dragons and war from a cat-loving authorRomance book about a shapeshifting unicorn and a shapeshifting dragonWhere does the notion of being injured or killed by an illusion originate?Why did J. K. Rowling choose to downplay dragons?Children's Book of short stories about dragonsShort story about military airships and a dragon corpsWhat's the origin of the trope where *healthy* immortality is a cause for sadness?
.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty
margin-bottom:0;
It's common in fantasy stories for dragons to be formerly common but rare or extinct by the time of the story, for example, in Discworld, Game of Thrones, and perhaps The Hobbit (I can't recall enough about Smaug to be sure).
Where did this idea come from? Is it known in any old mythology?
history-of dragons
add a comment
|
It's common in fantasy stories for dragons to be formerly common but rare or extinct by the time of the story, for example, in Discworld, Game of Thrones, and perhaps The Hobbit (I can't recall enough about Smaug to be sure).
Where did this idea come from? Is it known in any old mythology?
history-of dragons
add a comment
|
It's common in fantasy stories for dragons to be formerly common but rare or extinct by the time of the story, for example, in Discworld, Game of Thrones, and perhaps The Hobbit (I can't recall enough about Smaug to be sure).
Where did this idea come from? Is it known in any old mythology?
history-of dragons
It's common in fantasy stories for dragons to be formerly common but rare or extinct by the time of the story, for example, in Discworld, Game of Thrones, and perhaps The Hobbit (I can't recall enough about Smaug to be sure).
Where did this idea come from? Is it known in any old mythology?
history-of dragons
history-of dragons
edited Oct 14 at 13:59
TheLethalCarrot
84.5k38 gold badges535 silver badges573 bronze badges
84.5k38 gold badges535 silver badges573 bronze badges
asked Oct 14 at 13:58
Chris HChris H
4231 gold badge4 silver badges7 bronze badges
4231 gold badge4 silver badges7 bronze badges
add a comment
|
add a comment
|
4 Answers
4
active
oldest
votes
The idea that dragons were once numerous, but are no longer, is just one of many manifestations of what TV Tropes calls the "The Magic Goes Away" (named for the Larry Niven story). It is really one of the most common and fundamental tropes in fantasy—that the world of the past was more magical and fantastical than the world we live in now—and it traces its origins back to ancient myths.
Quoting from myself here:
The idea that magic was much more plentiful in the past is very common, both in fantasy fiction and mythology. It makes sense that myths would tend to develop this way. While there are things in the everyday world that seem magical in varying degrees (earthquakes, lightning, the bodies of the heavens), the physical forms of gods are conspicuously absent. So there is posited (either implicitly or explicitly) to have been an age where magic was more common, and the gods were closer. There might or might not be a new age of magic coming in the future, perhaps at the end of the universe.
Fantasy writing, including my own, tends to follow this formula. One reason for this is that it’s familiar from myths and folklore; it’s been a convention of the fantasy genre before the genre even existed as such. Another reason is that fantasy is often set is a world that is supposed to approximate some epoch of Earth’s past—culturally or technologically. If too much magic was available, it would change the setting drastically.... Yet a writer generally wants there to be enough powerful magic to tell a good story. A natural way of resolving this tension is if powerful magic exists, but it is hidden away; and even if it is uncovered, it cannot be duplicated.
Some authors have thought through the implications of the gradual decay of magic rather carefully. Others tend to accept it as a part of the standard fantasy setting without much explicit discussion.
Regarding dragons specifically, a very early example is from the Old English epic poem Beowulf. The last of the three monsters the hero Beowulf fights (after Grendel and Grendel's mother) is a dragon. The dragon has been sleeping for ages—implicitly since a time when dragon depredations were a more usual occurrence—when its sleep is disturbed by the theft of a golden cup from its ancient horde, and arises to lay waste to the countryside. The narrative compares the challenge of Beowulf's winged fire drake to earlier feats, specifically the slaying of the wyrm Fafnir (by Sigmund, according to the Beowulf, although in other sources the deed is more usually attributed to Sigmud's son Sigurd/Sigfried). Thus Beowulf's final victory, over this scaly relic of a former age, is compared to the deeds of the even older epic heroes of Germanic mythology, who were directly descended from the gods themselves.
12
The phenomenon of the audience expecting a story to happen in an alternate universe (MCU, Star Wars etc.) is fairly recent. Stories has always been told from the point of view of happening in our actual, real, world (one where Chris H just asked a question about dragons on stackexchange). But those stories need to reconcile the conceit of the story with reality - why lions and spiders like Anansi cannot talk, why you cannot actually use magic to stop time, why you won't find dragons in the Amazon etc. And the reconciliation is exactly the trope of these things used to be real but not anymore
– slebetman
Oct 15 at 9:47
3
There's also the contracting factor that there's an endless amount of past condensed into "The Past", so heroes (like dragons!) are few and far between now, yet so many stories! An unchanging 1-dragon-attack-per-generation-per-country means a dozen or maybe many more detailed descriptions in the country's oral history, without expectation to see one yourself in your lifetime (you'll hear about it happening elsewhere); i.e., "rare"
– user3445853
Oct 15 at 13:17
1
I would also add that "fall from grace" is often a theme in myths - and from there, it's only logical that the past was more marvelous and awe inspiring that the bleak and mundane present.
– Edheldil
Oct 15 at 14:36
10
Tolkien deliberately echoes Beowulf by having Bilbo wake Smaug by stealing a chalice
– Kevin Troy
Oct 16 at 14:49
2
A perfect illustration of the "Magic Goes Away" trope is from the 1981 film Dragonslayer: Ulrich - "In fact, if it weren't for sorcerers, there wouldn't be any dragons. Once the skies were dotted with them." . . . And later when Ulrich is asked to kill the dragon Vermithrax: "You want me to do battle with that?!" "Who else can we turn to?" "Did you try the Meredydd Sisters? What about Rinbod? I heard tell he killed a dragon once." "They're all dead. You're the only one left." I would have liked to see a prequel where we meet the Meredydd Sisters and Rinbod. :-)
– RobertF
Oct 17 at 15:35
|
show 3 more comments
I think this is inspired by real life.
Consider that where I live - the island of Ireland - was once a habitat for elk, wolves, wild cows and many species of deer.
Over the last thousands of years they have been killed off, or couldn't adapt to environmental changes.
The wolves were common in Ireland in the 17th century (see Wolves in Ireland) and my grandfather once dug up a partial antler from Great Irish Elk in a peat bog.
These creatures no longer exist, but occasionally their remains still come to light.
Imagine a farmer some hundreds of years ago finding the skeletal remains of a great Irish Elk
. . . and wondering at the size of it.
For me it's simple extrapolation that people find the remains of large animals, or fossils of them, and see that those animals no longer exist in their area.
Add to that the tall tales, the man who survives a wolf attack, it was never a small wolf, like the fish that got away it's size will grow each time the story is told, until it's the size of the direwolves of old come again.
Fathers, bringing their sons wolf hunting, try to put a bit of heart in the boys by telling them "these wolves you get these days, they're nothing like the wolves we got when I were young, sure my grand father killed a wolf taller than he was with nothing but a stone knife and his own bare hands!"
Also, we all know that our fathers, and their fathers had it harder in their day that we do . . . though they were happier then, even though they were poor
All of these things add to the impression that the world has diminished from how it was in the days of our ancestors.
Further reading of Dragon (Wikipedia) has unearthed (emphasis mine)
Nonetheless, scholars dispute where the idea of a dragon originates
from and a wide variety of theories have been proposed.[8] In his
book An Instinct for Dragons (2000), anthropologist David E. Jones
suggests a hypothesis that humans, just like monkeys, have inherited
instinctive reactions to snakes, large cats, and birds of prey. He
cites a study which found that approximately 39 people in a hundred
are afraid of snakes and notes that fear of snakes is especially
prominent in children, even in areas where snakes are rare. The
earliest attested dragons all resemble snakes or bear snakelike
attributes. Jones therefore concludes that the reason why dragons
appear in nearly all cultures is because of humans' innate fear of
snakes and other animals that were major predators of humans' primate
ancestors. Dragons are usually said to reside in "dank caves, deep
pools, wild mountain reaches, sea bottoms, haunted forests", all
places which would have been fraught with danger for early human
ancestors.
and
In her book The First Fossil Hunters: Dinosaurs, Mammoths, and Myth in
Greek and Roman Times (2000), Adrienne Mayor argues that some stories
of dragons may have been inspired by ancient discoveries of fossils
belonging to dinosaurs and other prehistoric animals.[14] She argues
that the dragon lore of northern India may have been inspired by
"observations of oversized, extraordinary bones in the fossilbeds of
the Siwalik Hills below the Himalayas" and that ancient Greek
artistic depictions of the Monster of Troy may have been influenced by
fossils of Samotherium, an extinct species of giraffe whose fossils
are common in the Mediterranean region. In China, a region where
fossils of large prehistoric animals are common, these remains are
frequently identified as "dragon bones" and are commonly used in
Chinese traditional medicine. Mayor, however, is careful to point
out that not all stories of dragons and giants are inspired by
fossils and notes that Scandinavia has many stories of dragons and
sea monsters, but has long "been considered barren of large fossils
2
I've since corrected that, I had mean "environmental changes", increasing forestation of post ice-age tundra that covered Ireland for many thousands of years is one theory of why the Irish Elk died out. The antlers were the result of sexual selection and they were a hindrance in wooded areas. "Global Warming" has happened before, it's just this time is largely "man made".
– Binary Worrier
Oct 14 at 15:54
20
Also dragons may not have existed, but I'm sure people uncovered fossils of long necked animals, and wondered at them before carving the rock up to upgrade their stone circle. "What's that in the rock Dad?", "Eh . . . it's a dragon son". "Why's it in the rock dad?", "Eh, some wizard turned it to stone, didn't he? Stands to reason when you think about it son. Now, hand me that hammer"
– Binary Worrier
Oct 14 at 15:58
6
I'm going to go with Chinese people finding dinosaur skulls; predating written history.
– Mazura
Oct 14 at 22:28
1
@Fattie: The OP asks "Where did this idea come from? Is it known in any old mythology?", the wikipedia article I link to and quote from, attempts to answer this, but can only guess at the origins and confirms that this trope is Older Than Dirt
– Binary Worrier
Oct 15 at 8:55
5
I agree with the Dinos= Dragons, accidental fossil finds; the same holds for elephant in the Mediterranean (whose skulls without teeth somewhat look like giant cyclops skulls due to the round hole).
– user3445853
Oct 15 at 13:10
|
show 11 more comments
Dinosaur bones.
No, really. Do you really think we were the first to unearth dinosaur bones and wonder WTF they were? Of course not. When your culture unearths the bones of several gigantic reptile-things and you only have hearsay of anything like that existing today, it's difficult not to make the assumption that these things were once plentiful and are either extinct or in very short supply.
3
Our ancestors didn't actually see dragons, but they saw these giant bones. Ergo, dragons were once plentiful but not anymore.
– RonJohn
Oct 16 at 21:26
3
dragons were once plentiful
And, in a sense, they were :). It's just that "once" was ... millions of years ago, and they didn't look quite like we picture them now.
– Reinstate Monica --Brondahl--
Oct 17 at 12:43
add a comment
|
To add a venerable precedent, in Jonathan Swift's Gulliver's Travels he arrives in Brobdingnag, land of giants. Those giants are convinced that they are the degenerated (in the physical sense) descendants of even bigger giants (of which they have found the bones1), and Gulliver speculates that men may be in turn the degenerated descendants of the inhabitants of Brobdingnag.
1And the reference to bones links to Carduus' observation that way before the theory of evolution was established the people realized that really big beings lived on Earth.
I was wondering about a Gulliver's Travels connection (but no dragons there that I recall). It's another example of the broader version though
– Chris H
Oct 17 at 20:39
1
@ChrisH no, no dragons in Gulliver, but given how old the book is I thought it was worth mentioning the similar theme.
– SJuan76
Oct 17 at 20:41
add a comment
|
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function()
var channelOptions =
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "186"
;
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
createEditor();
);
else
createEditor();
);
function createEditor()
StackExchange.prepareEditor(
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader:
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/"u003ecc by-sa 4.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
,
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
);
);
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f221552%2fwhats-the-origin-of-the-trope-that-dragons-used-to-be-common-but-arent-any-mor%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
4 Answers
4
active
oldest
votes
4 Answers
4
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
The idea that dragons were once numerous, but are no longer, is just one of many manifestations of what TV Tropes calls the "The Magic Goes Away" (named for the Larry Niven story). It is really one of the most common and fundamental tropes in fantasy—that the world of the past was more magical and fantastical than the world we live in now—and it traces its origins back to ancient myths.
Quoting from myself here:
The idea that magic was much more plentiful in the past is very common, both in fantasy fiction and mythology. It makes sense that myths would tend to develop this way. While there are things in the everyday world that seem magical in varying degrees (earthquakes, lightning, the bodies of the heavens), the physical forms of gods are conspicuously absent. So there is posited (either implicitly or explicitly) to have been an age where magic was more common, and the gods were closer. There might or might not be a new age of magic coming in the future, perhaps at the end of the universe.
Fantasy writing, including my own, tends to follow this formula. One reason for this is that it’s familiar from myths and folklore; it’s been a convention of the fantasy genre before the genre even existed as such. Another reason is that fantasy is often set is a world that is supposed to approximate some epoch of Earth’s past—culturally or technologically. If too much magic was available, it would change the setting drastically.... Yet a writer generally wants there to be enough powerful magic to tell a good story. A natural way of resolving this tension is if powerful magic exists, but it is hidden away; and even if it is uncovered, it cannot be duplicated.
Some authors have thought through the implications of the gradual decay of magic rather carefully. Others tend to accept it as a part of the standard fantasy setting without much explicit discussion.
Regarding dragons specifically, a very early example is from the Old English epic poem Beowulf. The last of the three monsters the hero Beowulf fights (after Grendel and Grendel's mother) is a dragon. The dragon has been sleeping for ages—implicitly since a time when dragon depredations were a more usual occurrence—when its sleep is disturbed by the theft of a golden cup from its ancient horde, and arises to lay waste to the countryside. The narrative compares the challenge of Beowulf's winged fire drake to earlier feats, specifically the slaying of the wyrm Fafnir (by Sigmund, according to the Beowulf, although in other sources the deed is more usually attributed to Sigmud's son Sigurd/Sigfried). Thus Beowulf's final victory, over this scaly relic of a former age, is compared to the deeds of the even older epic heroes of Germanic mythology, who were directly descended from the gods themselves.
12
The phenomenon of the audience expecting a story to happen in an alternate universe (MCU, Star Wars etc.) is fairly recent. Stories has always been told from the point of view of happening in our actual, real, world (one where Chris H just asked a question about dragons on stackexchange). But those stories need to reconcile the conceit of the story with reality - why lions and spiders like Anansi cannot talk, why you cannot actually use magic to stop time, why you won't find dragons in the Amazon etc. And the reconciliation is exactly the trope of these things used to be real but not anymore
– slebetman
Oct 15 at 9:47
3
There's also the contracting factor that there's an endless amount of past condensed into "The Past", so heroes (like dragons!) are few and far between now, yet so many stories! An unchanging 1-dragon-attack-per-generation-per-country means a dozen or maybe many more detailed descriptions in the country's oral history, without expectation to see one yourself in your lifetime (you'll hear about it happening elsewhere); i.e., "rare"
– user3445853
Oct 15 at 13:17
1
I would also add that "fall from grace" is often a theme in myths - and from there, it's only logical that the past was more marvelous and awe inspiring that the bleak and mundane present.
– Edheldil
Oct 15 at 14:36
10
Tolkien deliberately echoes Beowulf by having Bilbo wake Smaug by stealing a chalice
– Kevin Troy
Oct 16 at 14:49
2
A perfect illustration of the "Magic Goes Away" trope is from the 1981 film Dragonslayer: Ulrich - "In fact, if it weren't for sorcerers, there wouldn't be any dragons. Once the skies were dotted with them." . . . And later when Ulrich is asked to kill the dragon Vermithrax: "You want me to do battle with that?!" "Who else can we turn to?" "Did you try the Meredydd Sisters? What about Rinbod? I heard tell he killed a dragon once." "They're all dead. You're the only one left." I would have liked to see a prequel where we meet the Meredydd Sisters and Rinbod. :-)
– RobertF
Oct 17 at 15:35
|
show 3 more comments
The idea that dragons were once numerous, but are no longer, is just one of many manifestations of what TV Tropes calls the "The Magic Goes Away" (named for the Larry Niven story). It is really one of the most common and fundamental tropes in fantasy—that the world of the past was more magical and fantastical than the world we live in now—and it traces its origins back to ancient myths.
Quoting from myself here:
The idea that magic was much more plentiful in the past is very common, both in fantasy fiction and mythology. It makes sense that myths would tend to develop this way. While there are things in the everyday world that seem magical in varying degrees (earthquakes, lightning, the bodies of the heavens), the physical forms of gods are conspicuously absent. So there is posited (either implicitly or explicitly) to have been an age where magic was more common, and the gods were closer. There might or might not be a new age of magic coming in the future, perhaps at the end of the universe.
Fantasy writing, including my own, tends to follow this formula. One reason for this is that it’s familiar from myths and folklore; it’s been a convention of the fantasy genre before the genre even existed as such. Another reason is that fantasy is often set is a world that is supposed to approximate some epoch of Earth’s past—culturally or technologically. If too much magic was available, it would change the setting drastically.... Yet a writer generally wants there to be enough powerful magic to tell a good story. A natural way of resolving this tension is if powerful magic exists, but it is hidden away; and even if it is uncovered, it cannot be duplicated.
Some authors have thought through the implications of the gradual decay of magic rather carefully. Others tend to accept it as a part of the standard fantasy setting without much explicit discussion.
Regarding dragons specifically, a very early example is from the Old English epic poem Beowulf. The last of the three monsters the hero Beowulf fights (after Grendel and Grendel's mother) is a dragon. The dragon has been sleeping for ages—implicitly since a time when dragon depredations were a more usual occurrence—when its sleep is disturbed by the theft of a golden cup from its ancient horde, and arises to lay waste to the countryside. The narrative compares the challenge of Beowulf's winged fire drake to earlier feats, specifically the slaying of the wyrm Fafnir (by Sigmund, according to the Beowulf, although in other sources the deed is more usually attributed to Sigmud's son Sigurd/Sigfried). Thus Beowulf's final victory, over this scaly relic of a former age, is compared to the deeds of the even older epic heroes of Germanic mythology, who were directly descended from the gods themselves.
12
The phenomenon of the audience expecting a story to happen in an alternate universe (MCU, Star Wars etc.) is fairly recent. Stories has always been told from the point of view of happening in our actual, real, world (one where Chris H just asked a question about dragons on stackexchange). But those stories need to reconcile the conceit of the story with reality - why lions and spiders like Anansi cannot talk, why you cannot actually use magic to stop time, why you won't find dragons in the Amazon etc. And the reconciliation is exactly the trope of these things used to be real but not anymore
– slebetman
Oct 15 at 9:47
3
There's also the contracting factor that there's an endless amount of past condensed into "The Past", so heroes (like dragons!) are few and far between now, yet so many stories! An unchanging 1-dragon-attack-per-generation-per-country means a dozen or maybe many more detailed descriptions in the country's oral history, without expectation to see one yourself in your lifetime (you'll hear about it happening elsewhere); i.e., "rare"
– user3445853
Oct 15 at 13:17
1
I would also add that "fall from grace" is often a theme in myths - and from there, it's only logical that the past was more marvelous and awe inspiring that the bleak and mundane present.
– Edheldil
Oct 15 at 14:36
10
Tolkien deliberately echoes Beowulf by having Bilbo wake Smaug by stealing a chalice
– Kevin Troy
Oct 16 at 14:49
2
A perfect illustration of the "Magic Goes Away" trope is from the 1981 film Dragonslayer: Ulrich - "In fact, if it weren't for sorcerers, there wouldn't be any dragons. Once the skies were dotted with them." . . . And later when Ulrich is asked to kill the dragon Vermithrax: "You want me to do battle with that?!" "Who else can we turn to?" "Did you try the Meredydd Sisters? What about Rinbod? I heard tell he killed a dragon once." "They're all dead. You're the only one left." I would have liked to see a prequel where we meet the Meredydd Sisters and Rinbod. :-)
– RobertF
Oct 17 at 15:35
|
show 3 more comments
The idea that dragons were once numerous, but are no longer, is just one of many manifestations of what TV Tropes calls the "The Magic Goes Away" (named for the Larry Niven story). It is really one of the most common and fundamental tropes in fantasy—that the world of the past was more magical and fantastical than the world we live in now—and it traces its origins back to ancient myths.
Quoting from myself here:
The idea that magic was much more plentiful in the past is very common, both in fantasy fiction and mythology. It makes sense that myths would tend to develop this way. While there are things in the everyday world that seem magical in varying degrees (earthquakes, lightning, the bodies of the heavens), the physical forms of gods are conspicuously absent. So there is posited (either implicitly or explicitly) to have been an age where magic was more common, and the gods were closer. There might or might not be a new age of magic coming in the future, perhaps at the end of the universe.
Fantasy writing, including my own, tends to follow this formula. One reason for this is that it’s familiar from myths and folklore; it’s been a convention of the fantasy genre before the genre even existed as such. Another reason is that fantasy is often set is a world that is supposed to approximate some epoch of Earth’s past—culturally or technologically. If too much magic was available, it would change the setting drastically.... Yet a writer generally wants there to be enough powerful magic to tell a good story. A natural way of resolving this tension is if powerful magic exists, but it is hidden away; and even if it is uncovered, it cannot be duplicated.
Some authors have thought through the implications of the gradual decay of magic rather carefully. Others tend to accept it as a part of the standard fantasy setting without much explicit discussion.
Regarding dragons specifically, a very early example is from the Old English epic poem Beowulf. The last of the three monsters the hero Beowulf fights (after Grendel and Grendel's mother) is a dragon. The dragon has been sleeping for ages—implicitly since a time when dragon depredations were a more usual occurrence—when its sleep is disturbed by the theft of a golden cup from its ancient horde, and arises to lay waste to the countryside. The narrative compares the challenge of Beowulf's winged fire drake to earlier feats, specifically the slaying of the wyrm Fafnir (by Sigmund, according to the Beowulf, although in other sources the deed is more usually attributed to Sigmud's son Sigurd/Sigfried). Thus Beowulf's final victory, over this scaly relic of a former age, is compared to the deeds of the even older epic heroes of Germanic mythology, who were directly descended from the gods themselves.
The idea that dragons were once numerous, but are no longer, is just one of many manifestations of what TV Tropes calls the "The Magic Goes Away" (named for the Larry Niven story). It is really one of the most common and fundamental tropes in fantasy—that the world of the past was more magical and fantastical than the world we live in now—and it traces its origins back to ancient myths.
Quoting from myself here:
The idea that magic was much more plentiful in the past is very common, both in fantasy fiction and mythology. It makes sense that myths would tend to develop this way. While there are things in the everyday world that seem magical in varying degrees (earthquakes, lightning, the bodies of the heavens), the physical forms of gods are conspicuously absent. So there is posited (either implicitly or explicitly) to have been an age where magic was more common, and the gods were closer. There might or might not be a new age of magic coming in the future, perhaps at the end of the universe.
Fantasy writing, including my own, tends to follow this formula. One reason for this is that it’s familiar from myths and folklore; it’s been a convention of the fantasy genre before the genre even existed as such. Another reason is that fantasy is often set is a world that is supposed to approximate some epoch of Earth’s past—culturally or technologically. If too much magic was available, it would change the setting drastically.... Yet a writer generally wants there to be enough powerful magic to tell a good story. A natural way of resolving this tension is if powerful magic exists, but it is hidden away; and even if it is uncovered, it cannot be duplicated.
Some authors have thought through the implications of the gradual decay of magic rather carefully. Others tend to accept it as a part of the standard fantasy setting without much explicit discussion.
Regarding dragons specifically, a very early example is from the Old English epic poem Beowulf. The last of the three monsters the hero Beowulf fights (after Grendel and Grendel's mother) is a dragon. The dragon has been sleeping for ages—implicitly since a time when dragon depredations were a more usual occurrence—when its sleep is disturbed by the theft of a golden cup from its ancient horde, and arises to lay waste to the countryside. The narrative compares the challenge of Beowulf's winged fire drake to earlier feats, specifically the slaying of the wyrm Fafnir (by Sigmund, according to the Beowulf, although in other sources the deed is more usually attributed to Sigmud's son Sigurd/Sigfried). Thus Beowulf's final victory, over this scaly relic of a former age, is compared to the deeds of the even older epic heroes of Germanic mythology, who were directly descended from the gods themselves.
edited Oct 16 at 19:05
answered Oct 14 at 23:22
BuzzBuzz
49.3k8 gold badges163 silver badges263 bronze badges
49.3k8 gold badges163 silver badges263 bronze badges
12
The phenomenon of the audience expecting a story to happen in an alternate universe (MCU, Star Wars etc.) is fairly recent. Stories has always been told from the point of view of happening in our actual, real, world (one where Chris H just asked a question about dragons on stackexchange). But those stories need to reconcile the conceit of the story with reality - why lions and spiders like Anansi cannot talk, why you cannot actually use magic to stop time, why you won't find dragons in the Amazon etc. And the reconciliation is exactly the trope of these things used to be real but not anymore
– slebetman
Oct 15 at 9:47
3
There's also the contracting factor that there's an endless amount of past condensed into "The Past", so heroes (like dragons!) are few and far between now, yet so many stories! An unchanging 1-dragon-attack-per-generation-per-country means a dozen or maybe many more detailed descriptions in the country's oral history, without expectation to see one yourself in your lifetime (you'll hear about it happening elsewhere); i.e., "rare"
– user3445853
Oct 15 at 13:17
1
I would also add that "fall from grace" is often a theme in myths - and from there, it's only logical that the past was more marvelous and awe inspiring that the bleak and mundane present.
– Edheldil
Oct 15 at 14:36
10
Tolkien deliberately echoes Beowulf by having Bilbo wake Smaug by stealing a chalice
– Kevin Troy
Oct 16 at 14:49
2
A perfect illustration of the "Magic Goes Away" trope is from the 1981 film Dragonslayer: Ulrich - "In fact, if it weren't for sorcerers, there wouldn't be any dragons. Once the skies were dotted with them." . . . And later when Ulrich is asked to kill the dragon Vermithrax: "You want me to do battle with that?!" "Who else can we turn to?" "Did you try the Meredydd Sisters? What about Rinbod? I heard tell he killed a dragon once." "They're all dead. You're the only one left." I would have liked to see a prequel where we meet the Meredydd Sisters and Rinbod. :-)
– RobertF
Oct 17 at 15:35
|
show 3 more comments
12
The phenomenon of the audience expecting a story to happen in an alternate universe (MCU, Star Wars etc.) is fairly recent. Stories has always been told from the point of view of happening in our actual, real, world (one where Chris H just asked a question about dragons on stackexchange). But those stories need to reconcile the conceit of the story with reality - why lions and spiders like Anansi cannot talk, why you cannot actually use magic to stop time, why you won't find dragons in the Amazon etc. And the reconciliation is exactly the trope of these things used to be real but not anymore
– slebetman
Oct 15 at 9:47
3
There's also the contracting factor that there's an endless amount of past condensed into "The Past", so heroes (like dragons!) are few and far between now, yet so many stories! An unchanging 1-dragon-attack-per-generation-per-country means a dozen or maybe many more detailed descriptions in the country's oral history, without expectation to see one yourself in your lifetime (you'll hear about it happening elsewhere); i.e., "rare"
– user3445853
Oct 15 at 13:17
1
I would also add that "fall from grace" is often a theme in myths - and from there, it's only logical that the past was more marvelous and awe inspiring that the bleak and mundane present.
– Edheldil
Oct 15 at 14:36
10
Tolkien deliberately echoes Beowulf by having Bilbo wake Smaug by stealing a chalice
– Kevin Troy
Oct 16 at 14:49
2
A perfect illustration of the "Magic Goes Away" trope is from the 1981 film Dragonslayer: Ulrich - "In fact, if it weren't for sorcerers, there wouldn't be any dragons. Once the skies were dotted with them." . . . And later when Ulrich is asked to kill the dragon Vermithrax: "You want me to do battle with that?!" "Who else can we turn to?" "Did you try the Meredydd Sisters? What about Rinbod? I heard tell he killed a dragon once." "They're all dead. You're the only one left." I would have liked to see a prequel where we meet the Meredydd Sisters and Rinbod. :-)
– RobertF
Oct 17 at 15:35
12
12
The phenomenon of the audience expecting a story to happen in an alternate universe (MCU, Star Wars etc.) is fairly recent. Stories has always been told from the point of view of happening in our actual, real, world (one where Chris H just asked a question about dragons on stackexchange). But those stories need to reconcile the conceit of the story with reality - why lions and spiders like Anansi cannot talk, why you cannot actually use magic to stop time, why you won't find dragons in the Amazon etc. And the reconciliation is exactly the trope of these things used to be real but not anymore
– slebetman
Oct 15 at 9:47
The phenomenon of the audience expecting a story to happen in an alternate universe (MCU, Star Wars etc.) is fairly recent. Stories has always been told from the point of view of happening in our actual, real, world (one where Chris H just asked a question about dragons on stackexchange). But those stories need to reconcile the conceit of the story with reality - why lions and spiders like Anansi cannot talk, why you cannot actually use magic to stop time, why you won't find dragons in the Amazon etc. And the reconciliation is exactly the trope of these things used to be real but not anymore
– slebetman
Oct 15 at 9:47
3
3
There's also the contracting factor that there's an endless amount of past condensed into "The Past", so heroes (like dragons!) are few and far between now, yet so many stories! An unchanging 1-dragon-attack-per-generation-per-country means a dozen or maybe many more detailed descriptions in the country's oral history, without expectation to see one yourself in your lifetime (you'll hear about it happening elsewhere); i.e., "rare"
– user3445853
Oct 15 at 13:17
There's also the contracting factor that there's an endless amount of past condensed into "The Past", so heroes (like dragons!) are few and far between now, yet so many stories! An unchanging 1-dragon-attack-per-generation-per-country means a dozen or maybe many more detailed descriptions in the country's oral history, without expectation to see one yourself in your lifetime (you'll hear about it happening elsewhere); i.e., "rare"
– user3445853
Oct 15 at 13:17
1
1
I would also add that "fall from grace" is often a theme in myths - and from there, it's only logical that the past was more marvelous and awe inspiring that the bleak and mundane present.
– Edheldil
Oct 15 at 14:36
I would also add that "fall from grace" is often a theme in myths - and from there, it's only logical that the past was more marvelous and awe inspiring that the bleak and mundane present.
– Edheldil
Oct 15 at 14:36
10
10
Tolkien deliberately echoes Beowulf by having Bilbo wake Smaug by stealing a chalice
– Kevin Troy
Oct 16 at 14:49
Tolkien deliberately echoes Beowulf by having Bilbo wake Smaug by stealing a chalice
– Kevin Troy
Oct 16 at 14:49
2
2
A perfect illustration of the "Magic Goes Away" trope is from the 1981 film Dragonslayer: Ulrich - "In fact, if it weren't for sorcerers, there wouldn't be any dragons. Once the skies were dotted with them." . . . And later when Ulrich is asked to kill the dragon Vermithrax: "You want me to do battle with that?!" "Who else can we turn to?" "Did you try the Meredydd Sisters? What about Rinbod? I heard tell he killed a dragon once." "They're all dead. You're the only one left." I would have liked to see a prequel where we meet the Meredydd Sisters and Rinbod. :-)
– RobertF
Oct 17 at 15:35
A perfect illustration of the "Magic Goes Away" trope is from the 1981 film Dragonslayer: Ulrich - "In fact, if it weren't for sorcerers, there wouldn't be any dragons. Once the skies were dotted with them." . . . And later when Ulrich is asked to kill the dragon Vermithrax: "You want me to do battle with that?!" "Who else can we turn to?" "Did you try the Meredydd Sisters? What about Rinbod? I heard tell he killed a dragon once." "They're all dead. You're the only one left." I would have liked to see a prequel where we meet the Meredydd Sisters and Rinbod. :-)
– RobertF
Oct 17 at 15:35
|
show 3 more comments
I think this is inspired by real life.
Consider that where I live - the island of Ireland - was once a habitat for elk, wolves, wild cows and many species of deer.
Over the last thousands of years they have been killed off, or couldn't adapt to environmental changes.
The wolves were common in Ireland in the 17th century (see Wolves in Ireland) and my grandfather once dug up a partial antler from Great Irish Elk in a peat bog.
These creatures no longer exist, but occasionally their remains still come to light.
Imagine a farmer some hundreds of years ago finding the skeletal remains of a great Irish Elk
. . . and wondering at the size of it.
For me it's simple extrapolation that people find the remains of large animals, or fossils of them, and see that those animals no longer exist in their area.
Add to that the tall tales, the man who survives a wolf attack, it was never a small wolf, like the fish that got away it's size will grow each time the story is told, until it's the size of the direwolves of old come again.
Fathers, bringing their sons wolf hunting, try to put a bit of heart in the boys by telling them "these wolves you get these days, they're nothing like the wolves we got when I were young, sure my grand father killed a wolf taller than he was with nothing but a stone knife and his own bare hands!"
Also, we all know that our fathers, and their fathers had it harder in their day that we do . . . though they were happier then, even though they were poor
All of these things add to the impression that the world has diminished from how it was in the days of our ancestors.
Further reading of Dragon (Wikipedia) has unearthed (emphasis mine)
Nonetheless, scholars dispute where the idea of a dragon originates
from and a wide variety of theories have been proposed.[8] In his
book An Instinct for Dragons (2000), anthropologist David E. Jones
suggests a hypothesis that humans, just like monkeys, have inherited
instinctive reactions to snakes, large cats, and birds of prey. He
cites a study which found that approximately 39 people in a hundred
are afraid of snakes and notes that fear of snakes is especially
prominent in children, even in areas where snakes are rare. The
earliest attested dragons all resemble snakes or bear snakelike
attributes. Jones therefore concludes that the reason why dragons
appear in nearly all cultures is because of humans' innate fear of
snakes and other animals that were major predators of humans' primate
ancestors. Dragons are usually said to reside in "dank caves, deep
pools, wild mountain reaches, sea bottoms, haunted forests", all
places which would have been fraught with danger for early human
ancestors.
and
In her book The First Fossil Hunters: Dinosaurs, Mammoths, and Myth in
Greek and Roman Times (2000), Adrienne Mayor argues that some stories
of dragons may have been inspired by ancient discoveries of fossils
belonging to dinosaurs and other prehistoric animals.[14] She argues
that the dragon lore of northern India may have been inspired by
"observations of oversized, extraordinary bones in the fossilbeds of
the Siwalik Hills below the Himalayas" and that ancient Greek
artistic depictions of the Monster of Troy may have been influenced by
fossils of Samotherium, an extinct species of giraffe whose fossils
are common in the Mediterranean region. In China, a region where
fossils of large prehistoric animals are common, these remains are
frequently identified as "dragon bones" and are commonly used in
Chinese traditional medicine. Mayor, however, is careful to point
out that not all stories of dragons and giants are inspired by
fossils and notes that Scandinavia has many stories of dragons and
sea monsters, but has long "been considered barren of large fossils
2
I've since corrected that, I had mean "environmental changes", increasing forestation of post ice-age tundra that covered Ireland for many thousands of years is one theory of why the Irish Elk died out. The antlers were the result of sexual selection and they were a hindrance in wooded areas. "Global Warming" has happened before, it's just this time is largely "man made".
– Binary Worrier
Oct 14 at 15:54
20
Also dragons may not have existed, but I'm sure people uncovered fossils of long necked animals, and wondered at them before carving the rock up to upgrade their stone circle. "What's that in the rock Dad?", "Eh . . . it's a dragon son". "Why's it in the rock dad?", "Eh, some wizard turned it to stone, didn't he? Stands to reason when you think about it son. Now, hand me that hammer"
– Binary Worrier
Oct 14 at 15:58
6
I'm going to go with Chinese people finding dinosaur skulls; predating written history.
– Mazura
Oct 14 at 22:28
1
@Fattie: The OP asks "Where did this idea come from? Is it known in any old mythology?", the wikipedia article I link to and quote from, attempts to answer this, but can only guess at the origins and confirms that this trope is Older Than Dirt
– Binary Worrier
Oct 15 at 8:55
5
I agree with the Dinos= Dragons, accidental fossil finds; the same holds for elephant in the Mediterranean (whose skulls without teeth somewhat look like giant cyclops skulls due to the round hole).
– user3445853
Oct 15 at 13:10
|
show 11 more comments
I think this is inspired by real life.
Consider that where I live - the island of Ireland - was once a habitat for elk, wolves, wild cows and many species of deer.
Over the last thousands of years they have been killed off, or couldn't adapt to environmental changes.
The wolves were common in Ireland in the 17th century (see Wolves in Ireland) and my grandfather once dug up a partial antler from Great Irish Elk in a peat bog.
These creatures no longer exist, but occasionally their remains still come to light.
Imagine a farmer some hundreds of years ago finding the skeletal remains of a great Irish Elk
. . . and wondering at the size of it.
For me it's simple extrapolation that people find the remains of large animals, or fossils of them, and see that those animals no longer exist in their area.
Add to that the tall tales, the man who survives a wolf attack, it was never a small wolf, like the fish that got away it's size will grow each time the story is told, until it's the size of the direwolves of old come again.
Fathers, bringing their sons wolf hunting, try to put a bit of heart in the boys by telling them "these wolves you get these days, they're nothing like the wolves we got when I were young, sure my grand father killed a wolf taller than he was with nothing but a stone knife and his own bare hands!"
Also, we all know that our fathers, and their fathers had it harder in their day that we do . . . though they were happier then, even though they were poor
All of these things add to the impression that the world has diminished from how it was in the days of our ancestors.
Further reading of Dragon (Wikipedia) has unearthed (emphasis mine)
Nonetheless, scholars dispute where the idea of a dragon originates
from and a wide variety of theories have been proposed.[8] In his
book An Instinct for Dragons (2000), anthropologist David E. Jones
suggests a hypothesis that humans, just like monkeys, have inherited
instinctive reactions to snakes, large cats, and birds of prey. He
cites a study which found that approximately 39 people in a hundred
are afraid of snakes and notes that fear of snakes is especially
prominent in children, even in areas where snakes are rare. The
earliest attested dragons all resemble snakes or bear snakelike
attributes. Jones therefore concludes that the reason why dragons
appear in nearly all cultures is because of humans' innate fear of
snakes and other animals that were major predators of humans' primate
ancestors. Dragons are usually said to reside in "dank caves, deep
pools, wild mountain reaches, sea bottoms, haunted forests", all
places which would have been fraught with danger for early human
ancestors.
and
In her book The First Fossil Hunters: Dinosaurs, Mammoths, and Myth in
Greek and Roman Times (2000), Adrienne Mayor argues that some stories
of dragons may have been inspired by ancient discoveries of fossils
belonging to dinosaurs and other prehistoric animals.[14] She argues
that the dragon lore of northern India may have been inspired by
"observations of oversized, extraordinary bones in the fossilbeds of
the Siwalik Hills below the Himalayas" and that ancient Greek
artistic depictions of the Monster of Troy may have been influenced by
fossils of Samotherium, an extinct species of giraffe whose fossils
are common in the Mediterranean region. In China, a region where
fossils of large prehistoric animals are common, these remains are
frequently identified as "dragon bones" and are commonly used in
Chinese traditional medicine. Mayor, however, is careful to point
out that not all stories of dragons and giants are inspired by
fossils and notes that Scandinavia has many stories of dragons and
sea monsters, but has long "been considered barren of large fossils
2
I've since corrected that, I had mean "environmental changes", increasing forestation of post ice-age tundra that covered Ireland for many thousands of years is one theory of why the Irish Elk died out. The antlers were the result of sexual selection and they were a hindrance in wooded areas. "Global Warming" has happened before, it's just this time is largely "man made".
– Binary Worrier
Oct 14 at 15:54
20
Also dragons may not have existed, but I'm sure people uncovered fossils of long necked animals, and wondered at them before carving the rock up to upgrade their stone circle. "What's that in the rock Dad?", "Eh . . . it's a dragon son". "Why's it in the rock dad?", "Eh, some wizard turned it to stone, didn't he? Stands to reason when you think about it son. Now, hand me that hammer"
– Binary Worrier
Oct 14 at 15:58
6
I'm going to go with Chinese people finding dinosaur skulls; predating written history.
– Mazura
Oct 14 at 22:28
1
@Fattie: The OP asks "Where did this idea come from? Is it known in any old mythology?", the wikipedia article I link to and quote from, attempts to answer this, but can only guess at the origins and confirms that this trope is Older Than Dirt
– Binary Worrier
Oct 15 at 8:55
5
I agree with the Dinos= Dragons, accidental fossil finds; the same holds for elephant in the Mediterranean (whose skulls without teeth somewhat look like giant cyclops skulls due to the round hole).
– user3445853
Oct 15 at 13:10
|
show 11 more comments
I think this is inspired by real life.
Consider that where I live - the island of Ireland - was once a habitat for elk, wolves, wild cows and many species of deer.
Over the last thousands of years they have been killed off, or couldn't adapt to environmental changes.
The wolves were common in Ireland in the 17th century (see Wolves in Ireland) and my grandfather once dug up a partial antler from Great Irish Elk in a peat bog.
These creatures no longer exist, but occasionally their remains still come to light.
Imagine a farmer some hundreds of years ago finding the skeletal remains of a great Irish Elk
. . . and wondering at the size of it.
For me it's simple extrapolation that people find the remains of large animals, or fossils of them, and see that those animals no longer exist in their area.
Add to that the tall tales, the man who survives a wolf attack, it was never a small wolf, like the fish that got away it's size will grow each time the story is told, until it's the size of the direwolves of old come again.
Fathers, bringing their sons wolf hunting, try to put a bit of heart in the boys by telling them "these wolves you get these days, they're nothing like the wolves we got when I were young, sure my grand father killed a wolf taller than he was with nothing but a stone knife and his own bare hands!"
Also, we all know that our fathers, and their fathers had it harder in their day that we do . . . though they were happier then, even though they were poor
All of these things add to the impression that the world has diminished from how it was in the days of our ancestors.
Further reading of Dragon (Wikipedia) has unearthed (emphasis mine)
Nonetheless, scholars dispute where the idea of a dragon originates
from and a wide variety of theories have been proposed.[8] In his
book An Instinct for Dragons (2000), anthropologist David E. Jones
suggests a hypothesis that humans, just like monkeys, have inherited
instinctive reactions to snakes, large cats, and birds of prey. He
cites a study which found that approximately 39 people in a hundred
are afraid of snakes and notes that fear of snakes is especially
prominent in children, even in areas where snakes are rare. The
earliest attested dragons all resemble snakes or bear snakelike
attributes. Jones therefore concludes that the reason why dragons
appear in nearly all cultures is because of humans' innate fear of
snakes and other animals that were major predators of humans' primate
ancestors. Dragons are usually said to reside in "dank caves, deep
pools, wild mountain reaches, sea bottoms, haunted forests", all
places which would have been fraught with danger for early human
ancestors.
and
In her book The First Fossil Hunters: Dinosaurs, Mammoths, and Myth in
Greek and Roman Times (2000), Adrienne Mayor argues that some stories
of dragons may have been inspired by ancient discoveries of fossils
belonging to dinosaurs and other prehistoric animals.[14] She argues
that the dragon lore of northern India may have been inspired by
"observations of oversized, extraordinary bones in the fossilbeds of
the Siwalik Hills below the Himalayas" and that ancient Greek
artistic depictions of the Monster of Troy may have been influenced by
fossils of Samotherium, an extinct species of giraffe whose fossils
are common in the Mediterranean region. In China, a region where
fossils of large prehistoric animals are common, these remains are
frequently identified as "dragon bones" and are commonly used in
Chinese traditional medicine. Mayor, however, is careful to point
out that not all stories of dragons and giants are inspired by
fossils and notes that Scandinavia has many stories of dragons and
sea monsters, but has long "been considered barren of large fossils
I think this is inspired by real life.
Consider that where I live - the island of Ireland - was once a habitat for elk, wolves, wild cows and many species of deer.
Over the last thousands of years they have been killed off, or couldn't adapt to environmental changes.
The wolves were common in Ireland in the 17th century (see Wolves in Ireland) and my grandfather once dug up a partial antler from Great Irish Elk in a peat bog.
These creatures no longer exist, but occasionally their remains still come to light.
Imagine a farmer some hundreds of years ago finding the skeletal remains of a great Irish Elk
. . . and wondering at the size of it.
For me it's simple extrapolation that people find the remains of large animals, or fossils of them, and see that those animals no longer exist in their area.
Add to that the tall tales, the man who survives a wolf attack, it was never a small wolf, like the fish that got away it's size will grow each time the story is told, until it's the size of the direwolves of old come again.
Fathers, bringing their sons wolf hunting, try to put a bit of heart in the boys by telling them "these wolves you get these days, they're nothing like the wolves we got when I were young, sure my grand father killed a wolf taller than he was with nothing but a stone knife and his own bare hands!"
Also, we all know that our fathers, and their fathers had it harder in their day that we do . . . though they were happier then, even though they were poor
All of these things add to the impression that the world has diminished from how it was in the days of our ancestors.
Further reading of Dragon (Wikipedia) has unearthed (emphasis mine)
Nonetheless, scholars dispute where the idea of a dragon originates
from and a wide variety of theories have been proposed.[8] In his
book An Instinct for Dragons (2000), anthropologist David E. Jones
suggests a hypothesis that humans, just like monkeys, have inherited
instinctive reactions to snakes, large cats, and birds of prey. He
cites a study which found that approximately 39 people in a hundred
are afraid of snakes and notes that fear of snakes is especially
prominent in children, even in areas where snakes are rare. The
earliest attested dragons all resemble snakes or bear snakelike
attributes. Jones therefore concludes that the reason why dragons
appear in nearly all cultures is because of humans' innate fear of
snakes and other animals that were major predators of humans' primate
ancestors. Dragons are usually said to reside in "dank caves, deep
pools, wild mountain reaches, sea bottoms, haunted forests", all
places which would have been fraught with danger for early human
ancestors.
and
In her book The First Fossil Hunters: Dinosaurs, Mammoths, and Myth in
Greek and Roman Times (2000), Adrienne Mayor argues that some stories
of dragons may have been inspired by ancient discoveries of fossils
belonging to dinosaurs and other prehistoric animals.[14] She argues
that the dragon lore of northern India may have been inspired by
"observations of oversized, extraordinary bones in the fossilbeds of
the Siwalik Hills below the Himalayas" and that ancient Greek
artistic depictions of the Monster of Troy may have been influenced by
fossils of Samotherium, an extinct species of giraffe whose fossils
are common in the Mediterranean region. In China, a region where
fossils of large prehistoric animals are common, these remains are
frequently identified as "dragon bones" and are commonly used in
Chinese traditional medicine. Mayor, however, is careful to point
out that not all stories of dragons and giants are inspired by
fossils and notes that Scandinavia has many stories of dragons and
sea monsters, but has long "been considered barren of large fossils
edited Oct 15 at 8:50
answered Oct 14 at 15:47
Binary WorrierBinary Worrier
10.4k4 gold badges45 silver badges59 bronze badges
10.4k4 gold badges45 silver badges59 bronze badges
2
I've since corrected that, I had mean "environmental changes", increasing forestation of post ice-age tundra that covered Ireland for many thousands of years is one theory of why the Irish Elk died out. The antlers were the result of sexual selection and they were a hindrance in wooded areas. "Global Warming" has happened before, it's just this time is largely "man made".
– Binary Worrier
Oct 14 at 15:54
20
Also dragons may not have existed, but I'm sure people uncovered fossils of long necked animals, and wondered at them before carving the rock up to upgrade their stone circle. "What's that in the rock Dad?", "Eh . . . it's a dragon son". "Why's it in the rock dad?", "Eh, some wizard turned it to stone, didn't he? Stands to reason when you think about it son. Now, hand me that hammer"
– Binary Worrier
Oct 14 at 15:58
6
I'm going to go with Chinese people finding dinosaur skulls; predating written history.
– Mazura
Oct 14 at 22:28
1
@Fattie: The OP asks "Where did this idea come from? Is it known in any old mythology?", the wikipedia article I link to and quote from, attempts to answer this, but can only guess at the origins and confirms that this trope is Older Than Dirt
– Binary Worrier
Oct 15 at 8:55
5
I agree with the Dinos= Dragons, accidental fossil finds; the same holds for elephant in the Mediterranean (whose skulls without teeth somewhat look like giant cyclops skulls due to the round hole).
– user3445853
Oct 15 at 13:10
|
show 11 more comments
2
I've since corrected that, I had mean "environmental changes", increasing forestation of post ice-age tundra that covered Ireland for many thousands of years is one theory of why the Irish Elk died out. The antlers were the result of sexual selection and they were a hindrance in wooded areas. "Global Warming" has happened before, it's just this time is largely "man made".
– Binary Worrier
Oct 14 at 15:54
20
Also dragons may not have existed, but I'm sure people uncovered fossils of long necked animals, and wondered at them before carving the rock up to upgrade their stone circle. "What's that in the rock Dad?", "Eh . . . it's a dragon son". "Why's it in the rock dad?", "Eh, some wizard turned it to stone, didn't he? Stands to reason when you think about it son. Now, hand me that hammer"
– Binary Worrier
Oct 14 at 15:58
6
I'm going to go with Chinese people finding dinosaur skulls; predating written history.
– Mazura
Oct 14 at 22:28
1
@Fattie: The OP asks "Where did this idea come from? Is it known in any old mythology?", the wikipedia article I link to and quote from, attempts to answer this, but can only guess at the origins and confirms that this trope is Older Than Dirt
– Binary Worrier
Oct 15 at 8:55
5
I agree with the Dinos= Dragons, accidental fossil finds; the same holds for elephant in the Mediterranean (whose skulls without teeth somewhat look like giant cyclops skulls due to the round hole).
– user3445853
Oct 15 at 13:10
2
2
I've since corrected that, I had mean "environmental changes", increasing forestation of post ice-age tundra that covered Ireland for many thousands of years is one theory of why the Irish Elk died out. The antlers were the result of sexual selection and they were a hindrance in wooded areas. "Global Warming" has happened before, it's just this time is largely "man made".
– Binary Worrier
Oct 14 at 15:54
I've since corrected that, I had mean "environmental changes", increasing forestation of post ice-age tundra that covered Ireland for many thousands of years is one theory of why the Irish Elk died out. The antlers were the result of sexual selection and they were a hindrance in wooded areas. "Global Warming" has happened before, it's just this time is largely "man made".
– Binary Worrier
Oct 14 at 15:54
20
20
Also dragons may not have existed, but I'm sure people uncovered fossils of long necked animals, and wondered at them before carving the rock up to upgrade their stone circle. "What's that in the rock Dad?", "Eh . . . it's a dragon son". "Why's it in the rock dad?", "Eh, some wizard turned it to stone, didn't he? Stands to reason when you think about it son. Now, hand me that hammer"
– Binary Worrier
Oct 14 at 15:58
Also dragons may not have existed, but I'm sure people uncovered fossils of long necked animals, and wondered at them before carving the rock up to upgrade their stone circle. "What's that in the rock Dad?", "Eh . . . it's a dragon son". "Why's it in the rock dad?", "Eh, some wizard turned it to stone, didn't he? Stands to reason when you think about it son. Now, hand me that hammer"
– Binary Worrier
Oct 14 at 15:58
6
6
I'm going to go with Chinese people finding dinosaur skulls; predating written history.
– Mazura
Oct 14 at 22:28
I'm going to go with Chinese people finding dinosaur skulls; predating written history.
– Mazura
Oct 14 at 22:28
1
1
@Fattie: The OP asks "Where did this idea come from? Is it known in any old mythology?", the wikipedia article I link to and quote from, attempts to answer this, but can only guess at the origins and confirms that this trope is Older Than Dirt
– Binary Worrier
Oct 15 at 8:55
@Fattie: The OP asks "Where did this idea come from? Is it known in any old mythology?", the wikipedia article I link to and quote from, attempts to answer this, but can only guess at the origins and confirms that this trope is Older Than Dirt
– Binary Worrier
Oct 15 at 8:55
5
5
I agree with the Dinos= Dragons, accidental fossil finds; the same holds for elephant in the Mediterranean (whose skulls without teeth somewhat look like giant cyclops skulls due to the round hole).
– user3445853
Oct 15 at 13:10
I agree with the Dinos= Dragons, accidental fossil finds; the same holds for elephant in the Mediterranean (whose skulls without teeth somewhat look like giant cyclops skulls due to the round hole).
– user3445853
Oct 15 at 13:10
|
show 11 more comments
Dinosaur bones.
No, really. Do you really think we were the first to unearth dinosaur bones and wonder WTF they were? Of course not. When your culture unearths the bones of several gigantic reptile-things and you only have hearsay of anything like that existing today, it's difficult not to make the assumption that these things were once plentiful and are either extinct or in very short supply.
3
Our ancestors didn't actually see dragons, but they saw these giant bones. Ergo, dragons were once plentiful but not anymore.
– RonJohn
Oct 16 at 21:26
3
dragons were once plentiful
And, in a sense, they were :). It's just that "once" was ... millions of years ago, and they didn't look quite like we picture them now.
– Reinstate Monica --Brondahl--
Oct 17 at 12:43
add a comment
|
Dinosaur bones.
No, really. Do you really think we were the first to unearth dinosaur bones and wonder WTF they were? Of course not. When your culture unearths the bones of several gigantic reptile-things and you only have hearsay of anything like that existing today, it's difficult not to make the assumption that these things were once plentiful and are either extinct or in very short supply.
3
Our ancestors didn't actually see dragons, but they saw these giant bones. Ergo, dragons were once plentiful but not anymore.
– RonJohn
Oct 16 at 21:26
3
dragons were once plentiful
And, in a sense, they were :). It's just that "once" was ... millions of years ago, and they didn't look quite like we picture them now.
– Reinstate Monica --Brondahl--
Oct 17 at 12:43
add a comment
|
Dinosaur bones.
No, really. Do you really think we were the first to unearth dinosaur bones and wonder WTF they were? Of course not. When your culture unearths the bones of several gigantic reptile-things and you only have hearsay of anything like that existing today, it's difficult not to make the assumption that these things were once plentiful and are either extinct or in very short supply.
Dinosaur bones.
No, really. Do you really think we were the first to unearth dinosaur bones and wonder WTF they were? Of course not. When your culture unearths the bones of several gigantic reptile-things and you only have hearsay of anything like that existing today, it's difficult not to make the assumption that these things were once plentiful and are either extinct or in very short supply.
answered Oct 15 at 14:36
CarduusCarduus
3211 silver badge6 bronze badges
3211 silver badge6 bronze badges
3
Our ancestors didn't actually see dragons, but they saw these giant bones. Ergo, dragons were once plentiful but not anymore.
– RonJohn
Oct 16 at 21:26
3
dragons were once plentiful
And, in a sense, they were :). It's just that "once" was ... millions of years ago, and they didn't look quite like we picture them now.
– Reinstate Monica --Brondahl--
Oct 17 at 12:43
add a comment
|
3
Our ancestors didn't actually see dragons, but they saw these giant bones. Ergo, dragons were once plentiful but not anymore.
– RonJohn
Oct 16 at 21:26
3
dragons were once plentiful
And, in a sense, they were :). It's just that "once" was ... millions of years ago, and they didn't look quite like we picture them now.
– Reinstate Monica --Brondahl--
Oct 17 at 12:43
3
3
Our ancestors didn't actually see dragons, but they saw these giant bones. Ergo, dragons were once plentiful but not anymore.
– RonJohn
Oct 16 at 21:26
Our ancestors didn't actually see dragons, but they saw these giant bones. Ergo, dragons were once plentiful but not anymore.
– RonJohn
Oct 16 at 21:26
3
3
dragons were once plentiful
And, in a sense, they were :). It's just that "once" was ... millions of years ago, and they didn't look quite like we picture them now.– Reinstate Monica --Brondahl--
Oct 17 at 12:43
dragons were once plentiful
And, in a sense, they were :). It's just that "once" was ... millions of years ago, and they didn't look quite like we picture them now.– Reinstate Monica --Brondahl--
Oct 17 at 12:43
add a comment
|
To add a venerable precedent, in Jonathan Swift's Gulliver's Travels he arrives in Brobdingnag, land of giants. Those giants are convinced that they are the degenerated (in the physical sense) descendants of even bigger giants (of which they have found the bones1), and Gulliver speculates that men may be in turn the degenerated descendants of the inhabitants of Brobdingnag.
1And the reference to bones links to Carduus' observation that way before the theory of evolution was established the people realized that really big beings lived on Earth.
I was wondering about a Gulliver's Travels connection (but no dragons there that I recall). It's another example of the broader version though
– Chris H
Oct 17 at 20:39
1
@ChrisH no, no dragons in Gulliver, but given how old the book is I thought it was worth mentioning the similar theme.
– SJuan76
Oct 17 at 20:41
add a comment
|
To add a venerable precedent, in Jonathan Swift's Gulliver's Travels he arrives in Brobdingnag, land of giants. Those giants are convinced that they are the degenerated (in the physical sense) descendants of even bigger giants (of which they have found the bones1), and Gulliver speculates that men may be in turn the degenerated descendants of the inhabitants of Brobdingnag.
1And the reference to bones links to Carduus' observation that way before the theory of evolution was established the people realized that really big beings lived on Earth.
I was wondering about a Gulliver's Travels connection (but no dragons there that I recall). It's another example of the broader version though
– Chris H
Oct 17 at 20:39
1
@ChrisH no, no dragons in Gulliver, but given how old the book is I thought it was worth mentioning the similar theme.
– SJuan76
Oct 17 at 20:41
add a comment
|
To add a venerable precedent, in Jonathan Swift's Gulliver's Travels he arrives in Brobdingnag, land of giants. Those giants are convinced that they are the degenerated (in the physical sense) descendants of even bigger giants (of which they have found the bones1), and Gulliver speculates that men may be in turn the degenerated descendants of the inhabitants of Brobdingnag.
1And the reference to bones links to Carduus' observation that way before the theory of evolution was established the people realized that really big beings lived on Earth.
To add a venerable precedent, in Jonathan Swift's Gulliver's Travels he arrives in Brobdingnag, land of giants. Those giants are convinced that they are the degenerated (in the physical sense) descendants of even bigger giants (of which they have found the bones1), and Gulliver speculates that men may be in turn the degenerated descendants of the inhabitants of Brobdingnag.
1And the reference to bones links to Carduus' observation that way before the theory of evolution was established the people realized that really big beings lived on Earth.
edited Oct 17 at 20:52
DavidW
16.3k8 gold badges77 silver badges115 bronze badges
16.3k8 gold badges77 silver badges115 bronze badges
answered Oct 17 at 20:36
SJuan76SJuan76
4,4761 gold badge17 silver badges36 bronze badges
4,4761 gold badge17 silver badges36 bronze badges
I was wondering about a Gulliver's Travels connection (but no dragons there that I recall). It's another example of the broader version though
– Chris H
Oct 17 at 20:39
1
@ChrisH no, no dragons in Gulliver, but given how old the book is I thought it was worth mentioning the similar theme.
– SJuan76
Oct 17 at 20:41
add a comment
|
I was wondering about a Gulliver's Travels connection (but no dragons there that I recall). It's another example of the broader version though
– Chris H
Oct 17 at 20:39
1
@ChrisH no, no dragons in Gulliver, but given how old the book is I thought it was worth mentioning the similar theme.
– SJuan76
Oct 17 at 20:41
I was wondering about a Gulliver's Travels connection (but no dragons there that I recall). It's another example of the broader version though
– Chris H
Oct 17 at 20:39
I was wondering about a Gulliver's Travels connection (but no dragons there that I recall). It's another example of the broader version though
– Chris H
Oct 17 at 20:39
1
1
@ChrisH no, no dragons in Gulliver, but given how old the book is I thought it was worth mentioning the similar theme.
– SJuan76
Oct 17 at 20:41
@ChrisH no, no dragons in Gulliver, but given how old the book is I thought it was worth mentioning the similar theme.
– SJuan76
Oct 17 at 20:41
add a comment
|
Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f221552%2fwhats-the-origin-of-the-trope-that-dragons-used-to-be-common-but-arent-any-mor%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown