Is there a practical difference between different types of Berachos?Berakhos recited over food - Mitzvah or Matir?What's the difference between LaZman and LeZman?Meaning and Difference between baruch and bar'chuDifference between leaving place of eating and place of smelling besamimWhat is the difference between (for example) “notein” and “hanotein”?What is the difference between חרמין וההקדשותUnderstanding the difference between shevus and gezeirahDifference between books called “Shulchan Aruch”What is the difference between these two brachot?Difference Between Brit and Medical CircumcisionDifference between Chabad mikvaos and other mikvaos?
How can a single Member of the House block a Congressional bill?
Is it grammatical to use "car" like this?
Beginner's snake game using PyGame
How to detach yourself from a character you're going to kill?
Opposite of "Squeaky wheel gets the grease"
What is the correct expression of 10/20, 20/30, 30/40 etc?
What if you don't bring your credit card or debit for incidentals?
How can I add depth to my story or how do I determine if my story already has depth?
What is the right way to float a home lab?
Can an old DSLR be upgraded to match modern smartphone image quality
Is there a term for this?
Does any lore text explain why the planes of Acheron, Gehenna, and Carceri are the alignment they are?
Pros and cons of writing a book review?
Is it possible for people to live in the eye of a permanent hypercane?
Computing the differentials in the Adams spectral sequence
How can Iron Man's suit withstand this?
Access to all elements on the page
California: "For quality assurance, this phone call is being recorded"
Unconventional Opposites
Concise way to draw this pyramid
Can commodity 3d printer extrusion hardware and filament be used for injection molding?
Strange math syntax in old basic listing
Why use water tanks from a retired Space Shuttle?
Is the capacitor drawn or wired wrongly?
Is there a practical difference between different types of Berachos?
Berakhos recited over food - Mitzvah or Matir?What's the difference between LaZman and LeZman?Meaning and Difference between baruch and bar'chuDifference between leaving place of eating and place of smelling besamimWhat is the difference between (for example) “notein” and “hanotein”?What is the difference between חרמין וההקדשותUnderstanding the difference between shevus and gezeirahDifference between books called “Shulchan Aruch”What is the difference between these two brachot?Difference Between Brit and Medical CircumcisionDifference between Chabad mikvaos and other mikvaos?
Berachos tend to be grouped into different categories, as Berachos on pleasure (ברכות הנהנין), on Mitzvos (ברכות המצות), on events (ברכות ראיה ושמיעה), etc.
As far as I’m aware, the general halachos of these types of Berachos are the same across all categories; for instance, they all are said in response to certain triggers, whether that trigger is eating something, hearing some type of news, discharging an obligation, or something else.
Are there any halachos unique to one type of Beracha which don’t apply to the others?
halacha blessing
asked 8 hours ago
DonielFDonielF
18.6k12895
|
show 7 more comments
Berachos tend to be grouped into different categories, as Berachos on pleasure (ברכות הנהנין), on Mitzvos (ברכות המצות), on events (ברכות ראיה ושמיעה), etc.
As far as I’m aware, the general halachos of these types of Berachos are the same across all categories; for instance, they all are said in response to certain triggers, whether that trigger is eating something, hearing some type of news, discharging an obligation, or something else.
Are there any halachos unique to one type of Beracha which don’t apply to the others?
halacha blessing
asked 8 hours ago
DonielFDonielF
18.6k12895
1
Birkas Illanoys is said only on Nissan? Birkas Hagomel is said in Minyan? Some are said once in 30 days?
– Al Berko
8 hours ago
I don't think the Q reflects the title. And what Halochos you refer to?
– Al Berko
8 hours ago
@AlBerko Birchas Ilanos is a specific application of the general rule that Berachos are said in response to a prompt. Hagomel is indeed only said in a minyan, but that’s not a rule of general categories of Berachos; Hagomel would be a Birchas Hoda’ah, which generally do not have to be said in a minyan.
– DonielF
8 hours ago
If so the question is undecipherable for me.
– Al Berko
8 hours ago
@AlBerko Why don’t you think the Q reflects the title? I’m asking for a practical difference between Beracha categories - do any categories have unique halachos? I’m referring to, I dunno, any Halacha which applies to a category as a whole. When it’s said (if there’s a category which can be said whenever whyever), how it’s said, etc. If I knew what specific Halacha was different, I wouldn’t be asking this question.
– DonielF
8 hours ago
|
show 7 more comments
Berachos tend to be grouped into different categories, as Berachos on pleasure (ברכות הנהנין), on Mitzvos (ברכות המצות), on events (ברכות ראיה ושמיעה), etc.
As far as I’m aware, the general halachos of these types of Berachos are the same across all categories; for instance, they all are said in response to certain triggers, whether that trigger is eating something, hearing some type of news, discharging an obligation, or something else.
Are there any halachos unique to one type of Beracha which don’t apply to the others?
halacha blessing
asked 8 hours ago
DonielFDonielF
18.6k12895
Berachos tend to be grouped into different categories, as Berachos on pleasure (ברכות הנהנין), on Mitzvos (ברכות המצות), on events (ברכות ראיה ושמיעה), etc.
As far as I’m aware, the general halachos of these types of Berachos are the same across all categories; for instance, they all are said in response to certain triggers, whether that trigger is eating something, hearing some type of news, discharging an obligation, or something else.
Are there any halachos unique to one type of Beracha which don’t apply to the others?
halacha blessing
halacha blessing
asked 8 hours ago
DonielFDonielF
18.6k12895
asked 8 hours ago
DonielFDonielF
18.6k12895
asked 8 hours ago
DonielFDonielF
18.6k12895
asked 8 hours ago
DonielFDonielF
18.6k12895
asked 8 hours ago
DonielFDonielF
18.6k12895
18.6k12895
1
Birkas Illanoys is said only on Nissan? Birkas Hagomel is said in Minyan? Some are said once in 30 days?
– Al Berko
8 hours ago
I don't think the Q reflects the title. And what Halochos you refer to?
– Al Berko
8 hours ago
@AlBerko Birchas Ilanos is a specific application of the general rule that Berachos are said in response to a prompt. Hagomel is indeed only said in a minyan, but that’s not a rule of general categories of Berachos; Hagomel would be a Birchas Hoda’ah, which generally do not have to be said in a minyan.
– DonielF
8 hours ago
If so the question is undecipherable for me.
– Al Berko
8 hours ago
@AlBerko Why don’t you think the Q reflects the title? I’m asking for a practical difference between Beracha categories - do any categories have unique halachos? I’m referring to, I dunno, any Halacha which applies to a category as a whole. When it’s said (if there’s a category which can be said whenever whyever), how it’s said, etc. If I knew what specific Halacha was different, I wouldn’t be asking this question.
– DonielF
8 hours ago
|
show 7 more comments
1
Birkas Illanoys is said only on Nissan? Birkas Hagomel is said in Minyan? Some are said once in 30 days?
– Al Berko
8 hours ago
I don't think the Q reflects the title. And what Halochos you refer to?
– Al Berko
8 hours ago
@AlBerko Birchas Ilanos is a specific application of the general rule that Berachos are said in response to a prompt. Hagomel is indeed only said in a minyan, but that’s not a rule of general categories of Berachos; Hagomel would be a Birchas Hoda’ah, which generally do not have to be said in a minyan.
– DonielF
8 hours ago
If so the question is undecipherable for me.
– Al Berko
8 hours ago
@AlBerko Why don’t you think the Q reflects the title? I’m asking for a practical difference between Beracha categories - do any categories have unique halachos? I’m referring to, I dunno, any Halacha which applies to a category as a whole. When it’s said (if there’s a category which can be said whenever whyever), how it’s said, etc. If I knew what specific Halacha was different, I wouldn’t be asking this question.
– DonielF
8 hours ago
1
1
Birkas Illanoys is said only on Nissan? Birkas Hagomel is said in Minyan? Some are said once in 30 days?
– Al Berko
8 hours ago
Birkas Illanoys is said only on Nissan? Birkas Hagomel is said in Minyan? Some are said once in 30 days?
– Al Berko
8 hours ago
I don't think the Q reflects the title. And what Halochos you refer to?
– Al Berko
8 hours ago
I don't think the Q reflects the title. And what Halochos you refer to?
– Al Berko
8 hours ago
@AlBerko Birchas Ilanos is a specific application of the general rule that Berachos are said in response to a prompt. Hagomel is indeed only said in a minyan, but that’s not a rule of general categories of Berachos; Hagomel would be a Birchas Hoda’ah, which generally do not have to be said in a minyan.
– DonielF
8 hours ago
@AlBerko Birchas Ilanos is a specific application of the general rule that Berachos are said in response to a prompt. Hagomel is indeed only said in a minyan, but that’s not a rule of general categories of Berachos; Hagomel would be a Birchas Hoda’ah, which generally do not have to be said in a minyan.
– DonielF
8 hours ago
If so the question is undecipherable for me.
– Al Berko
8 hours ago
If so the question is undecipherable for me.
– Al Berko
8 hours ago
@AlBerko Why don’t you think the Q reflects the title? I’m asking for a practical difference between Beracha categories - do any categories have unique halachos? I’m referring to, I dunno, any Halacha which applies to a category as a whole. When it’s said (if there’s a category which can be said whenever whyever), how it’s said, etc. If I knew what specific Halacha was different, I wouldn’t be asking this question.
– DonielF
8 hours ago
@AlBerko Why don’t you think the Q reflects the title? I’m asking for a practical difference between Beracha categories - do any categories have unique halachos? I’m referring to, I dunno, any Halacha which applies to a category as a whole. When it’s said (if there’s a category which can be said whenever whyever), how it’s said, etc. If I knew what specific Halacha was different, I wouldn’t be asking this question.
– DonielF
8 hours ago
|
show 7 more comments
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
The law that כל הברכות מברכין עובר לעשייתן - that one must bless
before performing a mitzva - does not apply by Birchas Hareach
uReiyah (and according to most opinions is unique to Birchas
HaMitzvos; the reason Birchas Hanehenin must precede the
consumption is because אסור להנות מעולם הזה בלא ברכה).According to some opinions, one must stand for Birchas HaMitzvos
(see ארחות חיים (הל' ציצית סי' כז - כח), Rosh (Pesachim, Ch. 10 §41),
Magen Avraham §8.2); we do not see this law by other Brachos.According to some Rishonim (although we may not pasken like that),
the rule of ספק ברכות להקל (to avoid making brachos when in doubt)
applies only to Birchas HaMitzvos, not other brachos (See Tosfos
Brachos 12a, with Gilyon Hashas of R' Akiva Eiger).The law of arvus (אף על פי שיצא, מוציא) is primarily by Birchas Hamitzvos, not by the other categories of Brochos.
answered 7 hours ago
chortkov2chortkov2
1,995124
Notably, pretty much all these rules have exceptions. Categories are only as useful as their exceptions after all.
– Double AA♦
7 hours ago
See judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/15018/… - Birchas Hanehenin may be a mattir; Birchas Hamitzvos are not. There are numerous ramifications.
– chortkov2
7 hours ago
add a comment |
One difference is that berachas on events are said after the fact (We say the beracha on thunder after we hear the thunder, on lightning after the lightning, Hagomel after being saved, etc).
Berachas on mitzvos are almost always said before the fact-מברכים עובר לעשייתן (b’racha on hallel, Lulav, shofar, Megillah, etc).
And berachas on pleasure are said before and after the fact (b’racha rishonah, b’racha achrona etc).
edited 7 hours ago
Double AA♦
80.1k6200438
answered 7 hours ago
Lo aniLo ani
979214
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
The law that כל הברכות מברכין עובר לעשייתן - that one must bless
before performing a mitzva - does not apply by Birchas Hareach
uReiyah (and according to most opinions is unique to Birchas
HaMitzvos; the reason Birchas Hanehenin must precede the
consumption is because אסור להנות מעולם הזה בלא ברכה).According to some opinions, one must stand for Birchas HaMitzvos
(see ארחות חיים (הל' ציצית סי' כז - כח), Rosh (Pesachim, Ch. 10 §41),
Magen Avraham §8.2); we do not see this law by other Brachos.According to some Rishonim (although we may not pasken like that),
the rule of ספק ברכות להקל (to avoid making brachos when in doubt)
applies only to Birchas HaMitzvos, not other brachos (See Tosfos
Brachos 12a, with Gilyon Hashas of R' Akiva Eiger).The law of arvus (אף על פי שיצא, מוציא) is primarily by Birchas Hamitzvos, not by the other categories of Brochos.
answered 7 hours ago
chortkov2chortkov2
1,995124
Notably, pretty much all these rules have exceptions. Categories are only as useful as their exceptions after all.
– Double AA♦
7 hours ago
See judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/15018/… - Birchas Hanehenin may be a mattir; Birchas Hamitzvos are not. There are numerous ramifications.
– chortkov2
7 hours ago
add a comment |
The law that כל הברכות מברכין עובר לעשייתן - that one must bless
before performing a mitzva - does not apply by Birchas Hareach
uReiyah (and according to most opinions is unique to Birchas
HaMitzvos; the reason Birchas Hanehenin must precede the
consumption is because אסור להנות מעולם הזה בלא ברכה).According to some opinions, one must stand for Birchas HaMitzvos
(see ארחות חיים (הל' ציצית סי' כז - כח), Rosh (Pesachim, Ch. 10 §41),
Magen Avraham §8.2); we do not see this law by other Brachos.According to some Rishonim (although we may not pasken like that),
the rule of ספק ברכות להקל (to avoid making brachos when in doubt)
applies only to Birchas HaMitzvos, not other brachos (See Tosfos
Brachos 12a, with Gilyon Hashas of R' Akiva Eiger).The law of arvus (אף על פי שיצא, מוציא) is primarily by Birchas Hamitzvos, not by the other categories of Brochos.
answered 7 hours ago
chortkov2chortkov2
1,995124
Notably, pretty much all these rules have exceptions. Categories are only as useful as their exceptions after all.
– Double AA♦
7 hours ago
See judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/15018/… - Birchas Hanehenin may be a mattir; Birchas Hamitzvos are not. There are numerous ramifications.
– chortkov2
7 hours ago
add a comment |
The law that כל הברכות מברכין עובר לעשייתן - that one must bless
before performing a mitzva - does not apply by Birchas Hareach
uReiyah (and according to most opinions is unique to Birchas
HaMitzvos; the reason Birchas Hanehenin must precede the
consumption is because אסור להנות מעולם הזה בלא ברכה).According to some opinions, one must stand for Birchas HaMitzvos
(see ארחות חיים (הל' ציצית סי' כז - כח), Rosh (Pesachim, Ch. 10 §41),
Magen Avraham §8.2); we do not see this law by other Brachos.According to some Rishonim (although we may not pasken like that),
the rule of ספק ברכות להקל (to avoid making brachos when in doubt)
applies only to Birchas HaMitzvos, not other brachos (See Tosfos
Brachos 12a, with Gilyon Hashas of R' Akiva Eiger).The law of arvus (אף על פי שיצא, מוציא) is primarily by Birchas Hamitzvos, not by the other categories of Brochos.
answered 7 hours ago
chortkov2chortkov2
1,995124
The law that כל הברכות מברכין עובר לעשייתן - that one must bless
before performing a mitzva - does not apply by Birchas Hareach
uReiyah (and according to most opinions is unique to Birchas
HaMitzvos; the reason Birchas Hanehenin must precede the
consumption is because אסור להנות מעולם הזה בלא ברכה).According to some opinions, one must stand for Birchas HaMitzvos
(see ארחות חיים (הל' ציצית סי' כז - כח), Rosh (Pesachim, Ch. 10 §41),
Magen Avraham §8.2); we do not see this law by other Brachos.According to some Rishonim (although we may not pasken like that),
the rule of ספק ברכות להקל (to avoid making brachos when in doubt)
applies only to Birchas HaMitzvos, not other brachos (See Tosfos
Brachos 12a, with Gilyon Hashas of R' Akiva Eiger).The law of arvus (אף על פי שיצא, מוציא) is primarily by Birchas Hamitzvos, not by the other categories of Brochos.
answered 7 hours ago
chortkov2chortkov2
1,995124
answered 7 hours ago
chortkov2chortkov2
1,995124
answered 7 hours ago
chortkov2chortkov2
1,995124
answered 7 hours ago
chortkov2chortkov2
1,995124
1,995124
Notably, pretty much all these rules have exceptions. Categories are only as useful as their exceptions after all.
– Double AA♦
7 hours ago
See judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/15018/… - Birchas Hanehenin may be a mattir; Birchas Hamitzvos are not. There are numerous ramifications.
– chortkov2
7 hours ago
add a comment |
Notably, pretty much all these rules have exceptions. Categories are only as useful as their exceptions after all.
– Double AA♦
7 hours ago
See judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/15018/… - Birchas Hanehenin may be a mattir; Birchas Hamitzvos are not. There are numerous ramifications.
– chortkov2
7 hours ago
Notably, pretty much all these rules have exceptions. Categories are only as useful as their exceptions after all.
– Double AA♦
7 hours ago
Notably, pretty much all these rules have exceptions. Categories are only as useful as their exceptions after all.
– Double AA♦
7 hours ago
See judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/15018/… - Birchas Hanehenin may be a mattir; Birchas Hamitzvos are not. There are numerous ramifications.
– chortkov2
7 hours ago
See judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/15018/… - Birchas Hanehenin may be a mattir; Birchas Hamitzvos are not. There are numerous ramifications.
– chortkov2
7 hours ago
add a comment |
One difference is that berachas on events are said after the fact (We say the beracha on thunder after we hear the thunder, on lightning after the lightning, Hagomel after being saved, etc).
Berachas on mitzvos are almost always said before the fact-מברכים עובר לעשייתן (b’racha on hallel, Lulav, shofar, Megillah, etc).
And berachas on pleasure are said before and after the fact (b’racha rishonah, b’racha achrona etc).
edited 7 hours ago
Double AA♦
80.1k6200438
answered 7 hours ago
Lo aniLo ani
979214
add a comment |
One difference is that berachas on events are said after the fact (We say the beracha on thunder after we hear the thunder, on lightning after the lightning, Hagomel after being saved, etc).
Berachas on mitzvos are almost always said before the fact-מברכים עובר לעשייתן (b’racha on hallel, Lulav, shofar, Megillah, etc).
And berachas on pleasure are said before and after the fact (b’racha rishonah, b’racha achrona etc).
edited 7 hours ago
Double AA♦
80.1k6200438
answered 7 hours ago
Lo aniLo ani
979214
add a comment |
One difference is that berachas on events are said after the fact (We say the beracha on thunder after we hear the thunder, on lightning after the lightning, Hagomel after being saved, etc).
Berachas on mitzvos are almost always said before the fact-מברכים עובר לעשייתן (b’racha on hallel, Lulav, shofar, Megillah, etc).
And berachas on pleasure are said before and after the fact (b’racha rishonah, b’racha achrona etc).
edited 7 hours ago
Double AA♦
80.1k6200438
answered 7 hours ago
Lo aniLo ani
979214
One difference is that berachas on events are said after the fact (We say the beracha on thunder after we hear the thunder, on lightning after the lightning, Hagomel after being saved, etc).
Berachas on mitzvos are almost always said before the fact-מברכים עובר לעשייתן (b’racha on hallel, Lulav, shofar, Megillah, etc).
And berachas on pleasure are said before and after the fact (b’racha rishonah, b’racha achrona etc).
edited 7 hours ago
Double AA♦
80.1k6200438
answered 7 hours ago
Lo aniLo ani
979214
edited 7 hours ago
Double AA♦
80.1k6200438
edited 7 hours ago
Double AA♦
80.1k6200438
edited 7 hours ago
Double AA♦
80.1k6200438
80.1k6200438
answered 7 hours ago
Lo aniLo ani
979214
answered 7 hours ago
Lo aniLo ani
979214
answered 7 hours ago
Lo aniLo ani
979214
979214
add a comment |
add a comment |
1
Birkas Illanoys is said only on Nissan? Birkas Hagomel is said in Minyan? Some are said once in 30 days?
– Al Berko
8 hours ago
I don't think the Q reflects the title. And what Halochos you refer to?
– Al Berko
8 hours ago
@AlBerko Birchas Ilanos is a specific application of the general rule that Berachos are said in response to a prompt. Hagomel is indeed only said in a minyan, but that’s not a rule of general categories of Berachos; Hagomel would be a Birchas Hoda’ah, which generally do not have to be said in a minyan.
– DonielF
8 hours ago
If so the question is undecipherable for me.
– Al Berko
8 hours ago
@AlBerko Why don’t you think the Q reflects the title? I’m asking for a practical difference between Beracha categories - do any categories have unique halachos? I’m referring to, I dunno, any Halacha which applies to a category as a whole. When it’s said (if there’s a category which can be said whenever whyever), how it’s said, etc. If I knew what specific Halacha was different, I wouldn’t be asking this question.
– DonielF
8 hours ago